Worst appointment ever?
#61
(04-23-2025, 05:59 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: The more I see released in the press about things he's said about the players, the higher up the list of total dick heads Mowbray goes. In particular his comments about Dike are just downright disrespectful to a young bloke who's spent two years getting over injuries many don't whilst remaining more committed to the cause than some of Tony's favourites seem to. I just want to forget the last four months ever happened really.


Just read that.

Appalling man management, honestly shocked how bad that is. And it was so easily not said like that.
Reply
#62
Pulis shouldn't be mentioned here. His appointment was exactly what we needed at the time. He kept us up with ease. The issue is that is where we should have parted way. Unfortunately, the club made the error of seeing Pulis as a long term solution, when most people knew he'd end up dividing the fan base and creating a toxic atmosphere.

Despite the likes of Pardew and Bruce being complete failures, I still maintain Pulis is the worst manager we've had in my lifetime, just because of how poisonous he made the club. I've no doubt that was manufactured on purpose by Pulis for his own benefit. I think hate is a strong word, and I don't particularly hate him, I strongly dislike him, but I do hate what he did the club by the end of his tenure.

Worst appointment? In terms of where we were and how easy it should have been to maintain status quo and reach the play-offs, I don't think you can argue against Mowbray. It wasn't a great appointment at the time, and it was a shambles from start to finish. 

Pardew - we were already on a downward spiral, he couldn't arrest it.

Bruce - I think the appointment made sense at the time, so I can at least see the logic.
Reply
#63
There are lots of sticks to beat Mowbray with, legitimately.

Saying that Dike isn't match fit, can't handle intensity and can only play for part of a game is pretty low down the list, if legitimate at all.

DD, for some reason, gets a much easier ride than any other perennially injured player in my memory. Nobody claims he had the 'heart of a pea' presumably because he turned up on match days and cheered the team on for his £20k per week.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#64
(04-23-2025, 07:35 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: There are lots of sticks to beat Mowbray with, legitimately.

Saying that Dike isn't match fit, can't handle intensity and can only play for part of a game is pretty low down the list, if legitimate at all.

DD, for some reason, gets a much easier ride than any other perennially injured player in my memory. Nobody claims he had the 'heart of a pea' presumably because he turned up on match days and cheered the team on for his £20k per week.

He's been injured three times, he's just been unlucky enough that they were season ending each time. Bruce offered him the chance to rehab closer to home in the States, he stayed with the team, he's at every home game and is 100% more committed than some of our other players. Not to mention the fact that when he's fit, he's proven he can score and he's one of the best in the division. What Mowbray said was piss poor and the more that comes out, the more I'd absolutely not welcome him back to the Hawthorns ever again.
Reply
#65
(04-23-2025, 07:43 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-23-2025, 07:35 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: There are lots of sticks to beat Mowbray with, legitimately.

Saying that Dike isn't match fit, can't handle intensity and can only play for part of a game is pretty low down the list, if legitimate at all.

DD, for some reason, gets a much easier ride than any other perennially injured player in my memory. Nobody claims he had the 'heart of a pea' presumably because he turned up on match days and cheered the team on for his £20k per week.

He's been injured three times, he's just been unlucky enough that they were season ending each time. Bruce offered him the chance to rehab closer to home in the States, he stayed with the team, he's at every home game and is 100% more committed than some of our other players. Not to mention the fact that when he's fit, he's proven he can score and he's one of the best in the division. What Mowbray said was piss poor and the more that comes out, the more I'd absolutely not welcome him back to the Hawthorns ever again.
Can you send a link to some of these stories?
Reply
#66
(04-23-2025, 08:58 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(04-23-2025, 07:43 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-23-2025, 07:35 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: There are lots of sticks to beat Mowbray with, legitimately.

Saying that Dike isn't match fit, can't handle intensity and can only play for part of a game is pretty low down the list, if legitimate at all.

DD, for some reason, gets a much easier ride than any other perennially injured player in my memory. Nobody claims he had the 'heart of a pea' presumably because he turned up on match days and cheered the team on for his £20k per week.

He's been injured three times, he's just been unlucky enough that they were season ending each time. Bruce offered him the chance to rehab closer to home in the States, he stayed with the team, he's at every home game and is 100% more committed than some of our other players. Not to mention the fact that when he's fit, he's proven he can score and he's one of the best in the division. What Mowbray said was piss poor and the more that comes out, the more I'd absolutely not welcome him back to the Hawthorns ever again.
Can you send a link to some of these stories?

Some of it is fair enough, but the singling out of one of our better and most committed players who's simply suffered awful luck with injuries is pretty shameful. 

https://www.expressandstar.com/sport/202...king/?s=08
Reply
#67
Thanks Ted.
I guess managers have their favourites and Dike didn’t do it for Mowbray.
Personally I rate Dike but his injuries are a big concern.
With the dust settling this has been an awful few months for the club.
I questioned whether we would have made the playoffs with Corberan’ still here, but I’m certain now we would have as the points tally is so low to make top 6.
People can blame players but simply we did well for 2 years under CC so any remnants of a poor culture would surely be gone.
Simply I think TM badly mismanaged a squad capable of a top 6 finish by limping over the line in mid table form.
To have turned us into a side letting in 3 at home v a struggling side and to hit a streak of defeats that made us look like a team of relegation standard took some incredible incompetence.
I’m just glad Patel nipped this one in the bud.
There’s no huge damage done. After all barely any of us expected anything other than being in the Championship next season.
Reply
#68
(04-23-2025, 07:35 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: There are lots of sticks to beat Mowbray with, legitimately.

Saying that Dike isn't match fit, can't handle intensity and can only play for part of a game is pretty low down the list, if legitimate at all.

DD, for some reason, gets a much easier ride than any other perennially injured player in my memory. Nobody claims he had the 'heart of a pea' presumably because he turned up on match days and cheered the team on for his £20k per week.

A good manager wouldn't have said it at all. There was no need. The criticism of Grant was unnecessary and counter productive. Likewise the digs at Corberan, who is proving to be ten times the manager Mowbray is or ever was. Actions always speak louder than words, and that is what TM should have stuck to, unless of course he couldn't and was looking for excuses.
Reply
#69
One (legitimate I will add) question constantly levied at TM was why he wasn't playing DD. He doesn't explain - he gets pelters, he does explain - he gets pelters.

I didn't agree with how he handled Grant (it was insane) but he was in a different position on DD. Also, the way the article is written its presented as if TM just offered up an opinion rather than responded to a question.

As I said, there are lots of sticks to hit him with - for me this is not one that gets near the top of the pile.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#70
He literally insinuated Dike was lazy by not training when that's the instructions from the medical staff.

He could have simply said, Dike has been great and eager but with his rehabilitation I've had to use him more sparingly than either of us would like, we look forward to him being available fully. Simple, truthful and no one looks bad. Instead he threw him under the bus as he did Grant early on, as he tried with Fellows, players that aren't his weird fetish about soft feet and pretty passing.

Dike doesn't get pelters because none of it is his fault, not like Sick Vic who often the physios couldn't even find an issue. Players don't want to be injured and no one seems more frustrated than Dike about his so why criticise him, unless aiming for the biggest cunt on the board award?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)