Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(06-03-2025, 10:13 AM)Squid Wrote: (06-03-2025, 08:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Managers come and go, no owner is is going to listen to random posters on a messageboard with regards to whether a manager should stay or go. I’m always a bit baffled as to why fellow posters think we have so much influence, we don’t. Results within the expectations of the owner will see a manager stay or go 9 times out of 10. There are exceptions like Alan Irvine but again despite the negativity it was results, the fear of losing Prem status and the subsequent potential loss of the sale of the club that got him the sack.
Given I go to home matches, watch the game, clap the decent bits, get mildly miffed at the refs poor decisions on occasion and then tut and perhaps moan a bit at half time to fellow fans if we are playing poorly, I’m not sure either my 25% or 110% support makes a jot of difference to whether Mason, or any other managers tenure makes any difference.
It will be interesting to see how things go, he’s been given a three year contract so I expect the owners don’t want to be making any managerial changes for this year or next at least. Within this ‘data-driven’ approach it becomes increasingly difficult to say whether it’s the manager, coaches, or data analysts that are ultimately responsible for results, this creates its own problems of accountability so whether Mason is a success or not, depends so much more on Nestor and the wider football department than just him.
Maybe fans on a message board don't have much power, but fans in the stadium do.
The noticeable drop in attendances under Ismael hastened his exit.
When fans turned on Bruce, Luton at home, that was his last match.
Finally, the mass exodus following the third Derby goal was the death knell for Mowbray's second spell.
Absolutely. Patel was present at Cov and Derby. The crowd unrest would have been clearly noted. Of course it has an effect.
Posts: 17,077
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-03-2025, 10:16 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 10:13 AM)Squid Wrote: (06-03-2025, 08:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Managers come and go, no owner is is going to listen to random posters on a messageboard with regards to whether a manager should stay or go. I’m always a bit baffled as to why fellow posters think we have so much influence, we don’t. Results within the expectations of the owner will see a manager stay or go 9 times out of 10. There are exceptions like Alan Irvine but again despite the negativity it was results, the fear of losing Prem status and the subsequent potential loss of the sale of the club that got him the sack.
Given I go to home matches, watch the game, clap the decent bits, get mildly miffed at the refs poor decisions on occasion and then tut and perhaps moan a bit at half time to fellow fans if we are playing poorly, I’m not sure either my 25% or 110% support makes a jot of difference to whether Mason, or any other managers tenure makes any difference.
It will be interesting to see how things go, he’s been given a three year contract so I expect the owners don’t want to be making any managerial changes for this year or next at least. Within this ‘data-driven’ approach it becomes increasingly difficult to say whether it’s the manager, coaches, or data analysts that are ultimately responsible for results, this creates its own problems of accountability so whether Mason is a success or not, depends so much more on Nestor and the wider football department than just him.
Maybe fans on a message board don't have much power, but fans in the stadium do.
The noticeable drop in attendances under Ismael hastened his exit.
When fans turned on Bruce, Luton at home, that was his last match.
Finally, the mass exodus following the third Derby goal was the death knell for Mowbray's second spell.
Absolutely. Patel was present at Cov and Derby. The crowd unrest would have been clearly noted. Of course it has an effect.
The examples of Mowbray, Bruce and Val are simply down to managers results and performances, they had a direct effect on the fans either being disgruntled, bored or baffled. If it were just down to fans reactions Pulis would never have been appointed. Positive results will always no matter what the performances are mean a manager will keep his job, failure to get results will see them lose their job, how quickly that happens maybe be hastened by fans reactions. Lose playing pretty football gives you perhaps a couple more months leeway with some fans but it’ll always be results set against the owners expectations that will determine the managers tenure.
When Megson got us up, the club made it clear that the Prem was a free hit in our first season, this gave him leeway with fans that this wasn’t a short term plan. Maybe the club now should give similar parameters with regards to how we are judging success.
Also can those criticising others for using the term ‘data driven’ accept the club are the ones that are putting this message out their to fans not the other way round.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
I've no idea if Mason will prove to be a good choice or not . But I would say the same about anyone we could have realistically appointed.
But now he has been appointed I hope the club and to a lesser extent the fans show him some patience.
This is a more difficult job than most people seem to think it is. I believe we are at least two successful sumer transfer windows from having a viable promotion attaining squad.
That's why I think the most important decisions the club will make this summer will centre around player recruitment.
I'm sure we are capable of being in the race for the play offs next season, but aside from teams deep in relegation trouble, who isn't in the race for the play offs.
I'd prefer we set our sights higher and aim to be in the race for automatic promotion. Although I concede that might not be possible next season.
Posts: 206
Threads: 40
Joined: Apr 2025
(06-03-2025, 10:13 AM)Squid Wrote: (06-03-2025, 08:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Managers come and go, no owner is is going to listen to random posters on a messageboard with regards to whether a manager should stay or go. I’m always a bit baffled as to why fellow posters think we have so much influence, we don’t. Results within the expectations of the owner will see a manager stay or go 9 times out of 10. There are exceptions like Alan Irvine but again despite the negativity it was results, the fear of losing Prem status and the subsequent potential loss of the sale of the club that got him the sack.
Given I go to home matches, watch the game, clap the decent bits, get mildly miffed at the refs poor decisions on occasion and then tut and perhaps moan a bit at half time to fellow fans if we are playing poorly, I’m not sure either my 25% or 110% support makes a jot of difference to whether Mason, or any other managers tenure makes any difference.
