When exactly did it go wrong under Lai?
#1
It was probably always going to end in tears, but he (or whoever was actually running the show), did actually try to run us in a reasonably logical manner at first.

At the time John Williams seemed a sensible appointment as CEO and when that didn't work out, Lai was utterly correct to sack him and bring Jenkins back.

Lai was right to employ Darren Moore over Dean Smith and Jenkins helped get the personnel in who made the 2019/20 promotion happen. Appointing Allardyce was a reasonable decision too.

IMO, it all seemed to go wrong at some point during COVID, when they tried to sell of Pereira for stupid money, which instantly devalued one of the club's greatest assets. From then on, it seemed to be hand in the till time. 

Just my thoughts and on a very slow Albion news day, I'd be interested in hearing some alternative perspectives.
Reply
#2
(05-21-2025, 09:21 AM)Squid Wrote: It was probably always going to end in tears, but he (or whoever was actually running the show), did actually try to run us in a reasonably logical manner at first.

At the time John Williams seemed a sensible appointment as CEO and when that didn't work out, Lai was utterly correct to sack him and bring Jenkins back.

Lai was right to employ Darren Moore over Dean Smith and Jenkins helped get the personnel in who made the 2019/20 promotion happen. Appointing Allardyce was a reasonable decision too.

IMO, it all seemed to go wrong at some point during COVID, when they tried to sell of Pereira for stupid money, which instantly devalued one of the club's greatest assets. From then on, it seemed to be hand in the till time. 

Just my thoughts and on a very slow Albion news day, I'd be interested in hearing some alternative perspectives.
I'm no spurt but wasn't it to do with some change within China about money in and out?
Reply
#3
People will correct me I'm sure but from memory was that around the time China as a whole started to withdraw interest and backing  in foreign football clubs. As much as I hate Lai I think the hand in the till was a symptom of increasing pressure from those above him, to scrape back any amount of money possible.
Reply
#4
Summer of 2017 for me. We'd spent the previous two seasons building a really strong foundation of a side that never looked too threatened by relegation and we'd just finished 10th. It was probably the peak of our PL irrelevance for fans of other clubs, never at the bottom, never challenging to win a cup or darkening any European doorways. That was our summer to go shake hands with Pulis and bring in a Patrick Viera, Graham Potter (just names touted at the time) "progressive" coach to try and develop our style of play at the higher level and change our model to signing the likes of Eze, Olise, Wharton etc.

As it happened Lai was so petrified of getting relegated he stuck with Pulis and the whole thing went south. We'd dismantled the scouting network that helped us identify Yacob, Dorrans, McAuley, Mulumbu and ended up struggling to find our arse with both hands.

Pardew, enough said. Darren Moore was the right choice, Graeme Jones as it turned out, was not. That side really should have been promoted in 2018. Huge kick in the nads is not only were we shooting ourselves in the foot during this period, in losing to Villa in the POs we gave them the shot in the arm required to reestablish themselves in the upper reaches of the PL and playing European football again - wankers.

Bilic was a poor manager but got outrageously lucky with one of the best players we've ever had at Championship level. He ended up letting basic standards slip to the extent that Allardyce needed 6-weeks to get the team fit enough to play PL football, let alone try and win a match.

From here on it's been a total fucking mess as the Chinese fully lost interest. I think the appointment of Ismael was the right idea, he at least had a plan (debatable whether it was the right one), but he came tried to work with players in a system and we were tough to beat. His big downfall was that all our chances fell to Jordan Hugill and to this day I can remember three sitters off the top of my head in games we drew that would have kept us in the POs and Val in a job. Who knows where we'd have ended up if we had a Maja then, or Dike didn't fall to pieces after being rushed in as a last chance throw of the dice.

The Bruce appointment was a shambles and he seemed a nice guy despite dismantling all the good work that Val had done. He took us from a functional team that didn't concede or lose many, to a team that still couldn't score because we had no strikers but was unfit and ridiculously easy to play against - more on this later.

Corberan - just magic, not a lot else needs saying. Valencia's timing could have been better, would have been great to see what he could have done for a couple of seasons under the Bilkul leadership.

