Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-07-2025, 10:11 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (04-07-2025, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-07-2025, 09:39 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: I would disagree with recruitment, although would have a look at this at the end of the season
-Cole
-Dobbin
-Racic
-Wildsmith
-Fragole (excuse my poor Italian!)
-Armstrong
The difference is that only Armstrong was an expensive signing from that list, and he’s being ineffective due to management, not due to his ability. He’s a proven championship striker.
Racic and Dobbin were only loans, Wildsmith was a cheap, backup option and I expect we will see Cole and Frabotta leave on frees in the summer.
We have got the big spends right this season, which is bloody refreshing. Our turnover is about £26 million per annum, so I would consider it in that context. We also of course have not seen the contracts, but in terms of our income these signings were not cheap.
Cole has a two year contract, Wildsmith and Frabotta have three year contracts. We are going to have to pay these players wages for the length of these contracts unless some other club will take them off our hands, which will probably mean paying the same salary that we pay them. Most lower league clubs will not be able to afford them. I agree with you that there is unlikely to be a transfer fee.
If you take the case of Wildsmith, these are only estimates, but I assume we pay him more than Derby did. If he is on 10k a week then that is £1.5 million there was also probably an agents fee and a signing on fee so that probably amounts to £2 million. How much did we get for Palmer? Who got the better deal there!
I agree, but 10k/wk is the going rate for any Championship squad player, and we needed a backup goalkeeper. This is why we have to be smarter with our academy, and use of ESC and overseas players.
A club of our size can operate with 18-20 first team players on standard Championship level wages, the remaining squad has to be youth players unless we continue to be bankrolled by Patel. Currently our squad is bloated and has been since relegation with too many players taking big wages for little return. That’s improving but in the interim we need to strike the balance between low cost, free agents and players that we can invest in and develop.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-07-2025, 10:17 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-07-2025, 10:07 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Good thought and proof you can be underwhelmed with Mowbray without being a whining 'I told you so' pain in the snazzy hole.
Rich has said nothing that those of us branded as whining pains in the snazzy hole haven't said.
He said it with style and panache. Look and learn!
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
True, but most of the bad ones did not stay for long or cost us a lot. There was always some logic in the signings
Some of the recent signings defy logic, Kelly being probably the most obvious. Who decided to sign Cole and give him a two year contract when we had no intention of playing him. Frabotta seems to have played a few games here and there without staying anywhere very long, although at his age he might come good.
Posts: 1,960
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
04-07-2025, 10:34 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-07-2025, 10:34 AM by richbaggie.)
(04-07-2025, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-07-2025, 10:11 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (04-07-2025, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-07-2025, 09:39 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: I would disagree with recruitment, although would have a look at this at the end of the season
-Cole
-Dobbin
-Racic
-Wildsmith
-Fragole (excuse my poor Italian!)
-Armstrong
The difference is that only Armstrong was an expensive signing from that list, and he’s being ineffective due to management, not due to his ability. He’s a proven championship striker.
Racic and Dobbin were only loans, Wildsmith was a cheap, backup option and I expect we will see Cole and Frabotta leave on frees in the summer.
We have got the big spends right this season, which is bloody refreshing. Our turnover is about £26 million per annum, so I would consider it in that context. We also of course have not seen the contracts, but in terms of our income these signings were not cheap.
Cole has a two year contract, Wildsmith and Frabotta have three year contracts. We are going to have to pay these players wages for the length of these contracts unless some other club will take them off our hands, which will probably mean paying the same salary that we pay them. Most lower league clubs will not be able to afford them. I agree with you that there is unlikely to be a transfer fee.
If you take the case of Wildsmith, these are only estimates, but I assume we pay him more than Derby did. If he is on 10k a week then that is £1.5 million there was also probably an agents fee and a signing on fee so that probably amounts to £2 million. How much did we get for Palmer? Who got the better deal there!
I agree, but 10k/wk is the going rate for any Championship squad player, and we needed a backup goalkeeper. This is why we have to be smarter with our academy, and use of ESC and overseas players.
A club of our size can operate with 18-20 first team players on standard Championship level wages, the remaining squad has to be youth players unless we continue to be bankrolled by Patel. Currently our squad is bloated and has been since relegation with too many players taking big wages for little return. That’s improving but in the interim we need to strike the balance between low cost, free agents and players that we can invest in and develop.
Summer gives us a massive opportunity to reduce the wage bill further whilst being able to potentially improve the squad, as long as we continue to find gems like the ones I mentioned in my original post. Only Wallace and Grant of the bloated wage period will remain i think.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-07-2025, 10:34 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (04-07-2025, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-07-2025, 10:11 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (04-07-2025, 09:45 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-07-2025, 09:39 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: I would disagree with recruitment, although would have a look at this at the end of the season
-Cole
-Dobbin
-Racic
-Wildsmith
-Fragole (excuse my poor Italian!)
-Armstrong
The difference is that only Armstrong was an expensive signing from that list, and he’s being ineffective due to management, not due to his ability. He’s a proven championship striker.
Racic and Dobbin were only loans, Wildsmith was a cheap, backup option and I expect we will see Cole and Frabotta leave on frees in the summer.
We have got the big spends right this season, which is bloody refreshing. Our turnover is about £26 million per annum, so I would consider it in that context. We also of course have not seen the contracts, but in terms of our income these signings were not cheap.
Cole has a two year contract, Wildsmith and Frabotta have three year contracts. We are going to have to pay these players wages for the length of these contracts unless some other club will take them off our hands, which will probably mean paying the same salary that we pay them. Most lower league clubs will not be able to afford them. I agree with you that there is unlikely to be a transfer fee.
If you take the case of Wildsmith, these are only estimates, but I assume we pay him more than Derby did. If he is on 10k a week then that is £1.5 million there was also probably an agents fee and a signing on fee so that probably amounts to £2 million. How much did we get for Palmer? Who got the better deal there!
I agree, but 10k/wk is the going rate for any Championship squad player, and we needed a backup goalkeeper. This is why we have to be smarter with our academy, and use of ESC and overseas players.
A club of our size can operate with 18-20 first team players on standard Championship level wages, the remaining squad has to be youth players unless we continue to be bankrolled by Patel. Currently our squad is bloated and has been since relegation with too many players taking big wages for little return. That’s improving but in the interim we need to strike the balance between low cost, free agents and players that we can invest in and develop.
Summer gives us a massive opportunity to reduce the wage bill further whilst being able to potentially improve the squad, as long as we continue to find gems like the ones I mentioned in my original post. Only Wallace and Grant of the bloated wage period will remain i think.
Correct, and I imagine we will part ways with Wallace this summer too - even if it means we subsidize large parts of his wages next season still.
Will be another big summer of decisions... Dike, Maja, Grant's contracts expire in 2026, will be interesting to see what the club decides.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
I disagree about the back up keeper, we have Griffiths, Cann who is about 24 and never played, Wallis and Cisse. Although we will never know the economics of signing Wildsmith and letting Palmer go, they made little sense to me unless we were going to get about £10 million for Palmer.
As for youth players not one has debuted this season in the league. Will we let Whitall, Heard and Bostock go at the end of the season?
Posts: 340
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
-2
We've gone from one extreme of the coaching scale to the other. From intense coaching and match-day micro-management, which, whilst aesthetically not exactly pleasing to the eye, was, by and large, effective percentage Championship football.
I don't think Mowbray has paid much mind to any of that or anything of what came before him.
But his downfall will be the continued selection of Wildsmith and the rinse-and-repeat exercise involving "I've only known Adam and goals." Armstrong.
I just think had he stayed, Carlos, by hook or crook, would have got us in the top six. Mowbray has to earn his stripes, which begins now with Bristol up next. He could cut himself some slack by trying something different, but I get the feeling out of sheer stubbornness, he probably won't. It's become an incredibly frustrating match-day experience for fans.
Posts: 6,718
Threads: 354
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(04-07-2025, 09:21 AM)richbaggie Wrote: At the start of the season, I felt that we could make play offs again but realistically finish anywhere between 5th and 10th as we had to cut our cloth so carefully. The unknown to me was how the new recruits would fair, if we'd strengthen in January, if CC would hang around and how strong the division would be.
We have done fairly well overall with recruitment given the constraints. We've unearthed some gems for buttons. Yes, mistakes too but any success rate above 40% on transfers is decent and I'd say that's what we've got. I look at the squad and I don't see better squads from 5th down.
The division is competitive all the way down. There's no gimmes, easy games. However, it's pretty low on quality. Even the top 4, whilst being better than the rest, are pretty average. Southampton of last season are better than any of the top 4 and look at what has happened to them this season.
Our performances against the top 4, despite not winning games, has showed me that this squad is a top 6 squad even if it's not a strong squad, no question. We've let ourselves down against the lesser teams through a mixture of poor management and players simply not performing to their ability.
Carlos has to take a fair share of blame for this. The negative set up post Sheff Weds (a result and performance that set Carlos off into an ultra negative mindset) up to the end of November did major damage. We had a tough run of games in December and despite his agent whoring Carlos out, I felt we had turned a corner. We were scoring more, winning games at home and whilst still aesthetically uneasy on the eye, we were more on track with a window to come. We'll never know of course but if Valencia hadn't come knocking and CC had stayed, aligned with a January window, we would be comfortably in the play off positions now. Of that I'm certain. He'd have found a way, he's a far better coach than Mogga.
That wasn't to be though. He went, Mogga arrived. Whilst not excited by that, I could see the positives. A decent, on paper, window followed (although the Palmer domino effect has been bad) and I felt some optimism despite the poor start results wise for Mogga. He needed some time on the training ground and after the excellent performance at Burnley, I was confident we'd kick on.
However, the last 3 results have been poor. Whilst we played ok on Saturday, overall it feels like we have at best plateaued under Mogga, some would say regressed. Whilst the players have to take some blame, Mogga has made some inexplicable decisions. We don't look well coached right now. You could argue that CC over coached them but I always felt the players knew exactly what their jobs were, that we looked organised. It looks a little chaotic under Mogga, decision making often poor now they have freedom to make those decisions.
Hopefully we can finish strongly but it feels unlikely at the moment. Whilst there's not better squads around us, there are better teams.
Part of me wouldn't mind the season ending now though. Continue the evolution, release all those out of contract and return the loanees. I have no beef with Grady, Swift, Ajayi, Bartley but they are part of the problem. The future is Price, Heggem, Diakite, Styles and Bany. Proof that you don't need a fortune to rebuild. Find a few more in the summer, build a young exciting squad and get in someone like Danny Rohl to manage them. That would feel exciting. We need to feel hope again.
I thought 12th at start of the season, so we are still better off than I predicted.
Missed opportunities aots though. Coupled with teams outside of top 4 being pretty poor. Overall, we should have made top 6. Maybe we will.
Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
The lost points at places like Swansea, Plymouth, Norwich etc are costing us very dearly
Posts: 6,718
Threads: 354
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(04-07-2025, 10:17 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-07-2025, 10:07 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Good thought and proof you can be underwhelmed with Mowbray without being a whining 'I told you so' pain in the snazzy hole.
Rich has said nothing that those of us branded as whining pains in the snazzy hole haven't said.
I am a whining pain told you so type.
And so is my wife.
|