Sanity prevails
#81
Has anyone in this thread actually bothered to read the judgment?
Reply
#82
(04-18-2025, 08:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I agree completely with Squid. I’m am amazed at the position of the progressive misogynists on here.

Do you have trans people on your hate list along with Arabs, social workers and public sector workers?
Reply
#83
There are 2 types of human beings at birth, men and women. When a woman is killed or harmed it is almost always by a man. Women need the protection from the other form of the species whatever they claim to be
Reply
#84
(04-18-2025, 09:18 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Has anyone in this thread actually bothered to read the judgment?

I have. It is a very specific ruling clarifying the meaning of 'man' and 'woman' in the EA2010 - specifically, that these terms exclude persons holding a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC) and that they refer to 'Biological'* sex. It notes that, as of June 2024, 8,464 people had a GRC (the vast majority of people will never meet or know anyone holding a GRC).

As Squid has pointed out, those without a GRC could already be excluded from such policies, spaces etc.

As a result, bodies will be able to have policies pertaining to women (and men), for example around specific spaces like toilets, or sports competitions, or the make up of members of a board, and the exclusion of people holding a GRC (certified or acquired sex) will be legal. It does not mean, for example, that it will be illegal to create a space (for example toilets) which are considered to be used by a wider group e.g. unisex, or an inclusive sports competition. However, it would, for example, mean that, under a policy saying "50% of our board members must be women" it will be legal for those with a GRC to be excluded, as women, from such a policy without recourse to the EA2010 (and vice versa).

Comments such as "When a woman is killed or harmed it is almost always by a man" may well be true, but are about as relevant to the topic as to a thread about scuba diving.

This has been an interesting thread, at times uncomfortable, at others very saddening. If you find yourself positioned at an extreme end of the debate then you probably have not understood the complex issues involved or you are intolerant of other's views. These topics are uncomfortable because they ask us to look at our own prejudices and many are unwilling to do so.

For those who have stated that this is only about women's rights - this is not correct. The ruling specifically states "The questions raised by this appeal directly affect women and members of the trans community".

The prejudice displayed within this thread is disappointing, and many of the points raised are not connected to, nor shaped by this ruling, but they are symbolic of how it will, and already has been, publicised and interpreted by wider society for example the decision by British Transport Police that trans women will now be searched my men. How they propose to determine the biological sex of a trans person post-surgery is not clear - perhaps if you are a woman who happens to look 'a bit butch' you can now look forward to being searched by a policeman; reflect on their recent record. So much for women's safety.

I find it difficult to imagine what it might be like to genuinely consider yourself to be one gender, when your birth certificate says something else. What we do know is that these individuals go through great suffering, both internally, and externally through being bullied etc. It may be convenient for those on one side of the debate to imagine a 6'4" clodhopping bloke wearing a dress and size 11 Dr. Martens. However, they are more like to be someone like Brianna Ghey.

Ted Maul makes an excellent point about the discomfort felt by 'trans' (I'll use this shorthand term as a catch-all whilst recognising there is a great deal of complexity) people forced to use a male-only space. Who is at most danger: a woman who finds that someone like Brianna is sharing her women-only space, or a Brianna, forced to use a male facility?

It is not that long ago that homosexuals were discriminated against in this country, indeed it was illegal. Do we think such discrimination has disappeared? Some of the language, and citing of individual, irrelevant cases, on this thread is resonant of the proselytising of a narrative that homosexuals are sex offenders, paedophiles etc.

I understand that Squid's concerns are real. Other posters have pointed out that, in reality, though Squid may wish to 'feel' safer, criminals are criminals regardless - and they are not criminals simply because of how they self-identify. Those asking posters to be more thoughtful about women's rights and the challenges of being a woman might also do the same for the trans community. When Squid writes "I am a woman every day of my life all the time, whether I want to be or not" these could be the exact words of someone born 'XY' but, just as much as Squid does, or just as much as I feel myself to be a man, feel themself to be feminine. Similarly, to the question "Are we punishing all men for the misdeeds of some when we keep them out of women's spaces?" - no, we aren't because men generally have equivalent spaces. But there is another group who, already feeling that they do not belong anywhere, have just had this reinforced.

As a consequence of this ruling, people like Brianna Ghey may feel they have no safe space. They will simply become further ostracised from society. There are a lot of very valid points on both sides of the argument here, for example around competitive sport. However criminals are criminals not because of gender dysphoria and hideous acts will, unfortunately, continue to be perpetrated. These are challenges for society to resolve and it should seek to do so without bringing harm to anyone who does not deserve it.

