Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(06-03-2025, 02:38 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 02:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Failing to take a club up with some of the best players in the Championship via the play-offs
One promotion to the Prem with the biggest budget and best squad in the division, and one of the lowest points totals.
Relegation from the Prem
Coming second in a two horse race in the Scots Pub sorry Prem league.
One play-off position since then… average Championship record manager.
Are you purposely ignoring the fact that he over performed with the budget and players he had at Blackburn and Sunderland which was a big factor in him coming back here?
The old why didn't he get promoted with the great surrender team?
It's a total mystery.
There is no doubt the club was in a stronger position when he left than it was when he first arrived.
Ollsson, Brunt, Morrison, Mulumbu and Dorrans were the basis of a team that would go on to be a reasonably good Premier league team.
Most objective people would recognise that his work with Sunderland and Blackburn was good .
Boro and particularly Celtic were failures.
Mowbray is clearly not an exceptional manager, but at this level he has on the whole a good record.
Didn't work out for him on his return, which only goes to show you should never go back. But it was a diffic
Posts: 17,077
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-03-2025, 02:38 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 02:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Failing to take a club up with some of the best players in the Championship via the play-offs
One promotion to the Prem with the biggest budget and best squad in the division, and one of the lowest points totals.
Relegation from the Prem
Coming second in a two horse race in the Scots Pub sorry Prem league.
One play-off position since then… average Championship record manager.
Are you purposely ignoring the fact that he over performed with the budget and players he had at Blackburn and Sunderland which was a big factor in him coming back here?
I could ask the same of those who argue that he over achieved at Blackburn and Sunderland whilst ignoring or down playing the huge advantage he had over his rivals in the one and only season he got promoted from the Championship or lost to Derby, or came second in the Scot’s Prem. I understand the argument the club made for reappointing him but I will never agree with it as the data looked at a very small / skewed set of stats to inform the decision.
Anyway new manager, let’s see what he can do.
Posts: 19,493
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(06-03-2025, 04:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-03-2025, 02:38 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 02:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Failing to take a club up with some of the best players in the Championship via the play-offs
One promotion to the Prem with the biggest budget and best squad in the division, and one of the lowest points totals.
Relegation from the Prem
Coming second in a two horse race in the Scots Pub sorry Prem league.
One play-off position since then… average Championship record manager.
Are you purposely ignoring the fact that he over performed with the budget and players he had at Blackburn and Sunderland which was a big factor in him coming back here?
I could ask the same of those who argue that he over achieved at Blackburn and Sunderland whilst ignoring or down playing the huge advantage he had over his rivals in the one and only season he got promoted from the Championship or lost to Derby, or came second in the Scot’s Prem. I understand the argument the club made for reappointing him but I will never agree with it as the data looked at a very small / skewed set of stats to inform the decision.
Anyway new manager, let’s see what he can do.
Well no because you’re arguing that his achievements with us first time round don’t matter because of his budget, then saying his achievements despite his budgets at Blackburn and Sunderland don’t matter because he didn’t win anything. On paper Mowbray made sense, an experienced manager with a track record of delivering above his budget to guide a team into the playoffs after we’d missed out on our preferred choice and our interim solution was wobbling; unfortunately amongst all the data the interviewers clearly overlooked the fact he had some misty eyed intention to forego any of the things that had made us successful this season in a misguided attempt to make us score more goals.
It was a very bad decision, but one that has been rectified, and to give Nestor some forgiveness, I very much doubt Mowbray opened his interview with “I’m just going to let Swifty and co express themselves - I won’t be telling them where to pass and where to run”
Posts: 210
Threads: 19
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
1
If he did so well at Blackburn and Sunderland why was he sacked? The Blackburn's fans' reaction, kindly posted on here by Squid after the home defeat, was telling. I'm afraid they thought him clueless as we ultimately did. At the time I understood why he was appointed but then listening to him spout utter crap time and time again made me wonder if he had actually been interviewed. Surely if he had come out with this drivel about releasing the hand brake, falling in love with the game etc etc the board would and should have realised that all the good work done by CC was in danger of being ripped apart which it ultimately was. Red flags everywhere.
