Worst appointment ever?
#51
(04-22-2025, 07:44 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-22-2025, 07:35 AM)petty sniper Wrote: I cannot believe that no one has mentioned Pullis.  He brought players from 'the agents he knew and liked to work with' for the benefit of T Pullis and left us with a squad including James Chester and Ollie Burke who he had payed fortunes for.  He then downed tools and engineered himself the sack as he needed to pay some legal bills and avaoided the relegation on his CV.  In keeping us up for a couple of fucking miserable years he dismantled all scouting and within a few years we were signing the managers neigbour

Miserable years finishing midtable in the Prem having beaten top six teams, yes how miserable I long for days like yesterday and Coventry. Btw the reason Pulis came in was because the clubs brilliant system and scouting had failed, Blanco, Samaras, Davidson, Gamboa, Ideye Brown were brought in after the club allowed half the squad to leave in one Summer. We ended up with these players because of our scouting system and those employed in it, I appreciate this isn’t what many want to acknowledge but they are the facts. Pulis should have left at the end of the season before he did but let’s not rewrite history, he was brought in because the clubs brilliant system was failing not because it was succeeding.

100% Dekka - really unfair to see Pulis mentioned in this thread. Not his fault we didn't shake his hand and move on the summer of 2016 when we had our best chance to push on and appoint someone more 'progressive'.
Reply
#52
(04-22-2025, 07:35 AM)petty sniper Wrote: I cannot believe that no one has mentioned Pullis.  He brought players from 'the agents he knew and liked to work with' for the benefit of T Pullis and left us with a squad including James Chester and Ollie Burke who he had payed fortunes for.  He then downed tools and engineered himself the sack as he needed to pay some legal bills and avaoided the relegation on his CV.  In keeping us up for a couple of fucking miserable years he dismantled all scouting and within a few years we were signing the managers neigbour

I think most people were prepared to accept the style of Pulis as we were getting results. When he was appointed, I didn't shout hooray but didn't think it would be a disaster. For sure, it was him that made me stop loving football for a while. All the points you make are valid but I think,overall, he did well with us.
Reply
#53
(04-22-2025, 07:57 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: For me it is close to being the worst appointment in my time supporting us.

Most head coach changes happen as it's already gone, and/or is going to shit.

ToMo came into a really stable, well functioning set up. Was then backed in the window and given a much improved tool kit. And the deterioration in our performances and results was shocking.

Bruce and Mowbray are one and the same unfortunately on this occasion.

Mowbray mkII was worse than Bruce, sadly. The wheels had fallen off under Val and we had Hughill up front.

Mowbray had a well-functioning team and was given players to improve that team, yet he still made us much, much worse.
Reply
#54
Alan Irvine -remember him?

Birkenshaw -Lost 13 gaames on the bounce

HAs that record ever been beaten?
Reply
#55
(04-22-2025, 09:48 AM)Pipkins Wrote: Alan Irvine -remember him?

Birkenshaw -Lost 13 gaames on the bounce

HAs that record ever been beaten?

Irvine was awful and probably the most clueless of the lot. I didn't think it was a terrible appointment at the time though. I was just puzzled and interested to see how he would get on.

He is with Moyes at Everton so must have something. Probably one of those who will only be good as a no 2
Reply
#56
I think with worst appointments ever they have to have wrecked the club. Mowbray wasn’t around long enough to alter much.
Saunders takes some beating. Selling Ally Rob and Steve Bull set us back years.
I know he had to cut the playing staff and it was tough times in a really bad era for football, but Saunders left us with a threadbare team.
Reply
#57
(04-22-2025, 10:13 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(04-22-2025, 09:48 AM)Pipkins Wrote: Alan Irvine -remember him?

Birkenshaw -Lost 13 gaames on the bounce

HAs that record ever been beaten?

Irvine was awful and probably the most clueless of the lot. I didn't think it was a terrible appointment at the time though. I was just puzzled and interested to see how he would get on.

He is with Moyes at Everton so must have something. Probably one of those who will only be good as a no 2

I’m sure he lined us up in a 6-2-2 formation once. 

The man was bonkers.
Reply
#58
The worst thing about AFI was that it only took Pulis 45 minutes to sort the entire shitshow out.
Reply
#59
(04-22-2025, 10:56 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I think with worst appointments ever they have to have wrecked the club. Mowbray wasn’t around long enough to alter much.
Saunders takes some beating. Selling Ally Rob and Steve Bull set us back years.
I know he had to cut the playing staff and it was tough times in a really bad era for football, but Saunders left us with a threadbare team.

+1, remember some of his signings, Martin Dickinson, Martin Singleton. 

As you point out it took a long time to sort out the mess he caused

Did a good job for Wolves!
Reply
#60
The more I see released in the press about things he's said about the players, the higher up the list of total dick heads Mowbray goes. In particular his comments about Dike are just downright disrespectful to a young bloke who's spent two years getting over injuries many don't whilst remaining more committed to the cause than some of Tony's favourites seem to. I just want to forget the last four months ever happened really.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)