Sanity prevails
It wasn't meant as a 'win' Dekka, fwiw.

Just pointing out that the feelings you have towards disabled people feeling they have access to facilities is the same as Women feeling safe to access the facilities that are meant to be kept for them.

I think we have to park emotion in these instances. If there's a way of making facilities that already exist, accessible to another marginalised section of society, with very little impact on the current group using it. It should be explored.

As I said above, I am only going off the one disabled women I know well enough to get their immediate opinion, but when I look at it logically it makes sense.

How often will a trans person impinge on a disabled persons ability to use an accessible facility? My guess would be not very often.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(04-29-2025, 09:12 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It wasn't meant as a 'win' Dekka, fwiw.

Just pointing out that the feelings you have towards disabled people feeling they have access to facilities is the same as Women feeling safe to access the facilities that are meant to be kept for them.

I think we have to park emotion in these instances. If there's a way of making facilities that already exist, accessible to another marginalised section of society, with very little impact on the current group using it. It should be explored.

As I said above, I am only going off the one disabled women I know well enough to get their immediate opinion, but when I look at it logically it makes sense.

How often will a trans person impinge on a disabled persons ability to use an accessible facility? My guess would be not very often.

I haven’t got into the debate about what is right or wrong with regards to trans using gendered toilets. My point is, the spaces that people use with radar keys are usually changing spaces as well as toilets, they are for the disabled, particularly those with physical disabilities they aren’t there for others. If you aren’t disabled then don’t use them, it’s as simple as that. The disabled have enough access problems in this country already without adding to it by others using their few and far between decent spaces, because it’s easier for others to shunt the problem onto them. 

This isn’t about emotion it’s about the access needs of those who have a disability having a specific space designed for them rather than those perfectly capable of using normal facilities. You don’t just shove every ‘marginalised’ group together because it’s easy sorry a lazy solution for the majority.
Reply
That's fine, Dekka. We just disagree.

I think overcoming a problem so binary as access to sex based facilities by using accessible facilities for those that don't fit the binary, for what will be fleeting moments. Is sensible.

The big take from this is that society needs to do more in the coming weeks, months and years.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(04-29-2025, 09:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: That's fine, Dekka. We just disagree.

I think overcoming a problem so binary as access to sex based facilities by using accessible facilities for those that don't fit the binary, for what will be fleeting moments. Is sensible.

The big take from this is that society needs to do more in the coming weeks, months and years.

They aren’t disabled they don’t need to use accessible changing room and toilets, neither does anybody that isn’t. Those spaces are specifically for the disabled. There are already unisex toilets in cafe’s etc, those spaces do not require a radar key. Those spaces are for the disabled and fug knows this country is appalling enough when it comes to access before being told those spaces are now to be used by others because some non-disabled people can’t behave themselves in a normal loo.
Reply
Agree with Lurker, as a board response it’s a pragmatic solution whilst longer term answers can be found.

And I speak as someone who has access to those toilets for physical health reasons. No drama, no problem.
Reply
(04-30-2025, 07:40 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Agree with Lurker, as a board response it’s a pragmatic solution whilst longer term answers can be found.

And I speak as someone who has access to those toilets for physical health reasons. No drama, no problem.

+1
Reply
I’d also just add that in the vast majority of cases the issue of protected space doesn’t change, as they are usually, by design, a protected space for an individual user
Reply
So yet more erosion of spaces designed for disability access, because others can’t or are perceived can’t behave properly in ‘normal’ toilets.
Reply
Assuming, as per Lurker's suggestion, that there is an increase in disabled facilities then even with a tiny amount of trans people using them, disabled people would still have a net increase in the facilities available to them - surely a positive?

However, if the government announced free puppies for all Dekka would be moaning "what about people who prefer cats" so you have to accept that there are some people who are determined to never be happy.
Reply
(04-30-2025, 08:12 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So yet more erosion of spaces designed for disability access, because others can’t or are perceived can’t behave properly in ‘normal’ toilets.

It doesn’t erode anything, the consequential impact will be tiny. 

Separately, but on the same issue, it saddens me that you can guarantee that at the moment there will be a media witch hunt on for the first human they can find “violating” this proposed new norm. And their life will be ruined for having a shit in a bog.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: