Mowbray Watch
#1
When Mowbray was appointed I was unsure if things would work out. There was the obvious issue with his health and his relative lack of success at the top end of this division over a sustained period of time. Considering we are according to the owners a team that should always be in the mix for promotion then appointing a manager that has one promotion from this division could certainly be questioned. As a season ticket holder for years I have hardly missed any matches but unfortunately for me the two seasons that I did miss were the title winning season and Mowbray Prem season after the birth of my first son. Therefore I don't have the Mowbray love-in as my memory of him is the previous season culminating in that terrible day at Wembley against Derby.

I was prepared to give him a chance and was optimistic that we would see this free flowing football that he had supposedly delivered in his previous time here. I was also encouraged to hear that he had added a more pragmatic side to his approach since his previous time here. I had recent memories of his young Sunderland team looking very good against us a couple of years back too so there were definitely plus points to the appointment.

However since arriving it has just been a disaster and I genuinely think the downfall has been of his own making. I know it is easy in hindsight to find reasons to criticise a manager but there have been a number of things that he has done that have the alarm bells ringing for me.

  • Immediately eulogised about Grady and tried to make him out to be the creative force that we need when we all know that he is wildly inconsistent.
  • Said similar things about Swift when he is not only inconsistent but is also one of the laziest players I have ever seen. Besides which he has been pretty much useless since Blues away about 18 months ago.
  • Dropped Grant who was having a good season and looked well up for the fight. Then compounded the decision by going public pretty much demoralising him.
  • Signed Armstrong and then never found a way to get other players around him. Never played to his strengths of getting him on the shoulder of defenders and instead we pretty much nullified our own striker. 
  • Played Armstrong wide right at Bristol whilst leaving Fellows on the bench.
  • Played Price as a false 9 at Bristol whilst having Dike, Lankshear and Armstrong fit and available.
  • Never considered Diakite even though he was tremendous in the game at Burnley where he had to play him due to injuries.
  • Played Price in the 10, at right back and false 9. Only picked him in a central midfield role in the last couple of games for which he doesn't look fully fit.
  • Constantly talks about controlling matches such as Norwich away where we hardly threatened all day.The few occasions that Norwich came forwards we looked vulnerable eventually resulting in conceding a late winner.
  • At Bristol we looked terrible in the first half and then conceded early in the 2nd. We got massively lucky with the equaliser and then after 4 subs we actually looked a threat. Why did we look so clueless for the first hour? I couldn't even work out what we were trying to achieve.
  • We repeated the same pathetic first half performance at Coventry and this time we imploded early in the 2nd. Again I couldn't see a game plan and the quality of our passing was atrocious. 
  • After the Watford game where we created a ton of chances Mowbray claimed he didn't recognise the team as being one of his own due to the fact that we had less possession. As though this was a problem even though we won the game and looked threatening for the first time in weeks.
  • Wildsmith - no more words needed.
  • Talking about Wallace as though it is 2020 and he is still the assist king of the Championship.
  • His body language on the touchline is a million miles away from inspiring. Yesterday he was slumped on the touchline looking as brassed off as I was in the stands.
  • His comments about only watching Coventry over the last 3-4 days grinds a bit. They found it so easy yesterday to get into advanced areas of the pitch whilst we struggled to get in their half. As I said previously we looked clueless and without any form of plan.
I am sure there are more that I have forgotten about but for me this isn't going to work. I don't see a manager that has the drive to build a team. If we are going to build a younger dynamic team then we will need some motivation and structure - I don't think Mowbray can build that. 

Ironically I watched the video from 21 years ago yesterday when we beat Sunderland to pretty much secure promotion. If we wanted to turn the clock back maybe we should have employed Megson instead of Mowbray - we certainly wouldn't have rolled over as pathetically as we did yesterday. Before I get slated it is not a serious suggestion but it doesn't half sting to see a team that was no more talented than this lot but had character in spades.
Reply
#2
Agree with all that.

I wanted Mowbray based on an outlier, his team at Sunderland, clear now that was due to the situation there, he is still the deluded, naive manager he was here before clearly

A good man, but poor manager.
Reply
#3
Superb post. Everything spot on and the fact you can recall all these errors despite him only being in charge for three months, really sums up how bad a job he has done.
Reply
#4
Your point on Megson is a fair one. Those of us on here who were the biggest critics of Bilic maintained that there is no excuse for any football team not to be as fit and as organised as possible. You can add the quality players to produce a moment of magic or win you a game out of nothing. All the fancy football tricks and flicks isn't worth anything if you can't keep a clean sheet or are regularly out ran or competed.
Reply
#5
(04-19-2025, 09:27 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Agree with all that.

I wanted Mowbray based on an outlier, his team at Sunderland, clear now that was due to the situation there, he is still the deluded, naive manager he was here before clearly

A good man, but poor manager.

I actually think he is worse than the last time he was here, due to the (absolutely understandable) toll the last couple of years have taken on him physically and mentally
Reply
#6
Agree with all the above. What really pains me is that we beat Coventry fairly effortlessly under Brunt and Abella. Completely routine 2-0 win where Coventry weren't particularly bad, but we were better, particularly in terms of organisation.
Reply
#7
Shoe-horning Grant and Johnston into the same team is the overlooked madness. Corberan had the sense to pick one or the other.

I like them both and are vastly different players but their best positions are the same. Pick the one in better form/more suited for the game. Bring the other one on if it ay working.
Reply
#8
Agree with all the above, good bullet points
Reply
#9
(04-19-2025, 10:09 AM)HLS Wrote: Shoe-horning Grant and Johnston into the same team is the overlooked madness. Corberan had the sense to pick one or the other.

I like them both and are vastly different players but their best positions are the same. Pick the one in better form/more suited for the game. Bring the other one on if it ay working.

Exactly.

And neither seemed unhappy with the situation, advantage of 5 subs, a sub can be preplanned almost so players feel involved even on the bench.
Reply
#10
To carry on with the treatment of Grant

He seems a popular member of the squad, they seemed to all be revelling in how he finally had the crowd behind him, he had earned his place back, he was on form and having a fantastic season, as a team player, not just for goals as before.

Mowbray comes in and almost first thing he does is complain about him. I wonder how much that influenced opinions of the players early days.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)