Mowbray - pure crap. Set about dismantling the brilliant work of his predecessor in the same vein as Bruce, but did it whilst spouting patronising and in the end just downright bitter nonsense about his players in the press. Made a fool of himself and shouldn't be welcomed back through our door any time soon.

I hold out hope that the next appointment can't be as bad as the last one and I am cautiously optimistic we're through the worst of it. Sadly though, our worst period for a generation has coincided with the gap between the Championship and the PL being as big as it ever has been. It's a seriously long road back.
Reply
#5
(05-21-2025, 09:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Summer of 2017 for me. We'd spent the previous two seasons building a really strong foundation of a side that never looked too threatened by relegation and we'd just finished 10th. It was probably the peak of our PL irrelevance for fans of other clubs, never at the bottom, never challenging to win a cup or darkening any European doorways. That was our summer to go shake hands with Pulis and bring in a Patrick Viera, Graham Potter (just names touted at the time) "progressive" coach to try and develop our style of play at the higher level and change our model to signing the likes of Eze, Olise, Wharton etc.

As it happened Lai was so petrified of getting relegated he stuck with Pulis and the whole thing went south. We'd dismantled the scouting network that helped us identify Yacob, Dorrans, McAuley, Mulumbu and ended up struggling to find our arse with both hands.

Pardew, enough said. Darren Moore was the right choice, Graeme Jones as it turned out, was not. That side really should have been promoted in 2018. Huge kick in the nads is not only were we shooting ourselves in the foot during this period, in losing to Villa in the POs we gave them the shot in the arm required to reestablish themselves in the upper reaches of the PL and playing European football again - wankers.

Bilic was a poor manager but got outrageously lucky with one of the best players we've ever had at Championship level. He ended up letting basic standards slip to the extent that Allardyce needed 6-weeks to get the team fit enough to play PL football, let alone try and win a match.

From here on it's been a total fucking mess as the Chinese fully lost interest. I think the appointment of Ismael was the right idea, he at least had a plan (debatable whether it was the right one), but he came tried to work with players in a system and we were tough to beat. His big downfall was that all our chances fell to Jordan Hugill and to this day I can remember three sitters off the top of my head in games we drew that would have kept us in the POs and Val in a job. Who knows where we'd have ended up if we had a Maja then, or Dike didn't fall to pieces after being rushed in as a last chance throw of the dice.

The Bruce appointment was a shambles and he seemed a nice guy despite dismantling all the good work that Val had done. He took us from a functional team that didn't concede or lose many, to a team that still couldn't score because we had no strikers but was unfit and ridiculously easy to play against - more on this later.

Corberan - just magic, not a lot else needs saying. Valencia's timing could have been better, would have been great to see what he could have done for a couple of seasons under the Bilkul leadership.

Mowbray - pure crap. Set about dismantling the brilliant work of his predecessor in the same vein as Bruce, but did it whilst spouting patronising and in the end just downright bitter nonsense about his players in the press. Made a fool of himself and shouldn't be welcomed back through our door any time soon.

I hold out hope that the next appointment can't be as bad as the last one and I am cautiously optimistic we're through the worst of it. Sadly though, our worst period for a generation has coincided with the gap between the Championship and the PL being as big as it ever has been. It's a seriously long road back.

Good summary
Reply
#6
(05-21-2025, 09:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Summer of 2017 for me. We'd spent the previous two seasons building a really strong foundation of a side that never looked too threatened by relegation and we'd just finished 10th. It was probably the peak of our PL irrelevance for fans of other clubs, never at the bottom, never challenging to win a cup or darkening any European doorways. That was our summer to go shake hands with Pulis and bring in a Patrick Viera, Graham Potter (just names touted at the time) "progressive" coach to try and develop our style of play at the higher level and change our model to signing the likes of Eze, Olise, Wharton etc.

As it happened Lai was so petrified of getting relegated he stuck with Pulis and the whole thing went south. We'd dismantled the scouting network that helped us identify Yacob, Dorrans, McAuley, Mulumbu and ended up struggling to find our arse with both hands.

Pardew, enough said. Darren Moore was the right choice, Graeme Jones as it turned out, was not. That side really should have been promoted in 2018. Huge kick in the nads is not only were we shooting ourselves in the foot during this period, in losing to Villa in the POs we gave them the shot in the arm required to reestablish themselves in the upper reaches of the PL and playing European football again - wankers.

Bilic was a poor manager but got outrageously lucky with one of the best players we've ever had at Championship level. He ended up letting basic standards slip to the extent that Allardyce needed 6-weeks to get the team fit enough to play PL football, let alone try and win a match.

From here on it's been a total fucking mess as the Chinese fully lost interest. I think the appointment of Ismael was the right idea, he at least had a plan (debatable whether it was the right one), but he came tried to work with players in a system and we were tough to beat. His big downfall was that all our chances fell to Jordan Hugill and to this day I can remember three sitters off the top of my head in games we drew that would have kept us in the POs and Val in a job. Who knows where we'd have ended up if we had a Maja then, or Dike didn't fall to pieces after being rushed in as a last chance throw of the dice.

The Bruce appointment was a shambles and he seemed a nice guy despite dismantling all the good work that Val had done. He took us from a functional team that didn't concede or lose many, to a team that still couldn't score because we had no strikers but was unfit and ridiculously easy to play against - more on this later.

Corberan - just magic, not a lot else needs saying. Valencia's timing could have been better, would have been great to see what he could have done for a couple of seasons under the Bilkul leadership.

Mowbray - pure crap. Set about dismantling the brilliant work of his predecessor in the same vein as Bruce, but did it whilst spouting patronising and in the end just downright bitter nonsense about his players in the press. Made a fool of himself and shouldn't be welcomed back through our door any time soon.

I hold out hope that the next appointment can't be as bad as the last one and I am cautiously optimistic we're through the worst of it. Sadly though, our worst period for a generation has coincided with the gap between the Championship and the PL being as big as it ever has been. It's a seriously long road back.

Excellent summary indeed.
Reply
#7
(05-21-2025, 09:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Summer of 2017 for me. We'd spent the previous two seasons building a really strong foundation of a side that never looked too threatened by relegation and we'd just finished 10th. It was probably the peak of our PL irrelevance for fans of other clubs, never at the bottom, never challenging to win a cup or darkening any European doorways. That was our summer to go shake hands with Pulis and bring in a Patrick Viera, Graham Potter (just names touted at the time) "progressive" coach to try and develop our style of play at the higher level and change our model to signing the likes of Eze, Olise, Wharton etc.

As it happened Lai was so petrified of getting relegated he stuck with Pulis and the whole thing went south. We'd dismantled the scouting network that helped us identify Yacob, Dorrans, McAuley, Mulumbu and ended up struggling to find our arse with both hands.

Pardew, enough said. Darren Moore was the right choice, Graeme Jones as it turned out, was not. That side really should have been promoted in 2018. Huge kick in the nads is not only were we shooting ourselves in the foot during this period, in losing to Villa in the POs we gave them the shot in the arm required to reestablish themselves in the upper reaches of the PL and playing European football again - wankers.

Bilic was a poor manager but got outrageously lucky with one of the best players we've ever had at Championship level. He ended up letting basic standards slip to the extent that Allardyce needed 6-weeks to get the team fit enough to play PL football, let alone try and win a match.

From here on it's been a total fucking mess as the Chinese fully lost interest. I think the appointment of Ismael was the right idea, he at least had a plan (debatable whether it was the right one), but he came tried to work with players in a system and we were tough to beat. His big downfall was that all our chances fell to Jordan Hugill and to this day I can remember three sitters off the top of my head in games we drew that would have kept us in the POs and Val in a job. Who knows where we'd have ended up if we had a Maja then, or Dike didn't fall to pieces after being rushed in as a last chance throw of the dice.

The Bruce appointment was a shambles and he seemed a nice guy despite dismantling all the good work that Val had done. He took us from a functional team that didn't concede or lose many, to a team that still couldn't score because we had no strikers but was unfit and ridiculously easy to play against - more on this later.

Corberan - just magic, not a lot else needs saying. Valencia's timing could have been better, would have been great to see what he could have done for a couple of seasons under the Bilkul leadership.

Mowbray - pure crap. Set about dismantling the brilliant work of his predecessor in the same vein as Bruce, but did it whilst spouting patronising and in the end just downright bitter nonsense about his players in the press. Made a fool of himself and shouldn't be welcomed back through our door any time soon.

I hold out hope that the next appointment can't be as bad as the last one and I am cautiously optimistic we're through the worst of it. Sadly though, our worst period for a generation has coincided with the gap between the Championship and the PL being as big as it ever has been. It's a seriously long road back.

Can't argue with much of this and winced at quite a bit of it.

Where I would debate slightly, is that I think Bilic while helped hugely by Pereira, was a decent manager. His game management in particular was pretty decent.

However, for whatever reason, I think he completely lost interest over the summer and should have been replaced then. Keeping that team up would have always been very difficult, but buying better players in the summer and getting them fit would have helped.

Agree on Hughill. An utter donkey of a player. Also on that 2018 team. Madness to not be promoted with Gayle and J-Rod upfront.
Reply
#8
(05-21-2025, 09:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Summer of 2017 for me. We'd spent the previous two seasons building a really strong foundation of a side that never looked too threatened by relegation and we'd just finished 10th. It was probably the peak of our PL irrelevance for fans of other clubs, never at the bottom, never challenging to win a cup or darkening any European doorways. That was our summer to go shake hands with Pulis and bring in a Patrick Viera, Graham Potter (just names touted at the time) "progressive" coach to try and develop our style of play at the higher level and change our model to signing the likes of Eze, Olise, Wharton etc.

As it happened Lai was so petrified of getting relegated he stuck with Pulis and the whole thing went south. We'd dismantled the scouting network that helped us identify Yacob, Dorrans, McAuley, Mulumbu and ended up struggling to find our arse with both hands.

Pardew, enough said. Darren Moore was the right choice, Graeme Jones as it turned out, was not. That side really should have been promoted in 2018. Huge kick in the nads is not only were we shooting ourselves in the foot during this period, in losing to Villa in the POs we gave them the shot in the arm required to reestablish themselves in the upper reaches of the PL and playing European football again - wankers.

Bilic was a poor manager but got outrageously lucky with one of the best players we've ever had at Championship level. He ended up letting basic standards slip to the extent that Allardyce needed 6-weeks to get the team fit enough to play PL football, let alone try and win a match.

From here on it's been a total fucking mess as the Chinese fully lost interest. I think the appointment of Ismael was the right idea, he at least had a plan (debatable whether it was the right one), but he came tried to work with players in a system and we were tough to beat. His big downfall was that all our chances fell to Jordan Hugill and to this day I can remember three sitters off the top of my head in games we drew that would have kept us in the POs and Val in a job. Who knows where we'd have ended up if we had a Maja then, or Dike didn't fall to pieces after being rushed in as a last chance throw of the dice.

The Bruce appointment was a shambles and he seemed a nice guy despite dismantling all the good work that Val had done. He took us from a functional team that didn't concede or lose many, to a team that still couldn't score because we had no strikers but was unfit and ridiculously easy to play against - more on this later.

Corberan - just magic, not a lot else needs saying. Valencia's timing could have been better, would have been great to see what he could have done for a couple of seasons under the Bilkul leadership.

Mowbray - pure crap. Set about dismantling the brilliant work of his predecessor in the same vein as Bruce, but did it whilst spouting patronising and in the end just downright bitter nonsense about his players in the press. Made a fool of himself and shouldn't be welcomed back through our door any time soon.

I hold out hope that the next appointment can't be as bad as the last one and I am cautiously optimistic we're through the worst of it. Sadly though, our worst period for a generation has coincided with the gap between the Championship and the PL being as big as it ever has been. It's a seriously long road back.

