Sanity prevails
As usual this doesn't have to be a race to the bottom.

The biggest challenge to the number of accessible spaces in the UK in recent times has been in 2019 when "hidden disabilities" we added as a reason for people to have blue badges and radar keys etc. Those who sadly suffer with anxiety or brain related injuries far out way the 241,000 trans people who may need access to an accessible toilet due to their medical needs, primarily being their gender dysphoria.

I guess the big question is... Who, medically, should have access to these facilities?
"IMO of course..."
Reply
As someone who would not present as obvious in why there is sometimes a need to use such facilities, there’s still plenty of skewed perceptions or obvious (mis)judgements that you can be on the receiving end of. I suspect the hyperbole around this judgement is only going to make that worse.
Reply
(04-30-2025, 01:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: As usual this doesn't have to be a race to the bottom.

The biggest challenge to the number of accessible spaces in the UK in recent times has been in 2019 when "hidden disabilities" we added as a reason for people to have blue badges and radar keys etc. Those who sadly suffer with anxiety or brain related injuries far out way the 241,000 trans people who may need access to an accessible toilet due to their medical needs, primarily being their gender dysphoria.

I guess the big question is... Who, medically, should have access to these facilities?

It will become a race to the bottom, because as soon as you start making a ‘third’ space rather than specifically designed for those who need help changing as well as using toilets etc, those spaces are in danger of losing those facilities or the purpose of new facilities becoming watered down in terms of physical equipment installed in them. 

You see it all the time with SEND activities where they lump people who are physically vulnerable with those with autism and behavioural challenges without any thought about safeguarding the aforementioned safety or access to activities etc 

In my opinion those who have no access to any other space because they physically can’t use a normal toilet or need to change should be prioritised. Why? Because they have literally nowhere else to use, other groups have, they may not want to but they can.

It shouldn’t be a race to the bottom, and priority should be given to those in greatest need but just adding more and more groups to a place intended to be changing facilities first and foremost isn’t fair on those people who cannot do without the space.
Reply
In that comment Derek, you completely miss sections if people that would need such access but not for the sole reasons you alude to. It comes across as a very narrow view of the reality.
Reply
(04-30-2025, 02:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 01:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: As usual this doesn't have to be a race to the bottom.

The biggest challenge to the number of accessible spaces in the UK in recent times has been in 2019 when "hidden disabilities" we added as a reason for people to have blue badges and radar keys etc. Those who sadly suffer with anxiety or brain related injuries far out way the 241,000 trans people who may need access to an accessible toilet due to their medical needs, primarily being their gender dysphoria.

I guess the big question is... Who, medically, should have access to these facilities?

It will become a race to the bottom, because as soon as you start making a ‘third’ space rather than specifically designed for those who need help changing as well as using toilets etc, those spaces are in danger of losing those facilities or the purpose of new facilities becoming watered down in terms of physical equipment installed in them. 

You see it all the time with SEND activities where they lump people who are physically vulnerable with those with autism and behavioural challenges without any thought about safeguarding the aforementioned safety or access to activities etc 

In my opinion those who have no access to any other space because they physically can’t use a normal toilet or need to change should be prioritised. Why? Because they have literally nowhere else to use, other groups have, they may not want to but they can.

I don't disagree with a lot of what you say, Dekka. 

But you didn't really answer my last question. Who should have access to an accessible toilet? 

Those in wheelchairs? - Tick
Those with bowel issues? - Tick
Those who have carers as they struggle to undress? - Tick

Those with Autism? Anxiety? ADHD (the old fashioned one)? OCD? Gender Dysphoria? Sensory issues?
"IMO of course..."
Reply
Hate to break it to you Dekka but disabled facilities have been impinged on long before this landmark and vital judgement.

The office building I work in once a week, changed their disabled toilets to disabled/gender neutral toilets about 4 years ago.
Reply
(04-30-2025, 10:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s the same argument bellends in their Alpha Romeo’s and BMWs use when parking in disabled parking bays, ‘what’s your problem I’m only going to be a minute’!  You don’t solve a problem by moving that problem on to others to deal with.

Why on Earth have you lumped Alfa drivers in with BMW drivers?

I have no skin in the game as neither applies to me.
Reply
(04-30-2025, 02:36 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: In that comment Derek, you completely miss sections if people that would need such access but not for the sole reasons you alude to. It comes across as a very narrow view of the reality.

That was the intention of those spaces though, they were changing spaces with adapted equipment including toilets, sinks, showers (in some cases) and hoists. Others can use them but surely it’s not unreasonable that those spaces are prioritised for this who cannot use any other facilities whilst they are out in public places. I’m not saying others can’t use them for hidden disabilities but it can’t become a third space for groups that could use normal facilities.

(04-30-2025, 02:45 PM)Jacko Wrote: Hate to break it to you Dekka but disabled facilities have been impinged on long before this landmark and vital judgement.

The office building I work in once a week, changed their disabled toilets to disabled/gender neutral toilets about 4 years ago.

I said those spaces are available in at least two replies, they aren’t the same as changing spaces with properly adapted equipment, those areas are where radar keys are used most and the reason they require a key is so they don’t get used and abused by people who don’t need to use them.
Reply
To be fair Dekka, Radar keys are common place in many pubs and other public spaces (Airports especially) for general accessible facilities.

What needs to be worked out is who's disabled enough to use accessible toilets?
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(04-30-2025, 02:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-30-2025, 10:15 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s the same argument bellends in their Alpha Romeo’s and BMWs use when parking in disabled parking bays, ‘what’s your problem I’m only going to be a minute’!  You don’t solve a problem by moving that problem on to others to deal with.

Why on Earth have you lumped Alfa drivers in with BMW drivers?

I have no skin in the game as neither applies to me.

Alfa's need to use disabled bays because when they break down in the car park you need space to fix them.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: