So farewell then Grady
#11
(05-20-2025, 09:07 PM)aj21 Wrote: Could still end up a good player. He's someone that needed a manager and he had 6 in his time at the club. Carlos got something out of him but he often played in the centre when really he should have been nothing but a winger. Didn't have the brain or energy to play in the middle, should have just focused on being a winger. I'm sure he'll get a decent move and have some magic moments but remain inconsistent.

I tend to agree. He certainly didn't have the brain to play central.  Summed up by that stray pass against Southampton away in the play_offs. Then we folded, which is different story.
Reply
#12
I genuinely think people are watching a different player sometimes. He's one of our most productive players per 90 mins but his last 3 years have been blighted by injury and because he is such a good player, never finding a position in the forward line, and rather being used wherever we needed someone to fit in. I'll miss him anyway. Shame we couldn't get him on reduced terms, don't think he'll be short of offers.
Reply
#13
When Grady came he was fantastic and that's why he commanded a high fee.
He was on fire during his loan spell. Everyone believed we had got a special talent.
He then got injured after 6 months and never come close to getting back to the levels he was at.when he first came. He had the occasional 5 minute spell in a game but often went missing and often didn't look fit or interested. That is the player we've had for the last two season. Flashes of brilliance for 5 minutes once in a while, injuries and uninterested performances.
It's time for him to move on, we need new faces who want to graft and are enthusiastic and proud to wear the shirt. Unfortunately he no longer fits the bill.
Reply
#14
I'm not convinced he ever wanted to join us on a permanent basis, and that he felt West Ham pushed him out the door. His desire and commitment certainly suggested that was the case.

We should have had his best years, but he never lived up to the potential he showed while on loan. I can see him joining a lower Prem team, picking up a huge wage for mainly being on the bench, and showing occasional glimpses of brilliance.
Reply
#15
(05-21-2025, 06:04 AM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote: I'm not convinced he ever wanted to join us on a permanent basis, and that he felt West Ham pushed him out the door. His desire and commitment certainly suggested that was the case.

We should have had his best years, but he never lived up to the potential he showed while on loan. I can see him joining a lower Prem team, picking up a huge wage for mainly being on the bench, and showing occasional glimpses of brilliance.

This. No axe to grind with him, but for whatever reason beyond his brilliant loan spell (alongside Pereira as mentioned ad nauseum) it has simply never truly worked out for him here. 

A shame to make such a big loss on the lad, of course. But when he isn't in your first XI, is most likely at the top end of the wage bill, has had fitness issues, and yet most importantly you still can't work out where/how best to play him after five seasons you have to wonder what the rationale could be for keeping him. 

Good luck Grady.
Reply
#16
(05-20-2025, 10:51 PM)Jacko Wrote: I genuinely think people are watching a different player sometimes. He's one of our most productive players per 90 mins but his last 3 years have been blighted by injury and because he is such a good player, never finding a position in the forward line, and rather being used wherever we needed someone to fit in. I'll miss him anyway. Shame we couldn't get him on reduced terms, don't think he'll be short of offers.

Vastly more popular in the stands then online. I've said previously that there's no point holding the money we paid for him over his head, as we weren't run by sensible people when we bought him. Also, aside from under Corberán, the club has largely been a mess too. Under Corberán, he was decent more often than not and made more match-winning contributions then people realise.

I wish him all the best.
Reply
#17
(05-20-2025, 09:30 PM)Old Fart Wrote: He's never looked fully fit to me. 

If he lost about 20 lbs, and concentrated on getting super fit especially, so that he could beat an opponent over the first three yards, he would transform his performance. 

Instead his first touch was either great or crap, he thought he could beat one or two opponents in tight positions, but couldn't.  And that led to him losing the ball in potentially dangerous situations for us. 

He certainly has the brain to be a good player, he's just not put the effort in for his body to be able to  carry out the plan with a burst of speed.
He never looked happy or confident, once Perriera left. Always looked like he was trying, but never really got to grips with his decision making, consistently trying to beat one man too many instead of picking the pass, having taken a couple out the game and left them on their arse. 
Have to be honest though, whilst I wouldn't have always put him on my team sheet, whenever he was picked, a bit of me always hoped this would be the day.
He had his moments though and was far from being a terrible signing, just never reached his potential.
Reply
#18
15 g/a last season and pivot in us reaching the POs. No surprise we looked far worse as an attacking force without him this season.

Wish him will, not his fault Bilic and those in charge at the time were idiots with the transfer fee.
Reply
#19
occasionally good, mostly useless, thankfully gone
Reply
#20
(05-21-2025, 06:04 AM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote: I'm not convinced he ever wanted to join us on a permanent basis, and that he felt West Ham pushed him out the door. His desire and commitment certainly suggested that was the case.

We should have had his best years, but he never lived up to the potential he showed while on loan. I can see him joining a lower Prem team, picking up a huge wage for mainly being on the bench, and showing occasional glimpses of brilliance.

I too agree with this. I think his loan performances were largely driven by his efforts to earn minutes at West Ham. I don't think his skills make up for his slightness any more, opponents know he's not very strong.

A few weeks ago, the club's social media posted a video where players were asked to name the best teammate they'd ever played with. Grady, rather wistfully, said "Matheus" — which felt quite telling. I also remember a preseason friendly at Crewe during Bruce’s time, where he looked visibly uncomfortable with the fans singing his name while he was taking corners. He seemed almost embarrassed by the attention. 

I like him as a player but there's better value out there, I'm sure.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: