How does this work?
#51
(05-12-2025, 01:35 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-12-2025, 12:41 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(05-12-2025, 12:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Starts with condescending new terminology that he picked up in the Times and then criticises everyone else for not finding a solution the problem that has been with us since the 90s.

(05-12-2025, 12:20 PM)Jacko Wrote: Sir Kier has started his lurch towards Enoch Powell I see...

He can expect your vote then next time I presume

Bazinga!!

When its difficult to defend the insults come out. Come on,  straighten up that red rosette, dry your eyes and give it your best shot Champ.

Can't say my best shot is needed in this case - you are a dyed in the wool anti-immigration party voter, this policy should be right up your street.

Incorrect, but keep them coming. 

So you'll defend Labour on the smallest policy detail in seemingly every aspect of governance, but not this massive lurch to the right? I wonder why  Big Grin
Reply
#52
Fundamentally the problem with Labour in the care sector is that wages are low for a job that can be very demanding( it should be noted it can be very rewarding)

It doesn't matter who does the work, staff turnover will be high when wages are as low as they currently are.
Reply
#53
(05-12-2025, 02:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Who's paying for the British care workers to be trained? Who's paying for more of the NHS budget to be spent on trying to cover gaps in social care? What's the actual plan here?

Same with wanting to build, what's the point in planning reform if there's not enough labour to build the things you've planned?

All of these take time BB and I see it as announcing parts of the jigsaw when they are ready. I agree there needs to be a lot more to fill the gaps that are there in the way of funding and training. The former being the main problem, when we haven't got a fund it is difficult to provide funding.

(05-12-2025, 02:37 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Fundamentally the problem with Labour in the care sector is that wages are low for a job that can be very demanding( it should be noted it can be very rewarding)

It doesn't matter who does the work, staff turnover will be high when wages are as low as they currently are.

Hence my comment around needing to see this FPA. That is the next piece of the social care jigsaw.
Reply
#54
Labour churn is a fact of life in lower paid occupations where there are perennial shortages. It used to be over 100% in call centres in the 2000s FFS. Strawman argument.

Care, like retail is entry level to the labour market. Legal immigrants are generally more motivated to self improvement (FACT borne out by vocational attainment) so yes, they very often move on to better paid work.

As far as training is concerned, see my point earlier re the Apprenticeship Levy which you've ignored. And listen to the Care Sector FFS - the minimum wage is virtually £25K now - there is no such thing as "cheap labour". When local authority funding rises less than the Minimum Wage (let alone NI increases) how on Earth can the Care Sector afford to pay more?

Government is difficult, isn't it? Playing cynical political games on an issue like this is pretty pathetic when you see just how far in the opposite direction Keir has pivoted from his previous stated positions.

(05-12-2025, 02:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'd have more sympathy in your defence of the carer caps if there was a plan to actually address the issues of local authority spending on social care and the huge constraints put on the NHS by a lack of adequate social care provisions to release patients into, but this government have kicked that into the long grass.

Who's paying for the British care workers to be trained? Who's paying for more of the NHS budget to be spent on trying to cover gaps in social care? What's the actual plan here?

Same with wanting to build, what's the point in planning reform if there's not enough labour to build the things you've planned?

+1000
Reply
#55
(05-12-2025, 02:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I'd have more sympathy in your defence of the carer caps if there was a plan to actually address the issues of local authority spending on social care and the huge constraints put on the NHS by a lack of adequate social care provisions to release patients into, but this government have kicked that into the long grass.

Who's paying for the British care workers to be trained? Who's paying for more of the NHS budget to be spent on trying to cover gaps in social care? What's the actual plan here?

Same with wanting to build, what's the point in planning reform if there's not enough labour to build the things you've planned?

Is it right introducing a policy of cutting PIP without an impact statement? Is it right to have no idea how much extra pressure this will put on other areas like social care and local authorities? Is it right to proclaim you’re going to find thousands of jobs for the sick and disabled, despite numerous experts and organisations saying it’s not realistic? 

This government has a now undistinguished history of shouting policies piously from a lectern without ever showing their workings out, the impact they will cause or any real solutions. 

Working people. Working people, a changing world, working people, a changing world ad nauseam.
Reply
#56
They're making an already massive problem worse and have no strategy to solve the problem despite literally commissioning a report in the summer that told them to hurry up and fix the damn problem.

What this strategy will end up with is more local authority cuts, more council tax rises and more money given to the NHS spent on things that aren't the NHS's responsibility. They've had years to plan for this and it's extremely worrying that they've been blindsided by it. Dilnot was commissioned how many years ago and they've not even bothered to go back to that, we have to wait until 2028 at the earliest all the while making it more expensive?
Reply
#57
(05-12-2025, 02:45 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They're making an already massive problem worse and have no strategy to solve the problem despite literally commissioning a report in the summer that told them to hurry up and fix the damn problem.

What this strategy will end up with is more local authority cuts, more council tax rises and more money given to the NHS spent on things that aren't the NHS's responsibility. They've had years to plan for this and it's extremely worrying that they've been blindsided by it. Dilnot was commissioned how many years ago and they've not even bothered to go back to that, we have to wait until 2028 at the earliest all the while making it more expensive?

It’s pathetic and idiotic… just shouting slogans to voters they’ve lost at least six months ago, if they ever had them in the first place.
Reply
#58
What I love about this place is the desire to chase the wrong rabbit: https://www.health.org.uk/features-and-o...ocial-care

It appears that the number of visas granted had already fallen through the floor.
Reply
#59
(05-12-2025, 02:50 PM)baggy1 Wrote: What I love about this place is the desire to chase the wrong rabbit: https://www.health.org.uk/features-and-o...ocial-care

It appears that the number of visas granted had already fallen through the floor.

What rabbit are you chasing? The imaginary British Carers Bunny who will work for minimum wage and won’t look to progress their career?
Reply
#60
Please just let me be angry. Even if I’ve only just caught up.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)