Wow.what a superb summary Ted..never agreed to a post so much ..I have to say I’m a bit sceptical about Bilkull at the moment .cant believe they gave Tony a 2&1/2 year contract..really hope we get this 
Appointment right..such an important summer..
Reply
#9
(05-21-2025, 09:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Summer of 2017 for me. We'd spent the previous two seasons building a really strong foundation of a side that never looked too threatened by relegation and we'd just finished 10th. It was probably the peak of our PL irrelevance for fans of other clubs, never at the bottom, never challenging to win a cup or darkening any European doorways. That was our summer to go shake hands with Pulis and bring in a Patrick Viera, Graham Potter (just names touted at the time) "progressive" coach to try and develop our style of play at the higher level and change our model to signing the likes of Eze, Olise, Wharton etc.

As it happened Lai was so petrified of getting relegated he stuck with Pulis and the whole thing went south. We'd dismantled the scouting network that helped us identify Yacob, Dorrans, McAuley, Mulumbu and ended up struggling to find our arse with both hands.

Pardew, enough said. Darren Moore was the right choice, Graeme Jones as it turned out, was not. That side really should have been promoted in 2018. Huge kick in the nads is not only were we shooting ourselves in the foot during this period, in losing to Villa in the POs we gave them the shot in the arm required to reestablish themselves in the upper reaches of the PL and playing European football again - wankers.

Bilic was a poor manager but got outrageously lucky with one of the best players we've ever had at Championship level. He ended up letting basic standards slip to the extent that Allardyce needed 6-weeks to get the team fit enough to play PL football, let alone try and win a match.

From here on it's been a total fucking mess as the Chinese fully lost interest. I think the appointment of Ismael was the right idea, he at least had a plan (debatable whether it was the right one), but he came tried to work with players in a system and we were tough to beat. His big downfall was that all our chances fell to Jordan Hugill and to this day I can remember three sitters off the top of my head in games we drew that would have kept us in the POs and Val in a job. Who knows where we'd have ended up if we had a Maja then, or Dike didn't fall to pieces after being rushed in as a last chance throw of the dice.

The Bruce appointment was a shambles and he seemed a nice guy despite dismantling all the good work that Val had done. He took us from a functional team that didn't concede or lose many, to a team that still couldn't score because we had no strikers but was unfit and ridiculously easy to play against - more on this later.

Corberan - just magic, not a lot else needs saying. Valencia's timing could have been better, would have been great to see what he could have done for a couple of seasons under the Bilkul leadership.

Mowbray - pure crap. Set about dismantling the brilliant work of his predecessor in the same vein as Bruce, but did it whilst spouting patronising and in the end just downright bitter nonsense about his players in the press. Made a fool of himself and shouldn't be welcomed back through our door any time soon.

I hold out hope that the next appointment can't be as bad as the last one and I am cautiously optimistic we're through the worst of it. Sadly though, our worst period for a generation has coincided with the gap between the Championship and the PL being as big as it ever has been. It's a seriously long road back.

Maybe replacing Pulis then would have worked but maybe not. I recall Palace, a similar size to us, taking on a sexy progressive coach or two when they thought they were established in the Prem but they soon went back to Hodgson when it started to go wrong
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#10
(05-21-2025, 10:58 AM)Squid Wrote:
(05-21-2025, 09:42 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Summer of 2017 for me. We'd spent the previous two seasons building a really strong foundation of a side that never looked too threatened by relegation and we'd just finished 10th. It was probably the peak of our PL irrelevance for fans of other clubs, never at the bottom, never challenging to win a cup or darkening any European doorways. That was our summer to go shake hands with Pulis and bring in a Patrick Viera, Graham Potter (just names touted at the time) "progressive" coach to try and develop our style of play at the higher level and change our model to signing the likes of Eze, Olise, Wharton etc.

As it happened Lai was so petrified of getting relegated he stuck with Pulis and the whole thing went south. We'd dismantled the scouting network that helped us identify Yacob, Dorrans, McAuley, Mulumbu and ended up struggling to find our arse with both hands.

Pardew, enough said. Darren Moore was the right choice, Graeme Jones as it turned out, was not. That side really should have been promoted in 2018. Huge kick in the nads is not only were we shooting ourselves in the foot during this period, in losing to Villa in the POs we gave them the shot in the arm required to reestablish themselves in the upper reaches of the PL and playing European football again - wankers.

Bilic was a poor manager but got outrageously lucky with one of the best players we've ever had at Championship level. He ended up letting basic standards slip to the extent that Allardyce needed 6-weeks to get the team fit enough to play PL football, let alone try and win a match.

From here on it's been a total fucking mess as the Chinese fully lost interest. I think the appointment of Ismael was the right idea, he at least had a plan (debatable whether it was the right one), but he came tried to work with players in a system and we were tough to beat. His big downfall was that all our chances fell to Jordan Hugill and to this day I can remember three sitters off the top of my head in games we drew that would have kept us in the POs and Val in a job. Who knows where we'd have ended up if we had a Maja then, or Dike didn't fall to pieces after being rushed in as a last chance throw of the dice.

The Bruce appointment was a shambles and he seemed a nice guy despite dismantling all the good work that Val had done. He took us from a functional team that didn't concede or lose many, to a team that still couldn't score because we had no strikers but was unfit and ridiculously easy to play against - more on this later.

Corberan - just magic, not a lot else needs saying. Valencia's timing could have been better, would have been great to see what he could have done for a couple of seasons under the Bilkul leadership.

Mowbray - pure crap. Set about dismantling the brilliant work of his predecessor in the same vein as Bruce, but did it whilst spouting patronising and in the end just downright bitter nonsense about his players in the press. Made a fool of himself and shouldn't be welcomed back through our door any time soon.

I hold out hope that the next appointment can't be as bad as the last one and I am cautiously optimistic we're through the worst of it. Sadly though, our worst period for a generation has coincided with the gap between the Championship and the PL being as big as it ever has been. It's a seriously long road back.

Can't argue with much of this and winced at quite a bit of it.

Where I would debate slightly, is that I think Bilic while helped hugely by Pereira, was a decent manager. His game management in particular was pretty decent.

However, for whatever reason, I think he completely lost interest over the summer and should have been replaced then. Keeping that team up would have always been very difficult, but buying better players in the summer and getting them fit would have helped.

Agree on Hughill. An utter donkey of a player. Also on that 2018 team. Madness to not be promoted with Gayle and J-Rod upfront.

I think there were a couple of changes which completely screwed us over but TJ pretty much nails it.

When Lai purchased us in 2016 it was towards the end of the Chinese government's push for overseas investment in football. Clubs were being bought in 2014-16 regularly and it was accompanying some substantial investment in the game. As ever we were late to the party, and despite us having a solid season in 2016-17, our 10th place finish coincided with a downturn in the Chinese economy and the CCP deciding to retain money in the country and invest in the domestic game leaving Lai without political capital through our ownership and a reduced appetite for his "football towns" project. Instead of therefore providing backing for our progression we went risk adverse, extended TP's contract and ended up being rewarded with relegation. 

Through 18-19 the government were actively encouraging investors to sell foreign investment vehicles and again this coincided with our relegation. Several leading Chinese owners were forced to divest their clubs and big sponsorship deals at the likes of Atletico Madrid and Milan were pulled. Lai was caught in the tough situation of being told to sell the club from above but also seeing his asset having depreciated by more than half. Whilst we managed to bounce back before the PPs ran out Covid had hit at the worst possible time making it practically impossible for him to sell the club at a time when our value and publicity was high. As it became increasingly obvious we would not survive the season, Plan B emerged, and knowing the financial world had changed and he'd be unlikely to recoup his investment even with another promotion the focus changed to extracting as much money has he could. Chinese appointees all over the board and dodgy goings on AOTS behind the scenes. Getting as much money back to China seemed to be the sole ambition whilst actively selling the club to the highest bidder.

Whilst Lai was indeed a terrible owner, he was beset with misfortune. He made mistakes, but the external factors around government policy, the Chinese economic downturn, Covid and the financial challenges in the following years compounded things further.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)