Frustrated
#21
Same Rich.

However weirdly, I can see Mowbray doing well in the playoffs since we tend to do better when teams want to play football and attack, and with the firepower we have available we may shock ourselves a bit. Not saying we'll win them for sure or anything.

However there will still be questions about Mowbray going into and throughout the summer.
Reply
#22
(04-01-2025, 08:56 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Same Rich.

However weirdly, I can see Mowbray doing well in the playoffs since we tend to do better when teams want to play football and attack, and with the firepower we have available we may shock ourselves a bit. Not saying we'll win them for sure or anything.

However there will still be questions about Mowbray going into and throughout the summer.

Agree. I also feel confident about getting something at Cov and Bristol City for the same reasons.
Reply
#23
(04-01-2025, 09:01 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(04-01-2025, 08:56 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Same Rich.

However weirdly, I can see Mowbray doing well in the playoffs since we tend to do better when teams want to play football and attack, and with the firepower we have available we may shock ourselves a bit. Not saying we'll win them for sure or anything.

However there will still be questions about Mowbray going into and throughout the summer.

Agree. I also feel confident about getting something at Cov and Bristol City for the same reasons.

If either side have half a brain they'll sit off us and wait for us to shoot ourselves in the foot, Norwich have given everyone the perfect blueprint on how to play us for the rest of the season.
Reply
#24
Excellent post Birdie although I do like Heggem I would have kept Taylor here.
Reply
#25
(04-01-2025, 09:03 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-01-2025, 09:01 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(04-01-2025, 08:56 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Same Rich.

However weirdly, I can see Mowbray doing well in the playoffs since we tend to do better when teams want to play football and attack, and with the firepower we have available we may shock ourselves a bit. Not saying we'll win them for sure or anything.

However there will still be questions about Mowbray going into and throughout the summer.

Agree. I also feel confident about getting something at Cov and Bristol City for the same reasons.

If either side have half a brain they'll sit off us and wait for us to shoot ourselves in the foot, Norwich have given everyone the perfect blueprint on how to play us for the rest of the season.
 To be fair to Mogga, teams that sit back have caused us problems for years. Apart from a brief couple of months where MJ was scoring worldies from nowhere, the last time I was confident that we could unlock teams that sat back was under Bilic but he had Pereira and the best verson of Diangana.
Reply
#26
(04-01-2025, 08:22 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Don't think anyone can disagree r.e. Wildsmith - there's been five goals since he's come into the team that he's been at fault for.

The Taylor situation is classic hindsight, he showed in the Bournemouth game that he's not ready really at the level we need. That said by the time the season is done Holgate will have made 30 appearances for, would that game time have been better served in Taylor's development? I'd say there is certainly an argument to say so.

Diakite is a weird one and given the reaction of the fans to him, would be an easy way to win favour with those not yet convinced by Mowbray (dropping Wildsmith also falls into this category). I too would like to see Diakite given some game time in place of Molumby, who I remain unconvinced by despite his commitment.

Armstrong is a good player at this level but that does not mean he was the player we needed. We needed a Maja/Dike replacement, someone capable of playing the lone role. Armstrong came in and has been accommodated to the detriment of our other attacking options. The real loser being Karlan Grant who was on course to be one of our POTS contenders just prior to Christmas, now he can't get a kick.

I don't dislike Swift as much as others. However, Mowbray's obsession with turning him into the focal point of our team is strange and is a further symptom of him picking up the baton from Carlos and trying to change things where they didn't need changing. All the chat about "falling back in love with football" is Bruce level soundbites and takes away from the diligent work that was done by the previous manager to turn us from bottom of the league into PO contenders.

It's clear as day Dike has one last full pre-season to prove his fitness is sustainable. Lankshear is willing and slightly more suited than the lad from West Ham last season but he too is not the answer.

The youth point is neither here nor there. All well and good saying we're at the business end of the season, but so were Sunderland when they turned up here under Mowbray with a team of kids and turned us over. Perhaps our prospects just aren't as good as we keep telling ourselves they are? Griffiths and Taylor being the two obvious exceptions who should be in the team/squad in place of Wildsmith and Holgate.

I think when you take the points above and combine them with the fact we seem to have gone from one of the most organised, well drilled sides in the division to a bit of rabble then the concerns over the job being done by TM are more than valid. We're picking up a similar amount of points but it feels more through individual moments rather than by design and for a club in our position that is not a sustainable way to go about it.
That all makes sense although paragraph  2 is harsh on Taylor. Bournemouth promptly went on to score hatfuls at St.James Park, Old Trafford and the Custard bowl. Taylor certainly did no worse against Bournemouth than any of our others would and did manage to score. That's something else our current CBs never do.
Reply
#27
(03-31-2025, 08:37 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think that's the main feeling I have with everything at West Brom right now, I was very happy with Mowbray coming back but I have not been impressed with a few things that have happened, and I am really trying to understand a few things that are bothering me, and though I have some ideas of my own, want to see if others have any answers since we'll never get them directly.

1. Goalkeeping situation. Though Wildsmith isn't a massive issue, I do not understand why Mowbray has given him so much faith. Played roughly the same amount of games as Griffiths, who is younger, larger and has a higher potential. Griffiths was having an excellent season on loan, why cut it short to sit him on the bench, this is harming the development of what could be a key asset for the club in future, Wildsmith is never going to be worth any real money, worth noting at some clubs this alone could land a manager in trouble. Now Cann has gone on loan, it makes less sense. Better for Cann to stay who is never going to make it as Number 1 and at least get experience of match day here, and let Griffiths develop on loan.

2. Taylor loan. Should have stayed and been used, I'm not as sold on Heggem as many others, think people want to see Jonas Ollson where there simply isn't that player there at all. And playing every single game isn't going to help him either. Taylor would have had valuable game time at the level we want him to be playing right now had he stayed here, and would have helped with the minor defensive injury/suspension crisis we've had.

3. Diakate, MotM one game, abandoned after, more on that later too.

4. Armstrong up front isolated. Mowbray knows him well, so he should know better than anyone this isn't Armstrong's role, he's better out wide cutting in or playing off a more targetman style striker, do one or the other; however, out on the left, he hasn't earned a place over Grant or Johnstone.

5. Midfield. We lack runners, this was sort of solved by CC's tactics because runners in the centre were not wanted or needed. Mowbray needs them. Surely by now, a midfield of Mowatt and Molumby, as good as those players are at what they can do, have proven they can't do what we now need. Styles and Price would certainly be worth looking at, maybe with Diakate and make Swift earn his place properly, Swift can be a key player, but so often flatters to deceive. This is probably the biggest issue right now, and Mowbray seems blind to it.

6. Dike. Is he fit or not? If not, don't put him on the bench, if he is, let him play, I know he'll be desperate to play, and after everything he has a lot to prove, and he's shown enough in glimpses since last injury to show he may yet prove to be worth the heartache so far.

7. Youth. This isn't just Mowbray. Why, Why? WHY? Every single manager who comes to this club comes with a reputation for introducing young players and developing a base for the club to build from. Yet the second they walk through the door here, they suddenly want experience and age over all other attributes. Sunderland's Mowbray would have favoured Griffiths, Taylor and maybe even someone like Whitwell, at least as options. Here, though, no, old guard, always the same old players and nothing changes. Does anyone have an explanation?

Decent Post - my view;

1. GK - agree Griffitsh should be #1. I think Wildsmith is an issue and not sure why you think McCann won't make it 
2. Agree re Taylor - he stays and Holgates minutes are limited
3. Agree
4. Agree
5. Not sure what you mean TBF - but the 1st three midfielders on the sheet should me JM, AM & IP + probably Diakite
6. You're right, use him and if he gets injured again get shot
7. A couple of senior Pros (one in particular) have been very anti youth and influenced the last three managers about this
Reply
#28
Be interesting to know which senior pros they are tbh.
Reply
#29
(04-01-2025, 07:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Be interesting to know which senior pros they are tbh.
Contenders?

Wallace and/or Bartley
Reply
#30
Wallace was full of praise for Fellows after his U21 performances, I'd be surprised if it's Wallace tbh
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)