I just hope their latest interview process has been a little more discerning, intelligent and utlimately successful.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(06-03-2025, 08:27 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: If he did so well at Blackburn and Sunderland why was he sacked? The Blackburn's fans' reaction, kindly posted on here by Squid after the home defeat, was telling. I'm afraid they thought him clueless as we ultimately did. At the time I understood why he was appointed but then listening to him spout utter crap time and time again made me wonder if he had actually been interviewed. Surely if he had come out with this drivel about releasing the hand brake, falling in love with the game etc etc the board would and should have realised that all the good work done by CC was in danger of being ripped apart which it ultimately was. Red flags everywhere.
I just hope their latest interview process has been a little more discerning, intelligent and utlimately successful.
Define success? Many people thought minimum play-offs this season others thought not. We missed out by a couple of points, I think this seasons frustration comes from the manner of it happening.
With the relegated teams, other teams with parachute payments in place, free spending Blues & Wrexham, the usual play-off contenders and our current financial constraints what is acceptable and what is success?
I’ve no idea what to expect from Mason nor really what is a fair measurement. Patience may well be required and that’s been in very short supply since Pulis’s relegation season.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
06-04-2025, 07:44 AM
(This post was last modified: 06-04-2025, 07:44 AM by Tom Joad.)
(06-04-2025, 07:08 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 08:27 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: If he did so well at Blackburn and Sunderland why was he sacked? The Blackburn's fans' reaction, kindly posted on here by Squid after the home defeat, was telling. I'm afraid they thought him clueless as we ultimately did. At the time I understood why he was appointed but then listening to him spout utter crap time and time again made me wonder if he had actually been interviewed. Surely if he had come out with this drivel about releasing the hand brake, falling in love with the game etc etc the board would and should have realised that all the good work done by CC was in danger of being ripped apart which it ultimately was. Red flags everywhere.
I just hope their latest interview process has been a little more discerning, intelligent and utlimately successful.
Define success? Many people thought minimum play-offs this season others thought not. We missed out by a couple of points, I think this seasons frustration comes from the manner of it happening.
With the relegated teams, other teams with parachute payments in place, free spending Blues & Wrexham, the usual play-off contenders and our current financial constraints what is acceptable and what is success?
I’ve no idea what to expect from Mason nor really what is a fair measurement. Patience may well be required and that’s been in very short supply since Pulis’s relegation season.
Agree. I'd say expectations got raised somewhere between May and October last year. We all knew the awful shape the club was in last season and with player sales expected, personally I thought mid table would be OK. The (last) August window ended with us being in better shape, the great start to the season, our consistent league position etc. all made us believe achieving the play offs was realistic. Then the January signings confirmed our expectations. I've no doubt had CC not left this would have been achieved. I also think the appointment of Eustace, or any steady hand on the tiller, would have seen that target accomplished.
We now have to face a period where our new manager, however good he becomes eventually, is going to have to learn his trade on the job with players that are not yet his chouce and a P and S situationin the background. Patience will be required. I'm actually OK with that until a manager starts seeing a different game to everyone else.
Posts: 17,077
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-04-2025, 07:44 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-04-2025, 07:08 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 08:27 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: If he did so well at Blackburn and Sunderland why was he sacked? The Blackburn's fans' reaction, kindly posted on here by Squid after the home defeat, was telling. I'm afraid they thought him clueless as we ultimately did. At the time I understood why he was appointed but then listening to him spout utter crap time and time again made me wonder if he had actually been interviewed. Surely if he had come out with this drivel about releasing the hand brake, falling in love with the game etc etc the board would and should have realised that all the good work done by CC was in danger of being ripped apart which it ultimately was. Red flags everywhere.
I just hope their latest interview process has been a little more discerning, intelligent and utlimately successful.
Define success? Many people thought minimum play-offs this season others thought not. We missed out by a couple of points, I think this seasons frustration comes from the manner of it happening.
With the relegated teams, other teams with parachute payments in place, free spending Blues & Wrexham, the usual play-off contenders and our current financial constraints what is acceptable and what is success?
