Disability vote
#1
It seems not everyone in the Labour Party are willing to just meekly accept cuts to the most vulnerable… 

Shall we consult those who the cuts will affect?
Reply
#2
Party you would never vote for apparently
Reply
#3
(06-24-2025, 06:38 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Party you would never vote for apparently

Ffs B1, it’s only because a minority of Labour MPs are daring to go against the morality and principle free ‘leadership’ of Starmer, Reeves, Kendall and co that it’s even has the remote chance of being stopped/amended/even consulted on.  Blue Labour are the ones threatening and trying to cajole their fellow MPs to vote for this, you know the ones you think are doing a good job. 

Can you explain how someone who cannot wash below the waist or make a meal will not eligible for PIP (not an out of work benefit) but can find and hold down a job without the support PIP allows? It’s bullshit, the Labour Party are balancing the books on the back of the most vulnerable in society. 

So no I won’t be voting for them, because I think those who vote for this bill are massive xxxxs
Reply
#4
Of the many things Dekka moans about this one is the most valid.
Reply
#5
There is a fundamental misunderstanding on how the Labour party works by Dekka and also an misunderstanding of how these things work in practice. His fear is that it will punish the most vulnerable and those in need, something that it states within the document that it won't do. It will, justifiably, try to address fraud in the system, something that Dekka suggests doesn't happen without understanding that unidentified fraud is below the waterline and not measured or reported on. The government have increased frontline resource to deal with the assessment process and ultimately this is something that needs to be addressed.

I'll give you a very current example of where fraud in the system doesn't get measured. In the last few weeks I have had a Romanian national register with the DWP and NHS England at my address without any issues.
Reply
#6
It’ll be like Osbourne and Tax Credits. It’ll get canned eventually but only when it doesn’t spook the markets to do so.

(06-24-2025, 08:03 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Of the many things Dekka moans about this one is the most valid.

Can’t agree Ted. But I don’t agree with the changes they are making either. It needs reform, they are right about that. The manner of the reform is as bad as the problem it’s trying to reform.
Reply
#7
(06-24-2025, 08:20 AM)baggy1 Wrote: There is a fundamental misunderstanding on how the Labour party works by Dekka and also an misunderstanding of how these things work in practice. His fear is that it will punish the most vulnerable and those in need, something that it states within the document that it won't do. It will, justifiably, try to address fraud in the system, something that Dekka suggests doesn't happen without understanding that unidentified fraud is below the waterline and not measured or reported on. The government have increased frontline resource to deal with the assessment process and ultimately this is something that needs to be addressed.

I'll give you a very current example of where fraud in the system doesn't get measured. In the last few weeks I have had a Romanian national register with the DWP and NHS England at my address without any issues.

They are cuts don’t pretend that it is genuine reform. Even the governments own figures say it’ll push 250k of the poorest people in the country into poverty. Charities and other organisations say that’s a conservative estimate. 

You say there is widespread fraud without any evidence beyond some anecdotal stories you like to share. If the fraud hasn’t been measured how do you know what the figure is? The official figures say there isn’t significant fraud regarding a ‘in work PIP support’. 

Even the Select Committee are against the manner in which these reforms are being made/pushed through and they’ve heard all the evidence, but still you tow the Blue Labour line. 

If you think that someone who can’t make a meal or wash below the waist doesn’t need additional support to work then I’m not sure you you care one way or the other about the reasons for these cuts.
Reply
#8
https://www.tiktok.com/discover/how-to-f...your-money

Derek there are literally people earning a living by guiding people how to manipulate the forms. The problem isn’t those people, it’s the idiotic design of the application.

Whether you believe that or not doesn’t make it any less true.
Reply
#9
(06-24-2025, 09:39 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 08:20 AM)baggy1 Wrote: There is a fundamental misunderstanding on how the Labour party works by Dekka and also an misunderstanding of how these things work in practice. His fear is that it will punish the most vulnerable and those in need, something that it states within the document that it won't do. It will, justifiably, try to address fraud in the system, something that Dekka suggests doesn't happen without understanding that unidentified fraud is below the waterline and not measured or reported on. The government have increased frontline resource to deal with the assessment process and ultimately this is something that needs to be addressed.

I'll give you a very current example of where fraud in the system doesn't get measured. In the last few weeks I have had a Romanian national register with the DWP and NHS England at my address without any issues.

They are cuts don’t pretend that it is genuine reform. Even the governments own figures say it’ll push 250k of the poorest people in the country into poverty. Charities and other organisations say that’s a conservative estimate. 

You say there is widespread fraud without any evidence beyond some anecdotal stories you like to share. If the fraud hasn’t been measured how do you know what the figure is? The official figures say there isn’t significant fraud regarding a ‘in work PIP support’. 

Even the Select Committee are against the manner in which these reforms are being made/pushed through and they’ve heard all the evidence, but still you tow the Blue Labour line. 

If you think that someone who can’t make a meal or wash below the waist doesn’t need additional support to work then I’m not sure you you care one way or the other about the reasons for these cuts.

Can you help me understand where it says in the paper that this will be applied in the way you state it will. I would wholeheartedly agree that anyone who couldn't do either of those tasks would deserve PIP.
Reply
#10
(06-24-2025, 09:46 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: https://www.tiktok.com/discover/how-to-f...your-money

Derek there are literally people earning a living by guiding people how to manipulate the forms. The problem isn’t those people, it’s the idiotic design of the application.

Whether you believe that or not doesn’t make it any less true.

Who has said there shouldn’t be reform? I have never said that and wouldn’t. I question the figures around fraud and PIP because until they can be proven it’s all a bit behind the twitching curtain… dob in your neighbour style politics.

However these cuts aren’t about reform they are exactly that cuts to the budget. No proper consultation with people has yet taken place, no real plan to address how you get employers to employ those who need additional support and nothing to address the impact this will have on people. They are pushing through the bill to make cuts first and without proper scrutiny for MPs to make an informed decision. 

The conceit that this is to help people is what I find particularly troubling from a supposed Labour government who show virtually no sign of listening to anyone but a handful of advisers who are still trying divide as Reform do.

(06-24-2025, 09:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 09:39 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-24-2025, 08:20 AM)baggy1 Wrote: There is a fundamental misunderstanding on how the Labour party works by Dekka and also an misunderstanding of how these things work in practice. His fear is that it will punish the most vulnerable and those in need, something that it states within the document that it won't do. It will, justifiably, try to address fraud in the system, something that Dekka suggests doesn't happen without understanding that unidentified fraud is below the waterline and not measured or reported on. The government have increased frontline resource to deal with the assessment process and ultimately this is something that needs to be addressed.

I'll give you a very current example of where fraud in the system doesn't get measured. In the last few weeks I have had a Romanian national register with the DWP and NHS England at my address without any issues.

They are cuts don’t pretend that it is genuine reform. Even the governments own figures say it’ll push 250k of the poorest people in the country into poverty. Charities and other organisations say that’s a conservative estimate. 

You say there is widespread fraud without any evidence beyond some anecdotal stories you like to share. If the fraud hasn’t been measured how do you know what the figure is? The official figures say there isn’t significant fraud regarding a ‘in work PIP support’. 

Even the Select Committee are against the manner in which these reforms are being made/pushed through and they’ve heard all the evidence, but still you tow the Blue Labour line. 

If you think that someone who can’t make a meal or wash below the waist doesn’t need additional support to work then I’m not sure you you care one way or the other about the reasons for these cuts.

Can you help me understand where it says in the paper that this will be applied in the way you state it will. I would wholeheartedly agree that anyone who couldn't do either of those tasks would deserve PIP.

You could try reading the article yourself…

‘Foxcroft, a former shadow disability minister, quit her post last week as a government whip, saying she could not support the cuts, which could affect more than a million people.

The changes, which are at the centre of a £4.8bn welfare cuts package, will mean even people who are unable to wash half their body or cook a meal for themselves will be denied the payments if they have no other impairments.’
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: