The real threat to women's rights
#1
An independent candidate has just won a seat in Burnley having campaigned against "free mixing" a.k.a. sex segregation.
Reply
#2
Islamophobe  Wink
Reply
#3
She said Muslim women aren't comfortable in the company of Muslim men I believe. She says the Gaza genocide inspired her to get into politics.
Reply
#4
(05-02-2025, 12:36 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: An independent candidate has just won a seat in Burnley having campaigned against "free mixing" a.k.a. sex segregation.

She's an 18 year old who has just been elected as a local councillor in Burnley. Her website is here and doesn't make any of those statements:

https://maheenkamran.com/

Meanwhile, you've just spent the last week crying on here because the Supreme Court have ruled that being a woman is a biological fact, as opposed to a feeling that anyone can have. A ruling that is necessary for women to have single sex refuges, health care, prison facilities and sports.

In response to that ruling, angry males ran around London waving banners saying "The only good TERF is a dead TERF" but apparently that's not a threat to women's rights either. 

I would be rather more circumspect about declaring what the "real threats" to women's rights were, if I were you.
Reply
#5
https://www.politicshome.com/news/articl...dium=email

Please, do try and defend that Squid. And I'm sure outright lying about me talking about the supreme court ruling (do quote me anything close to your assertion, wanting trans men to be allowed to use the men's toilets instead of the disabled toilets isn't anything close to what you've put) and talking about banners that have fuck all to do with me in order to deflect from this immature extremist is a good look.
Reply
#6
I did see that they'd banned transgender players from women's football.

I then saw that there were 20 registered transgender players across the whole of England's grassroots football system.

Given such a low number is it crazy to assume that those 20 players would have found a club that is happy with and accommodating of them within their women's section, yet now they're left without an environment they feel they can play in?
Reply
#7
In response to your question, I would need to see the full context of the quote. Is she wanting more for women-only facilities for Muslim women or something for wider society as a whole? As stated, it hasn't been a campaign pledge, so it's not possible to know.

Also, the fact that she is a medical student and wants to serve her community as a local councillor, would indicate that she is happy to integrate with wider society, both male and female. And makes your claim that she is the "real threat to women's rights" seem rather hyperbolic. Especially as you seem to think the wellbeing of women as a class needs to come secondary to females who identify as trans men. 

Finally, yes, I do take violent males more seriously as a threat to women than an 18 year old councillor in Burnley. I see violent transactivists and the incel movement as two sides of the same woman-hating coin.
Reply
#8
Wanting trans men to be able to use the gents has zero bearing on the rights of women. You know full well that it doesn't.

I find it laughable that you are trying to twist this into being benign when it clearly isn't, what does opposing "free mixing" entail and how does it stop the threat of Muslim men? Why have you decided to attack trans people instead as a means to deflect from her comments instead of address Muslim men if you want to take her comments in good faith? What are "segregated areas"? I highly doubt Muslim men are transgender, are they?

And I consider the biggest threat to women to come from backwards religious extremists trying to suppress women's rights, as evidenced by the persecution of women and girls in the Middle East, Asia and North Africa, as well as the erosion of women's rights in the US. This smacks of that rhetoric, and it's extremely concerning that it's filtering into British politics.
Reply
#9
(05-02-2025, 03:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Wanting trans men to be able to use the gents has zero bearing on the rights of women. You know full well that it doesn't.

I find it laughable that you are trying to twist this into being benign when it clearly isn't, what does opposing "free mixing" entail and how does it stop the threat of Muslim men? Why have you decided to attack trans people instead as a means to deflect from her comments instead of address Muslim men if you want to take her comments in good faith? What are "segregated areas"? I highly doubt Muslim men are transgender, are they?

And I consider the biggest threat to women to come from backwards religious extremists trying to suppress women's rights, as evidenced by the persecution of women and girls in the Middle East, Asia and North Africa, as well as the erosion of women's rights in the US. This smacks of that rhetoric, and it's extremely concerning that it's filtering into British politics.

The UK is not the US. We absolutely do have issues with misogyny here, but you are pretending not to see them, because you'd rather demonise an 18 year old woman instead.

I meant what I said, transactivism and incels are both groups with a strong undercurrent of violent misogyny. Here is a partial list of violence and intimidation by transactivists. We have the Plymouth shootings by a known incel and increasing numbers of Prevent referrals due to incel ideology. 

To see all that and think the real threat to women in the UK is a medical student who may or may not want more facilities for Muslim women in Burnley is laughable.
Reply
#10
You are seriously playing down the problems of sectarian voting patterns and the effect that has on women's rights - the serious threats that it has, you don't need to be the US to notice it - that are now filtering through to the ballot box with overt calls by an elected politician to end free mixing, and are trying to deflect that by talking about trans people and incels, and now trying to conflate things like wanting trans men to continue to have the right to use the gents with incel culture.

Why are you trying to downplay this sectarian issue? We both know she's got this opinion from somewhere, and the disturbing rhetoric like that needs to be called out and challenged instead of trying to downplay it like you're doing. It's not like religious sectarianism has never been an issue in the UK, one of the UK's constituent countries is one of the biggest examples of it in the west and it not only affected civil rights but women's rights were marginalised by religious extremists only being equalised with the rest of the UK within the last 5 years.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)