I’ve no idea what to expect from Mason nor really what is a fair measurement. Patience may well be required and that’s been in very short supply since Pulis’s relegation season.
Agree. I'd say expectations got raised somewhere between May and October last year. We all knew the awful shape the club was in last season and with player sales expected, personally I thought mid table would be OK. The (last) August window ended with us being in better shape, the great start to the season, our consistent league position etc. all made us believe achieving the play offs was realistic. Then the January signings confirmed our expectations. I've no doubt had CC not left this would have been achieved. I also think the appointment of Eustace, or any steady hand on the tiller, would have seen that target accomplished.
We now have to face a period where our new manager, however good he becomes eventually, is going to have to learn his trade on the job with players that are not yet his chouce and a P and S situationin the background. Patience will be required. I'm actually OK with that until a manager starts seeing a different game to everyone else.
I don’t think the manager is ever going to have his players under our new way of operating.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(06-04-2025, 08:21 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-04-2025, 07:44 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-04-2025, 07:08 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 08:27 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: If he did so well at Blackburn and Sunderland why was he sacked? The Blackburn's fans' reaction, kindly posted on here by Squid after the home defeat, was telling. I'm afraid they thought him clueless as we ultimately did. At the time I understood why he was appointed but then listening to him spout utter crap time and time again made me wonder if he had actually been interviewed. Surely if he had come out with this drivel about releasing the hand brake, falling in love with the game etc etc the board would and should have realised that all the good work done by CC was in danger of being ripped apart which it ultimately was. Red flags everywhere.
I just hope their latest interview process has been a little more discerning, intelligent and utlimately successful.
Define success? Many people thought minimum play-offs this season others thought not. We missed out by a couple of points, I think this seasons frustration comes from the manner of it happening.
With the relegated teams, other teams with parachute payments in place, free spending Blues & Wrexham, the usual play-off contenders and our current financial constraints what is acceptable and what is success?
I’ve no idea what to expect from Mason nor really what is a fair measurement. Patience may well be required and that’s been in very short supply since Pulis’s relegation season.
Agree. I'd say expectations got raised somewhere between May and October last year. We all knew the awful shape the club was in last season and with player sales expected, personally I thought mid table would be OK. The (last) August window ended with us being in better shape, the great start to the season, our consistent league position etc. all made us believe achieving the play offs was realistic. Then the January signings confirmed our expectations. I've no doubt had CC not left this would have been achieved. I also think the appointment of Eustace, or any steady hand on the tiller, would have seen that target accomplished.
We now have to face a period where our new manager, however good he becomes eventually, is going to have to learn his trade on the job with players that are not yet his chouce and a P and S situationin the background. Patience will be required. I'm actually OK with that until a manager starts seeing a different game to everyone else.
I don’t think the manager is ever going to have his players under our new way of operating. I am sure he'll have plenty of input. What's the point otherwise?
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(06-04-2025, 08:23 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-04-2025, 08:21 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-04-2025, 07:44 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-04-2025, 07:08 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 08:27 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: If he did so well at Blackburn and Sunderland why was he sacked? The Blackburn's fans' reaction, kindly posted on here by Squid after the home defeat, was telling. I'm afraid they thought him clueless as we ultimately did. At the time I understood why he was appointed but then listening to him spout utter crap time and time again made me wonder if he had actually been interviewed. Surely if he had come out with this drivel about releasing the hand brake, falling in love with the game etc etc the board would and should have realised that all the good work done by CC was in danger of being ripped apart which it ultimately was. Red flags everywhere.
I just hope their latest interview process has been a little more discerning, intelligent and utlimately successful.
Define success? Many people thought minimum play-offs this season others thought not. We missed out by a couple of points, I think this seasons frustration comes from the manner of it happening.
With the relegated teams, other teams with parachute payments in place, free spending Blues & Wrexham, the usual play-off contenders and our current financial constraints what is acceptable and what is success?
I’ve no idea what to expect from Mason nor really what is a fair measurement. Patience may well be required and that’s been in very short supply since Pulis’s relegation season.
Agree. I'd say expectations got raised somewhere between May and October last year. We all knew the awful shape the club was in last season and with player sales expected, personally I thought mid table would be OK. The (last) August window ended with us being in better shape, the great start to the season, our consistent league position etc. all made us believe achieving the play offs was realistic. Then the January signings confirmed our expectations. I've no doubt had CC not left this would have been achieved. I also think the appointment of Eustace, or any steady hand on the tiller, would have seen that target accomplished.
We now have to face a period where our new manager, however good he becomes eventually, is going to have to learn his trade on the job with players that are not yet his chouce and a P and S situationin the background. Patience will be required. I'm actually OK with that until a manager starts seeing a different game to everyone else.
I don’t think the manager is ever going to have his players under our new way of operating. I am sure he'll have plenty of input. What's the point otherwise?
There is a big misconception among football fans about the way modern recruitment works.
For the majority of clubs (unless you employ Steve Bruce), gone are the days when a manager gives the Chairman or DoF a name and says sign him. Instead the manager will provide the scouting team with metrics, outputs, stats he wants from a player, recruitment team then find players who hit those parameters, then they watch the players and only at the last point will any consideration be given to the player as a person and whether they'll fit into the squad. Managers just naming players brings in bias and is a sure fire way to miss out on value signings, which is not the way we want to go.
Hence why Nestor was so explicit about the new coach having a shared idea of the game model they want to introduce here. To say the players aren't the managers choice is wrong, he is being given the tools to play the way he wants to play, he's just not involved until later on in identifying who those players are.
Posts: 19,493
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(06-04-2025, 08:58 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (06-04-2025, 08:23 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-04-2025, 08:21 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-04-2025, 07:44 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: (06-04-2025, 07:08 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Define success? Many people thought minimum play-offs this season others thought not. We missed out by a couple of points, I think this seasons frustration comes from the manner of it happening.
With the relegated teams, other teams with parachute payments in place, free spending Blues & Wrexham, the usual play-off contenders and our current financial constraints what is acceptable and what is success?
I’ve no idea what to expect from Mason nor really what is a fair measurement. Patience may well be required and that’s been in very short supply since Pulis’s relegation season.
Agree. I'd say expectations got raised somewhere between May and October last year. We all knew the awful shape the club was in last season and with player sales expected, personally I thought mid table would be OK. The (last) August window ended with us being in better shape, the great start to the season, our consistent league position etc. all made us believe achieving the play offs was realistic. Then the January signings confirmed our expectations. I've no doubt had CC not left this would have been achieved. I also think the appointment of Eustace, or any steady hand on the tiller, would have seen that target accomplished.
We now have to face a period where our new manager, however good he becomes eventually, is going to have to learn his trade on the job with players that are not yet his chouce and a P and S situationin the background. Patience will be required. I'm actually OK with that until a manager starts seeing a different game to everyone else.
I don’t think the manager is ever going to have his players under our new way of operating. I am sure he'll have plenty of input. What's the point otherwise?
There is a big misconception among football fans about the way modern recruitment works.
For the majority of clubs (unless you employ Steve Bruce), gone are the days when a manager gives the Chairman or DoF a name and says sign him. Instead the manager will provide the scouting team with metrics, outputs, stats he wants from a player, recruitment team then find players who hit those parameters, then they watch the players and only at the last point will any consideration be given to the player as a person and whether they'll fit into the squad. Managers just naming players brings in bias and is a sure fire way to miss out on value signings, which is not the way we want to go.
Hence why Nestor was so explicit about the new coach having a shared idea of the game model they want to introduce here. To say the players aren't the managers choice is wrong, he is being given the tools to play the way he wants to play, he's just not involved until later on in identifying who those players are.
Exactly.
Managers will still be given the opportunity to suggest players - Mowbray was given Armstrong for example - but generally recruitment will be a long term process handled by Nestor with a view to a style the team will be built and coached to play… Managers will be given a say in signings and will be given some freedom I suppose on short term loans and quick fixes, but the money will be spent where Nestor and co. say!
|