Growth
#91
What do you think made up the lost tax revenue from raising the personal allowance? Other taxes did, VAT is a big one as it went up to 20%. Liz Truss literally pushed for what you are trying to argue - unfunded tax cuts - and the bond markets blew up. When the coalition raised the personal allowance other taxes went up to cover lost income tax receipts, what taxes are you suggesting we raise to cover that £50bn shortfall?

I've pointed out to you the cost of raising the personal allowance, you said it would be made up by growth and I've shown you there is no link between narrowing the tax base and growth - growth being what's needed to fund tax cuts. So I don't consider growth to be a satisfactory response.
Reply
#92
The report I linked splits into the different taxes and shows an increase in PAYE taxes over the period (figure 2). That doesn't support your view that it would create a black hole.
Reply
#93
CGT raises, unemployment rate dropping, immigration rates.

That isn't a per capita income tax graph, there's a lot of externalities in that graph that you're just straight up ignoring.

£50bn is a macroeconomic assessment from the IFS for the cost of a £20k personal allowance. So I'll ask again, how are you going to cover that shortfall?
Reply
#94
CGT raised went from 5bn to 10bn in the period that the graph increased by £100bn so I would say it was that impactful, unemployment rate dropping was negligible but that and the immigration rates all resulted from more jobs being created (growth).

Look, it was a relatively throw away comment that seems to have bought out the Mr Angry in you 'Asking me again', so lets disagree and leave it at that.
Reply
#95
Immigration went up, economic inactivity dropped and unemployment dropped all in that time frame. That graph isn't on a per-capita basis.

You say it was just a "throw away" comment but the party leading in the polls is pushing for it and it's fiscal suicide, it's nearly £5k higher than just matching inflation from 2020.

https://www.productivity.ac.uk/news/mind...pital-gap/

https://www.ft.com/content/583a30e1-f411...02634a6a3c

What we need to do to stimulate growth is obvious and it has nothing to do with the personal allowance. We need to invest capital.
Reply
#96
Reform are using Proth's spiteful policies.
Proth is going full kipper.
https://www.unison.org.uk/news/2025/06/r...etirement/
Reply
#97
If someone has an argument suggesting incentives to work and to invest haven’t been attacked consistently for 17 years I’d be pleased to hear it.

It was only the corrosive period of zero interest rates and free money that kept this country going at all.

Now the tides proper out.
Reply
#98
Still unsure where you stand on this. Get off the fence
Reply
#99
(06-05-2025, 09:21 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Still unsure where you stand on this. Get off the fence

He'll be telling us that Reeves needs 2% growth next and claiming he's been saying it for ages.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(06-06-2025, 07:04 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(06-05-2025, 09:21 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Still unsure where you stand on this. Get off the fence

He'll be telling us that Reeves needs 2% growth next and claiming he's been saying it for ages.

I wish I wasn't right. It's a cross I have to bear.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: