Things you’ve changed your mind on late in life
Good for you

(06-11-2025, 09:44 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:  am I missing something

Yes you are missing something. Enlightened self interest lies behind every business ever created. Serve the needs of others, and in doing so benefit yourself too.
Reply
Oxymorons
Reply
As I've said before proth doesn't understand what it means no. He seems to think "serve the needs of others" means "create a for-profit enterprise that services a need" when instead it means that altruistic action ultimately creates a better society for everyone, including yourself (hence the "self interest" part).

"A society grows great when old men plant trees in whose shade they shall never sit"
Reply
(06-12-2025, 06:17 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Good for you

(06-11-2025, 09:44 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:  am I missing something

Yes you are missing something. Enlightened self interest lies behind every business ever created. Serve the needs of others, and in doing so benefit yourself too.

Quite, but when you defined it you seemed to place the needs of your family as being that of "others". I don't think "family first" is the definition of "enlightened self-interest" that you assume it means.  The definition I have read in several formats states that  "Enlightened self-interest" results in an improvement to society as a whole as a result of placing the needs of others first which as a consequence results in an improvement to one's own value, both financial but primarily social.
Reply
(06-12-2025, 07:22 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(06-12-2025, 06:17 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Good for you

(06-11-2025, 09:44 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:  am I missing something

Yes you are missing something. Enlightened self interest lies behind every business ever created. Serve the needs of others, and in doing so benefit yourself too.

Quite, but when you defined it you seemed to place the needs of your family as being that of "others". I don't think "family first" is the definition of "enlightened self-interest" that you assume it means.  The definition I have read in several formats states that  "Enlightened self-interest" results in an improvement to society as a whole as a result of placing the needs of others first which as a consequence results in an improvement to one's own value, both financial but primarily social.

So it seems to be selflessness should be placed at the forefront of this ideal, and by performing selfless acts that better society as a whole, your life would also become better. Which is directly opposite to what Proth has been advocating in his seeming me and mine first, then others possibly if they're lucky philosophy.

I'd also like to comment on Proth's career description, basically saying that he's worked really hard to get where he is. I'm sure he has, I'm not trying to take anything away from him there. But the implication is that others who aren't as successful haven't worked hard in their life to try and succeed, and in the majority of cases, that isn't true, and is actually quite offensive to suggest.
Reply
(06-12-2025, 06:53 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: As I've said before proth doesn't understand what it means no. He seems to think "serve the needs of others" means "create a for-profit enterprise that services a need" when instead it means that altruistic action ultimately creates a better society for everyone, including yourself (hence the "self interest" part).

"A society grows great when old men plant trees in whose shade they shall never sit"

I understand Adam Smith's suggestion that Enlightened self-interest refers to the concept that regard for one's own good prompts a person to assist in promoting the good of others.

No business would survive if it did not put the needs of others first. No society would flourish without the free exchange of goods and services.

Do you believe that 1 billion people have been raised out of absolute poverty in East / South Asia & the Pacific since 1990 by chance?

(06-12-2025, 07:35 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: But the implication is that others who aren't as successful haven't worked hard in their life to try and succeed, and in the majority of cases, that isn't true, and is actually quite offensive to suggest.

I implied nothing of the sort, but as usual that won't stop some of you deciding what I think.

In fact, I've learned that hard work has very little to do with reward; informed risk, on the other hand does. Now reread that post.
Reply
Adam Smith's interpretation of self-interest as outlined in The Wealth of Nations and Enlightened Self Interest are two (very) different concepts.
Reply
Isn't the basic rule of business, keep your costs down, materials / wages, and your sales high, consumer prices. The bit in the middle is what matters and that's the profit.

Not sure how that benefits either the manufacturer, the worker or the consumer. The supermarkets are a prime example, they drive down what they pay their suppliers and then reduce staff, none of which appears to be reflected in the prices they sell at. The only ones that benefit big are the owners and the shareholders.

However you dress it up, it's plain greed, driven by massive margins.

No financial stickyfoots but them's my onions.
Reply
(06-12-2025, 08:41 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-12-2025, 07:35 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: But the implication is that others who aren't as successful haven't worked hard in their life to try and succeed, and in the majority of cases, that isn't true, and is actually quite offensive to suggest.

I implied nothing of the sort, but as usual that won't stop some of you deciding what I think.

In fact, I've learned that hard work has very little to do with reward; informed risk, on the other hand does. Now reread that post.

You posted a big long spiel about how you've worked hard, raised yourself from your starting point and now deserve the money, property and wealth you've accumulated. Later on you pointed to it being about your mindset. Fine, well done you.

The implication of this is that those that DON'T have money and wealth, haven't worked hard and tried to better themselves, or done some dirty work like cleaning drains or the equivalent. Otherwise, they would also be in your position or similar. The implication is that others who aren't successful don't have the necessary mindset, which is a slightly fairer point, but one I still take issue with, as this mindset is based around ruthlessness and personal gains as opposed to community gains, despite what you say about enlightened self interest.

The fact you can't see how this comes across and the implication it gives is a big reason why you just don't get the point myself and several others are making. You can do the classic "oh but that's not what I've said" and act obtuse, but anyone with any reading comprehension can see what you're implying here.
Reply
I've changed my mind on opening this Fred...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: