Mason and Bracewell it is then….
The problem we have is that currently the players are a ,ox of what VI, Bruce, Carlos or TM wanted, some go back further. It's no wonder we have imbalance to the squad, we need a period of calm for a style or pattern of play to be determined and then bring in players to fit that, at the same time any future manager/head coach should align with that approach and style. This then should be the ethos through the club.

It's pretty much what Dan Ashworth did in his time here and that was more hit than miss.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
So in reality, Nestor is the team manager, in that he dictates style and players in... So he should be getting the vitriol and not the coach in the dug out, who is more akin to what Brunt / Mozza etc... are?
Reply
(06-04-2025, 09:39 AM)MrBater Wrote: So in reality, Nestor is the team manager, in that he dictates style and players in... So he should be getting the vitriol and not the coach in the dug out, who is more akin to what Brunt / Mozza etc... are?

Not really.

Nestor will have an idea of the way he feels the club should play to not only win football matches but also to give players a platform to perform and increase in value. This would have been one of the criteria for any potential new manager. Mason obviously delivered the most compelling case.

The principles may be set by Nestor - sign and develop younger players (U23), play possession football, press high up the pitch - but there are a number of ways this can be implemented on the pitch, that is Mason's job.

We've all acknowledged on here that we need a new CB this summer, the conversation might go something like "we need a centre half who wins x% of headers, has this many progressive passes, loses possession on avg. this many times per 90, makes this many clearances" - parameters based on what Mason wants from his CB in this position.

The recruitment team will go away, do the analysis and find players who fit those criteria and are realistic signings for us based on the club they're currently playing for, their age, their current contract and nationality.

Said list of players will be watched and the list will be given to Mason whereby he can probably then start thinking about which of them will fit best into the squad, if he knows people who know people he might ask them.

It's basically like recruiting for any job. Gone are the days when managers turn up and say "sign x, he's a good lad"

Goes without saying that this is a very simplistic view of the process.
Reply
(06-04-2025, 09:39 AM)MrBater Wrote: So in reality, Nestor is the team manager, in that he dictates style and players in... So he should be getting the vitriol and not the coach in the dug out, who is more akin to what Brunt / Mozza etc... are?

Mason must have convinced them that his ideas align, so he will take responsibility for what happens on the pitch.

I think you are right in terms of signings though, in that the coach should get some slack, as his input will be more limited in that area. Will inevitably be split, however, based on his popularity. If he does well, then any good signings will be his and bad ones will be Nestor, a-la Corberan. If he does badly, he'll get the blame for everything, a-la Mowbray.
Reply
Coaches are like F1 drivers. They get to have input but ultimately they drive what's given to them and it's up to them to get the maximum out of what they are given.
Reply
(06-04-2025, 10:09 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-04-2025, 09:39 AM)MrBater Wrote: So in reality, Nestor is the team manager, in that he dictates style and players in... So he should be getting the vitriol and not the coach in the dug out, who is more akin to what Brunt / Mozza etc... are?

Mason must have convinced them that his ideas align, so he will take responsibility for what happens on the pitch.

I think you are right in terms of signings though, in that the coach should get some slack, as his input will be more limited in that area. Will inevitably be split, however, based on his popularity. If he does well, then any good signings will be his and bad ones will be Nestor, a-la Corberan. If he does badly, he'll get the blame for everything, a-la Mowbray.

Aye that's the rub. I remember reading something Brunt or Mozza said about the players not being the sort Mowbray would've chosen, so it definitely is Nestor who gets who Nestor wants... To play Nestor's vision, it's like we need a robotic Head Coach who just does as he's told within the Nestor vision... Heck there's plenty of AI models (surely?!) that can provide lists of players hitting x y z stats for specific parameters...

Footballers are people, people are unpredictable, some need encouraging, some need a bollocking, so I guess at least that bit will still be down to the head coach.

Now, do we know what Nestor wants? Is it flexible if we find ourselves scrapping and needing to play the opposite way to the vision? Feels like another area where the human element of the game is being swapped to me...
Reply
(06-04-2025, 09:34 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: The problem we have is that currently the players are a ,ox of what VI, Bruce, Carlos or TM wanted, some go back further.  It's no wonder we have imbalance to the squad, we need a period of calm for a style or pattern of play to be determined and then bring in players to fit that, at the same time any future manager/head coach should align with that approach and style.  This then should be the ethos through the club.

It's pretty much what Dan Ashworth did in his time here and that was more hit than miss.