It will be interesting to see how things go, he’s been given a three year contract so I expect the owners don’t want to be making any managerial changes for this year or next at least. Within this ‘data-driven’ approach it becomes increasingly difficult to say whether it’s the manager, coaches, or data analysts that are ultimately responsible for results, this creates its own problems of accountability so whether Mason is a success or not, depends so much more on Nestor and the wider football department than just him.
Maybe fans on a message board don't have much power, but fans in the stadium do.
The noticeable drop in attendances under Ismael hastened his exit.
When fans turned on Bruce, Luton at home, that was his last match.
Finally, the mass exodus following the third Derby goal was the death knell for Mowbray's second spell.
I think the majority of fans turned on Bruce, Pardew and Pulis long before they were sacked.
Posts: 2,955
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
I was at Huddersfield when the fans (who are they?! It wasn't me!) turned on Pulis.
It was obvious that he was a dead duck that afternoon.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
Wonder if there's a break clause in the contract, could end getting 2.5 years compo if things go tits up.
Good luck to the new guy, I think he'll need it. If he manages top 8 I think he'll have done OK. Play offs and the 3 year deal will be a masterstroke.
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(06-03-2025, 10:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (06-03-2025, 10:16 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (06-03-2025, 10:13 AM)Squid Wrote: (06-03-2025, 08:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Managers come and go, no owner is is going to listen to random posters on a messageboard with regards to whether a manager should stay or go. I’m always a bit baffled as to why fellow posters think we have so much influence, we don’t. Results within the expectations of the owner will see a manager stay or go 9 times out of 10. There are exceptions like Alan Irvine but again despite the negativity it was results, the fear of losing Prem status and the subsequent potential loss of the sale of the club that got him the sack.
Given I go to home matches, watch the game, clap the decent bits, get mildly miffed at the refs poor decisions on occasion and then tut and perhaps moan a bit at half time to fellow fans if we are playing poorly, I’m not sure either my 25% or 110% support makes a jot of difference to whether Mason, or any other managers tenure makes any difference.
It will be interesting to see how things go, he’s been given a three year contract so I expect the owners don’t want to be making any managerial changes for this year or next at least. Within this ‘data-driven’ approach it becomes increasingly difficult to say whether it’s the manager, coaches, or data analysts that are ultimately responsible for results, this creates its own problems of accountability so whether Mason is a success or not, depends so much more on Nestor and the wider football department than just him.
Maybe fans on a message board don't have much power, but fans in the stadium do.
The noticeable drop in attendances under Ismael hastened his exit.
When fans turned on Bruce, Luton at home, that was his last match.
Finally, the mass exodus following the third Derby goal was the death knell for Mowbray's second spell.
Absolutely. Patel was present at Cov and Derby. The crowd unrest would have been clearly noted. Of course it has an effect.
The examples of Mowbray, Bruce and Val are simply down to managers results and performances, they had a direct effect on the fans either being disgruntled, bored or baffled. If it were just down to fans reactions Pulis would never have been appointed. Positive results will always no matter what the performances are mean a manager will keep his job, failure to get results will see them lose their job, how quickly that happens maybe be hastened by fans reactions. Lose playing pretty football gives you perhaps a couple more months leeway with some fans but it’ll always be results set against the owners expectations that will determine the managers tenure.
When Megson got us up, the club made it clear that the Prem was a free hit in our first season, this gave him leeway with fans that this wasn’t a short term plan. Maybe the club now should give similar parameters with regards to how we are judging success.
Also can those criticising others for using the term ‘data driven’ accept the club are the ones that are putting this message out their to fans not the other way round.
People don't have a clue what data driven means and what data is being used to drive things. That's my issue about people using data driven to bash the club with.
Posts: 266
Threads: 14
Joined: Oct 2023
Reputation:
6
(06-03-2025, 11:41 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I was at Huddersfield when the fans (who are they?! It wasn't me!) turned on Pulis.
It was obvious that he was a dead duck that afternoon.
I was there when the fans (it wasn't me either!) sang 'You're not so special, we lose every week' to the Stoke crowd. That was the end of Irvine.
I doubt whether opinions on a message board would influence decisions at the club, but live protests definitely do.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
Trouble with 'data driven' is that in the real world it can mean fugg all...
Lots of countries took a data driven approach to COVID... Whereas some took a gut driven feeling and closed down super quickly.
Obviously they can't have used data on Mason's managerial performances as there's not really any. Maybe they used data on the fitness / improvement of Spurs players instead?
There's not really any metric for hiring a head coach outside of his winnings record / weighted by club level / extenuating circumstances...
So I can't see how he is a data driven appointment.
Posts: 17,077
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-03-2025, 11:52 AM)Tiptonmon Wrote: (06-03-2025, 11:41 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I was at Huddersfield when the fans (who are they?! It wasn't me!) turned on Pulis.
It was obvious that he was a dead duck that afternoon.
I was there when the fans (it wasn't me either!) sang 'You're not so special, we lose every week' to the Stoke crowd. That was the end of Irvine.
I doubt whether opinions on a message board would influence decisions at the club, but live protests definitely do.
Not to the degree that is made out or as I said AI and Pulis would never have got the job in the first place.
|