Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
In less than a year Labour has walked away from several elements of its "Fully Costed" Manifesto pledges. This is the latest event. The Manifesto foresaw Welfare Cuts of £3bn, Liz Kendall knows the real deal is likely to be more like £5bn, but the assorted social workers, community activists, minority rights campaigners and never-had-a-proper-job-at-all types who populate the Labour bankbenches have no stomach for doing what's right over what's popular.
In this respect they're no different from the last lot. You cannot get a Rizla between Labour and the Tories in office. If there is a big issue to be addressed, it will always be ducked instead.
Plus ca change.
Posts: 7,446
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
I think it’s healthy that they can’t just bulldoze this one through easily to be honest. It’s just a shame no one is pointing out what the actual problem is.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-24-2025, 10:12 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I think it’s healthy that they can’t just bulldoze this one through easily to be honest. It’s just a shame no one is pointing out what the actual problem is.
What, we can't afford so many people of working age to be idle?
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
06-24-2025, 10:30 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-24-2025, 10:39 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(06-24-2025, 10:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-24-2025, 10:12 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I think it’s healthy that they can’t just bulldoze this one through easily to be honest. It’s just a shame no one is pointing out what the actual problem is.
What, we can't afford so many people of working age to be idle?
Spoken like a man who thinks children’s hospices should rely on the generosity of donations from individuals without the support from the state. You are no arbiter of what is ‘right’.
Oh and your ‘proper jobs’ seem to be consultancy for councils, working for failing water companies and being a landlord’ hardly saving people from burning buildings, keeping people safe or making them well.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(06-24-2025, 09:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 09:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-24-2025, 09:39 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If you think that someone who can’t make a meal or wash below the waist doesn’t need additional support to work then I’m not sure you you care one way or the other about the reasons for these cuts.
Can you help me understand where it says in the paper that this will be applied in the way you state it will. I would wholeheartedly agree that anyone who couldn't do either of those tasks would deserve PIP.
You could try reading the article yourself…
‘Foxcroft, a former shadow disability minister, quit her post last week as a government whip, saying she could not support the cuts, which could affect more than a million people.
The changes, which are at the centre of a £4.8bn welfare cuts package, will mean even people who are unable to wash half their body or cook a meal for themselves will be denied the payments if they have no other impairments.’
And here is the crux of the problem - if you take all of the independence issues individually and make a statement that includes 'if', you have to look behind the actual wording. What is the likelihood that anyone who is unable to wash half their body doesn't have any other issues? The actual requirement is "Needs assistance to be able to wash their body between the shoulders and waist." With that activity there is a high likelihood that they will also "Needs ... assistance to be able to manage therapy that takes more than 3.5 but no more than 7 hours a week.", or even "Needs ... assistance to either prepare or cook a simple meal." or one of the, in total, 12 activities: pip_descriptors.pdf
So I would suggest that for the examples you have given they are highly unlikely to be the only impediment and therefore the statement made is to lead in a specific direction i.e. their viewpoint
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
I don't personally know any disabled people, therefore it is an unnecessary expense catering for a cohort of our population who simply do not exist.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-24-2025, 10:48 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-24-2025, 09:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 09:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-24-2025, 09:39 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If you think that someone who can’t make a meal or wash below the waist doesn’t need additional support to work then I’m not sure you you care one way or the other about the reasons for these cuts.
Can you help me understand where it says in the paper that this will be applied in the way you state it will. I would wholeheartedly agree that anyone who couldn't do either of those tasks would deserve PIP.
You could try reading the article yourself…
‘Foxcroft, a former shadow disability minister, quit her post last week as a government whip, saying she could not support the cuts, which could affect more than a million people.
The changes, which are at the centre of a £4.8bn welfare cuts package, will mean even people who are unable to wash half their body or cook a meal for themselves will be denied the payments if they have no other impairments.’
And here is the crux of the problem - if you take all of the independence issues individually and make a statement that includes 'if', you have to look behind the actual wording. What is the likelihood that anyone who is unable to wash half their body doesn't have any other issues? The actual requirement is "Needs assistance to be able to wash their body between the shoulders and waist." With that activity there is a high likelihood that they will also "Needs ... assistance to be able to manage therapy that takes more than 3.5 but no more than 7 hours a week.", or even "Needs ... assistance to either prepare or cook a simple meal." or one of the, in total, 12 activities: pip_descriptors.pdf
So I would suggest that for the examples you have given they are highly unlikely to be the only impediment and therefore the statement made is to lead in a specific direction i.e. their viewpoint
Hi Proth.
Posts: 7,446
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
(06-24-2025, 10:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-24-2025, 10:12 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I think it’s healthy that they can’t just bulldoze this one through easily to be honest. It’s just a shame no one is pointing out what the actual problem is.
What, we can't afford so many people of working age to be idle?
I doubt anyone who receives between £100 and £700 a month is then able to sack off work as a result. It simply needs a better assessment process and a more sensible distribution of the amounts, including a higher rate at the top end and a more tapered rate in the middle.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
06-24-2025, 11:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-24-2025, 11:16 AM by baggy1.)
(06-24-2025, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-24-2025, 10:48 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-24-2025, 09:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 09:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-24-2025, 09:39 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If you think that someone who can’t make a meal or wash below the waist doesn’t need additional support to work then I’m not sure you you care one way or the other about the reasons for these cuts.
Can you help me understand where it says in the paper that this will be applied in the way you state it will. I would wholeheartedly agree that anyone who couldn't do either of those tasks would deserve PIP.
You could try reading the article yourself…
‘Foxcroft, a former shadow disability minister, quit her post last week as a government whip, saying she could not support the cuts, which could affect more than a million people.
The changes, which are at the centre of a £4.8bn welfare cuts package, will mean even people who are unable to wash half their body or cook a meal for themselves will be denied the payments if they have no other impairments.’
And here is the crux of the problem - if you take all of the independence issues individually and make a statement that includes 'if', you have to look behind the actual wording. What is the likelihood that anyone who is unable to wash half their body doesn't have any other issues? The actual requirement is "Needs assistance to be able to wash their body between the shoulders and waist." With that activity there is a high likelihood that they will also "Needs ... assistance to be able to manage therapy that takes more than 3.5 but no more than 7 hours a week.", or even "Needs ... assistance to either prepare or cook a simple meal." or one of the, in total, 12 activities: pip_descriptors.pdf
So I would suggest that for the examples you have given they are highly unlikely to be the only impediment and therefore the statement made is to lead in a specific direction i.e. their viewpoint
Hi Proth.
You are blindly accepting somebodies word without digging too deeply because it fits your narrative. I have pointed out the issues with the view stated and your comeback is that. You are not looking for solutions or discussion, you just want to moan about something that, when pointed out is inaccurate, turns you into a 13 year old girl responding on facebook.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
06-24-2025, 11:17 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-24-2025, 11:29 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(06-24-2025, 11:12 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (06-24-2025, 10:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-24-2025, 10:12 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I think it’s healthy that they can’t just bulldoze this one through easily to be honest. It’s just a shame no one is pointing out what the actual problem is.
What, we can't afford so many people of working age to be idle?
I doubt anyone who receives between £100 and £700 a month is then able to sack off work as a result. It simply needs a better assessment process and a more sensible distribution of the amounts, including a higher rate at the top end and a more tapered rate in the middle.
It also needs people who it’s obvious will and can’t ever work and their carers to be taken out if the ludicrous and expensive continual reassessments. However it should be clear by now these are cuts it’s not about reform. That reminds me if only Reform were against the cuts, you can bet your bottom dollar Labour would be dropping this bill asap. That’s how far this government have sunk.
(06-24-2025, 11:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-24-2025, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-24-2025, 10:48 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (06-24-2025, 09:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 09:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Can you help me understand where it says in the paper that this will be applied in the way you state it will. I would wholeheartedly agree that anyone who couldn't do either of those tasks would deserve PIP.
You could try reading the article yourself…
‘Foxcroft, a former shadow disability minister, quit her post last week as a government whip, saying she could not support the cuts, which could affect more than a million people.
The changes, which are at the centre of a £4.8bn welfare cuts package, will mean even people who are unable to wash half their body or cook a meal for themselves will be denied the payments if they have no other impairments.’
And here is the crux of the problem - if you take all of the independence issues individually and make a statement that includes 'if', you have to look behind the actual wording. What is the likelihood that anyone who is unable to wash half their body doesn't have any other issues? The actual requirement is "Needs assistance to be able to wash their body between the shoulders and waist." With that activity there is a high likelihood that they will also "Needs ... assistance to be able to manage therapy that takes more than 3.5 but no more than 7 hours a week.", or even "Needs ... assistance to either prepare or cook a simple meal." or one of the, in total, 12 activities: pip_descriptors.pdf
So I would suggest that for the examples you have given they are highly unlikely to be the only impediment and therefore the statement made is to lead in a specific direction i.e. their viewpoint
Hi Proth.
You are blindly accepting somebodies word without digging too deeply because it fits your narrative. I have pointed out the issues with the view stated and your comeback is that. You are not looking for solutions or discussion, you just want to moan about something that, when pointed out is inaccurate, turns you into a 13 year old girl responding on facebook.
No you have latched onto one quote (with the argument they have to be more disabled than that surely) in the forlorn hope you can justify pushing through a bill in parliament without showing impact statements and no proper consultation with disability groups, experts, charities or even business’s as to what reform should be. Even the Select Committee are against the bill as it currently stands and yet here you are like the bastard child of Liz Kendall and Morgan McSweeney defending the indefensible.
|