Exactly. It's imperative that we moove some of them on.
Reply
(06-04-2025, 10:30 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(06-04-2025, 10:09 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-04-2025, 09:39 AM)MrBater Wrote: So in reality, Nestor is the team manager, in that he dictates style and players in... So he should be getting the vitriol and not the coach in the dug out, who is more akin to what Brunt / Mozza etc... are?

Mason must have convinced them that his ideas align, so he will take responsibility for what happens on the pitch.

I think you are right in terms of signings though, in that the coach should get some slack, as his input will be more limited in that area. Will inevitably be split, however, based on his popularity. If he does well, then any good signings will be his and bad ones will be Nestor, a-la Corberan. If he does badly, he'll get the blame for everything, a-la Mowbray.

Aye that's the rub. I remember reading something Brunt or Mozza said about the players not being the sort Mowbray would've chosen, so it definitely is Nestor who gets who Nestor wants... To play Nestor's vision, it's like we need a robotic Head Coach who just does as he's told within the Nestor vision... Heck there's plenty of AI models (surely?!) that can provide lists of players hitting x y z stats for specific parameters...

Footballers are people, people are unpredictable, some need encouraging, some need a bollocking, so I guess at least that bit will still be down to the head coach.

Now, do we know what Nestor wants? Is it flexible if we find ourselves scrapping and needing to play the opposite way to the vision? Feels like another area where the human element of the game is being swapped to me...

It's just an outline of the style. The manager will be free to tweak it, use other tactics, put an extra body in midfield if necessary,  double up on a winger etc. I don't know why everyone takes it so literally.  SGM wanted us to play 442. He was the first to say 3 at the back suited us better after he'd been in charge a while. It will be results 1st, style of play will a long term project to which players are introduced along the way. 
Of course, I might be wrong but I think there's more to the plan than players taking off the handbrake and discovering their inner child.
Reply
(06-04-2025, 11:15 AM)Tokyo Baggie Wrote:
(06-04-2025, 09:34 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: The problem we have is that currently the players are a ,ox of what VI, Bruce, Carlos or TM wanted, some go back further.  It's no wonder we have imbalance to the squad, we need a period of calm for a style or pattern of play to be determined and then bring in players to fit that, at the same time any future manager/head coach should align with that approach and style.  This then should be the ethos through the club.

It's pretty much what Dan Ashworth did in his time here and that was more hit than miss.

Exactly. It's imperative that we moove some of them on.
Yeah, we need udder options
Reply
(06-04-2025, 01:07 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(06-04-2025, 10:30 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(06-04-2025, 10:09 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-04-2025, 09:39 AM)MrBater Wrote: So in reality, Nestor is the team manager, in that he dictates style and players in... So he should be getting the vitriol and not the coach in the dug out, who is more akin to what Brunt / Mozza etc... are?

Mason must have convinced them that his ideas align, so he will take responsibility for what happens on the pitch.

I think you are right in terms of signings though, in that the coach should get some slack, as his input will be more limited in that area. Will inevitably be split, however, based on his popularity. If he does well, then any good signings will be his and bad ones will be Nestor, a-la Corberan. If he does badly, he'll get the blame for everything, a-la Mowbray.

Aye that's the rub. I remember reading something Brunt or Mozza said about the players not being the sort Mowbray would've chosen, so it definitely is Nestor who gets who Nestor wants... To play Nestor's vision, it's like we need a robotic Head Coach who just does as he's told within the Nestor vision... Heck there's plenty of AI models (surely?!) that can provide lists of players hitting x y z stats for specific parameters...

Footballers are people, people are unpredictable, some need encouraging, some need a bollocking, so I guess at least that bit will still be down to the head coach.

Now, do we know what Nestor wants? Is it flexible if we find ourselves scrapping and needing to play the opposite way to the vision? Feels like another area where the human element of the game is being swapped to me...

It's just an outline of the style. The manager will be free to tweak it, use other tactics, put an extra body in midfield if necessary,  double up on a winger etc. I don't know why everyone takes it so literally.  SGM wanted us to play 442. He was the first to say 3 at the back suited us better after he'd been in charge a while. It will be results 1st, style of play will a long term project to which players are introduced along the way. 
Of course, I might be wrong but I think there's more to the plan than players taking off the handbrake and discovering their inner child.

Because nuance and critical thinking is hard for some people, whether deliberately or otherwise.

FWIW, I completely agree with you.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)