I am reminded also of the white man's fear of the black man (resulting from underlying prejudice, and the projection of fears onto a section of society) - and the resultant othering of people as 'less than' based on their race - and a group of mixed race people who felt they did not belong anywhere. Again, looking to the recent past, "no blacks, no dogs, no Irish'" was acceptable. Whilst society has thankfully moved on from this, it seems that 'no trans' has, for some, become ok.

As individuals, and collectively, we would do well to look at our own prejudices and improve our tolerance, curiosity, and acceptance of 'the other'.

*What is really meant here is 'box ticked by registrar at birth' - very few babies are actually tested (genetically) - but the genetics are complex, and registrars sometimes make mistakes. Whilst many folk like things to be black and white, while the 'concept' of gender may be binary, the biological reality is not. For those interested in the biological determination of sex there is an interesting article here:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK99...%20the%20Y.

For those without the time to read it all, I invite you to scroll down to figure 17.11 . This person is biologically (based on XX/XY) a man. Whilst these cases are rare, biology is not binary. Of course, this only relates to 'biological sex' - the genetic, psycho, social or other factors which cause someone to feel that they are one gender when they have been assigned another are poorly researched and understood (just as they are for homosexuality).
Reply
#85
(04-18-2025, 10:17 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(04-18-2025, 08:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I agree completely with Squid. I’m am amazed at the position of the progressive misogynists on here.

Do you have trans people on your hate list along with Arabs, social workers and public sector workers?

A passionate anti-brown TERF who dislikes the “armpit of civilisation” but regards 50% of the population as worthy of exclusive protected spaces (except Palestinians and Iranians)

Untangle that at your peril

Great post Paddock
Reply
#86
I stopped looking at my own prejudices after my 80 year old mom was frightened off trying on new clothes in shops after she was confronted by a woman with her knob hanging out. I had to go with her after that during the last few years of her life. No respect was given by he/she that day. Can't please everybody all the time and some will always suffer being different. I'm genuinely saddened for those affected. The majority of away fans come to the Hawthorns in peace but all are confined to the away section.
Reply
#87
Paddock so many words and yet so many tired arguments, most of which I've already dealt with.

I note in your sympathy in the British Transport Police only seems to extend for the trans woman being searched, whereas you think it is absolutely fine for a female BT police officer to have to intimately search a male. The lack of empathy for the female in the situation says absolutely everything about who you think matters and it is NOT women.

The other big flaw on your argument is that we cannot base access to spaces such hospital wards as to how well someone "passes". It's completely unworkable in practice and still leaves women vulnerable to male violence. It has been tried. It has failed. 

Finally, bringing in differences of sexual development is a tired distraction. Not everyone is born with two legs, but we as a society operate with the knowledge that humans are a bimodal species. The same applies to biological sex.

P.S Baggiejacko's analogy is spot on.
Reply
#88
Echoes of the 50s on race and 60s and 70s on sexuality.

Good will prevail over segregation/apartite eventually. All this will do is hasten it.
Reply
#89
This is always a hard topic for me.

Due to certain circles I move in, I know a lot of trans people, both male and female trans. I also know someone born female who is male, as in went through male puberty due to having testes but physically presented female at birth. They have chosen to be recognised as neither, and I understand.

I also totally understand that a women need certain spaces and areas to be safe in away from men, and sadly some men will take advantage of trans rights to infiltrate them, and any rules to stop that and be trans inclusive are exceptionally difficult.

It's worth noting I'm a very strong feminist, and I'm trans inclusive, but I don't like black and white thinking and think it's always hard to balance everyone's needs.

I don't have an answer, but while people hang onto black and white thinking on the natter there will never be an answer, that I do know.
Reply
#90
(04-19-2025, 02:14 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Echoes of the 50s on race and 60s and 70s on sexuality.

Good will prevail over segregation/apartite eventually. All this will do is hasten it.

I'm starting to feel a bit like Fuzzbox when he has to talk about race here.

Baggiejacko shared a very moving story about his mum (and btw, such stories are not uncommon)

I don't think some people commenting here have any idea how unpleasant indecent exposure is. That fear of "Here is a man in my space and he's doing something purposely frightening and I have no idea what he is going to do next".

Eighty years old and having to ask her son to go shopping with her because she no longer felt safe. And you have the nerve to compare women wanting that to apartheid!

How dare you.

Recently there was an earbud advert that showed a woman jogging late at night wearing them. It was greeted with howls of derision because very, very few women would feel safe to go jogging at night and know that if we did while wearing headphones, we'd be blamed for whatever happened to us.
You have no idea what it is like to be a woman in the world. We just want some spaces where we can feel safe. Is that too much to ask?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)