Growth
#81
(06-05-2025, 01:18 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Has this turned into a self therapy blog?

It's rather turned into a "no one is taking issue with what Proth is saying anymore about growth anymore" thread.

Which makes a pleasant change.
Reply
#82
Not certain anyone cares much any more - you saying the sky is blue doesn't mean that we are surprised it is blue or you should take the credit for being the only one to know that.

Between 1990 and 2000 the PA went up £1,335, 2000 to 2010 - £2,140, 2010 to 2020 - £6k and £70 since then. So it appears that long term policy (apart from the Conservatives under Cameron) has been to allow it to happen. When the PA is lower than the state pension then you know something is wrong, growth or otherwise. Me personally, I'd advocate for a base PA of £20k, the logic for me is that it creates more available funds to spend which would lead to growth. I'd also push the higher rate thresholds up as well which have only moved £300 since 2010.
Reply
#83
(06-05-2025, 03:30 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not certain anyone cares much any more - you saying the sky is blue doesn't mean that we are surprised it is blue or you should take the credit for being the only one to know that.

Between 1990 and 2000 the PA went up £1,335, 2000 to 2010 - £2,140, 2010 to 2020 - £6k and £70 since then. So it appears that long term policy (apart from the Conservatives under Cameron) has been to allow it to happen. When the PA is lower than the state pension then you know something is wrong, growth or otherwise. Me personally, I'd advocate for a base PA of £20k, the logic for me is that it creates more available funds to spend which would lead to growth. I'd also push the higher rate thresholds up as well which have only moved £300 since 2010.

Are you Nigel Farage?

Just increasing the personal allowance would cost £50bn in lost taxes, getting it to £15.5k in line with inflation is expensive enough. £20k would be economic suicide, how are you making up the lost revenue for that?
Reply
#84
(06-05-2025, 03:36 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(06-05-2025, 03:30 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Not certain anyone cares much any more - you saying the sky is blue doesn't mean that we are surprised it is blue or you should take the credit for being the only one to know that.

Between 1990 and 2000 the PA went up £1,335, 2000 to 2010 - £2,140, 2010 to 2020 - £6k and £70 since then. So it appears that long term policy (apart from the Conservatives under Cameron) has been to allow it to happen. When the PA is lower than the state pension then you know something is wrong, growth or otherwise. Me personally, I'd advocate for a base PA of £20k, the logic for me is that it creates more available funds to spend which would lead to growth. I'd also push the higher rate thresholds up as well which have only moved £300 since 2010.

Are you Nigel Farage?

Just increasing the personal allowance would cost £50bn in lost taxes, getting it to £15.5k in line with inflation is expensive enough. £20k would be economic suicide, how are you making up the lost revenue for that?

In a static calculation that is correct BB, but it isn't a static calculation is it. More money in peoples pockets would create more spending, which would generate more tax revenue and growth. It would also allow organisations, including government, to reduce any pay rises (as people would still be better off nett) and therefore generate more profits and therefore tax. It also allows more growth for those companies which creates jobs and therefore more tax and more money in the economy.

Or we could continue with the same approach and see if one day it works.
Reply
#85
That didn't happen when the coalition massively increased it, I fail to see the evidence it will happen now. That is pure hopeful conjecture.

All that will happen is that money will be lost to rising costs - particularly housing.

The problem with the UK is a productivity one, you get much better returns on that by incentivising capital investment from businesses, the public sector and big individual private investors into the UK and dealing with stupid tax traps that cause people to cut hours.
Reply
#86
Not certain I agree with your 1st point there BB. Take a look at this and specifically the Income Tax, VAT and Business Taxes after 2010. I would like to see further back but it looks like prior to 2010 there was a flat (ish) line and growth started after 2010 with a delay on the Business Taxes, which wouldn't have been as immediately impacted as VAT and PAYE.
https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics...20slowdown
Reply
#87
You don't agree with me about what? The personal allowance massively increased during the coalition, growth was modest.

https://ifs.org.uk/taxlab/taxlab-data-it...-over-time

As you can see it was actually falling quite sharply during the sustained period of growth between 1995 and 2007 as percentage of average earnings, there is no evidence that raising the personal impacts growth. The justifications are for alleviating poverty, not economic growth.

Need I bring up the Nordic countries who are in much stronger fiscal positions with better growth prospects than us that have a much broader tax base? Tax adjustments between £50k and £125k are much more prescient because of the link to productivity.
Reply
#88
Are you comparing apples with pears here by taking the % of average earnings - we are purely looking at a tax revenue growth in total not spread across individual earners. The tax revenue grew when the PA was increased. You've moved the point onto another discussion by looking at average earnings. Your point was that tax revenue wouldn't increase if we raised the PA, I simply pointed to a stat that said it did - surely that is a good thing?

And it is implicit that by raising the PA to £20k you alleviate poverty as the lower earners are impacted, %wise more.
Reply
#89
We are talking about the costs and benefits from raising the personal allowance to £20k, as evidenced by historic precedent in the UK and comparing our position with Nordic countries there is no link between raising the personal allowance and growth. You haven't presented any evidence to the contrary.

And I'd rather not raise VAT to keep the Exchequer's income stable as it's a reductive tax. That £50bn gets made up elsewhere (a.k.a. reductive taxes) or is made up by borrowing, either way there's no growth prospects.
Reply
#90
Just to recap:

I suggested raising PA

You suggested that would leave a massive hole in tax revenue (£50bn)

I showed you where the last time the PA was raised it led to a year on year increase in tax revenue (as opposed to the reduction you stated) - I know this is simplistic due to the many factors however the point that the tax revenues wouldn't drop stands.

You talked about something else and bought VAT into it. I agree that we shouldn't increase VAT, however more spending capacity would create more VAT revenue.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: