Frustrated
#1
I think that's the main feeling I have with everything at West Brom right now, I was very happy with Mowbray coming back but I have not been impressed with a few things that have happened, and I am really trying to understand a few things that are bothering me, and though I have some ideas of my own, want to see if others have any answers since we'll never get them directly.

1. Goalkeeping situation. Though Wildsmith isn't a massive issue, I do not understand why Mowbray has given him so much faith. Played roughly the same amount of games as Griffiths, who is younger, larger and has a higher potential. Griffiths was having an excellent season on loan, why cut it short to sit him on the bench, this is harming the development of what could be a key asset for the club in future, Wildsmith is never going to be worth any real money, worth noting at some clubs this alone could land a manager in trouble. Now Cann has gone on loan, it makes less sense. Better for Cann to stay who is never going to make it as Number 1 and at least get experience of match day here, and let Griffiths develop on loan.

2. Taylor loan. Should have stayed and been used, I'm not as sold on Heggem as many others, think people want to see Jonas Ollson where there simply isn't that player there at all. And playing every single game isn't going to help him either. Taylor would have had valuable game time at the level we want him to be playing right now had he stayed here, and would have helped with the minor defensive injury/suspension crisis we've had.

3. Diakate, MotM one game, abandoned after, more on that later too.

4. Armstrong up front isolated. Mowbray knows him well, so he should know better than anyone this isn't Armstrong's role, he's better out wide cutting in or playing off a more targetman style striker, do one or the other; however, out on the left, he hasn't earned a place over Grant or Johnstone.

5. Midfield. We lack runners, this was sort of solved by CC's tactics because runners in the centre were not wanted or needed. Mowbray needs them. Surely by now, a midfield of Mowatt and Molumby, as good as those players are at what they can do, have proven they can't do what we now need. Styles and Price would certainly be worth looking at, maybe with Diakate and make Swift earn his place properly, Swift can be a key player, but so often flatters to deceive. This is probably the biggest issue right now, and Mowbray seems blind to it.

6. Dike. Is he fit or not? If not, don't put him on the bench, if he is, let him play, I know he'll be desperate to play, and after everything he has a lot to prove, and he's shown enough in glimpses since last injury to show he may yet prove to be worth the heartache so far.

7. Youth. This isn't just Mowbray. Why, Why? WHY? Every single manager who comes to this club comes with a reputation for introducing young players and developing a base for the club to build from. Yet the second they walk through the door here, they suddenly want experience and age over all other attributes. Sunderland's Mowbray would have favoured Griffiths, Taylor and maybe even someone like Whitwell, at least as options. Here, though, no, old guard, always the same old players and nothing changes. Does anyone have an explanation?
Reply
#2
Good post Birdie.

Don’t agree about Taylor but I do on the rest.
Reply
#3
I agree with points 1-6. What I would say on point 7 is that Val tried to give the youngsters a go when possible, brought Gardner Hickman into the first team, gave Fellows his debut and reduced the age of the squad with his signings (although I know this is a slightly different issue) despite not being here very long. Corberan brought Fellows into the first team and also made an effort to reduce the age of the first team. Obviously there's been an active attempt to do this over the past season.

The point I'm making is that at least 2 of the last 4 managers did make some effort to integrate the youngsters that were ready. I find it bizarre that Mowbray has completely underutilised Fellows, although he has played Price despite him only being 21.

Bruce signing golden oldies isn't a surprise to me.
Reply
#4
(03-31-2025, 08:41 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Good post Birdie.

Don’t agree about Taylor but I do on the rest.

I thought you'd like Taylor, large build, athletic, does the actual basics properly while also being tidy on the ball, has the potential to go far and is a natural leader.

He'll be raw for the first 6 months he plays for us, but defenders, central defenders especially, always are, it's something fans are going to need to learn to accept if we are to develop any players here.
Reply
#5
(03-31-2025, 08:45 PM)Sliced Wrote: I agree with points 1-6. What I would say on point 7 is that Val tried to give the youngsters a go when possible, brought Gardner Hickman into the first team, gave Fellows his debut and reduced the age of the squad with his signings (although I know this is a slightly different issue) despite not being here very long. Corberan brought Fellows into the first team and also made an effort to reduce the age of the first team.

The point I'm making is that at least 2 of the last 4 managers did make some effort to integrate the youngsters that were ready. I find it bizarre that Mowbray has completely underutilised Fellows, although he has played Price despite him only being 21.

Bruce signing golden oldies isn't a surprise to me.

Good point on Val, that was one thing he did right. CC, I don't know how much was because it was necessary at times, but with everything else going on I don't blame him much.
Reply
#6
(03-31-2025, 08:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 08:41 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Good post Birdie.

Don’t agree about Taylor but I do on the rest.

I thought you'd like Taylor, large build, athletic, does the actual basics properly while also being tidy on the ball, has the potential to go far and is a natural leader.

He'll be raw for the first 6 months he plays for us, but defenders, central defenders especially, always are, it's something fans are going to need to learn to accept if we are to develop any players here.
Agree he has all the tools but needs to be more imposing. It would be hard to integrate him mid-season so makes sense in the summer.
Reply
#7
(03-31-2025, 09:25 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 08:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 08:41 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Good post Birdie.

Don’t agree about Taylor but I do on the rest.

I thought you'd like Taylor, large build, athletic, does the actual basics properly while also being tidy on the ball, has the potential to go far and is a natural leader.

He'll be raw for the first 6 months he plays for us, but defenders, central defenders especially, always are, it's something fans are going to need to learn to accept if we are to develop any players here.
Agree he has all the tools but needs to be more imposing. It would be hard to integrate him mid-season so makes sense in the summer.

Yeah can understand that.
Reply
#8
(03-31-2025, 09:27 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:25 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 08:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 08:41 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Good post Birdie.

Don’t agree about Taylor but I do on the rest.

I thought you'd like Taylor, large build, athletic, does the actual basics properly while also being tidy on the ball, has the potential to go far and is a natural leader.

He'll be raw for the first 6 months he plays for us, but defenders, central defenders especially, always are, it's something fans are going to need to learn to accept if we are to develop any players here.
Agree he has all the tools but needs to be more imposing. It would be hard to integrate him mid-season so makes sense in the summer.

Yeah can understand that.

In fairness we also looked pretty well stocked back there at the time. Ajayi and Bartley were back, we didn’t bank on them both getting injured again as soon as the window closed and then a string of suspensions kicking in. At the time it seemed the right decision.
Reply
#9
While we are in the chase for the play-offs, I can understand some of the choices he's making. He has to pick players that he believes are best suited to doing the job now rather than what they may do in the future and he can only go on what he sees in training. 

With the keeper, Wildsmith hasn't really done much wrong - yes, he's made a couple of mistakes but so does every keeper. Every squad at our level needs 2 capable keepers in case of injury, having Cann on the bench with Griffiths out on loan would be a huge risk.

At centre back, we have 4 capable players (when fit) in Heggem, Bartley, Ajayi and Holgate - is Taylor currently better than those? Debateable, but he's better off playing every week rather than sitting on our bench it a position where we have adequate cover (not like the goalkeeping situation).

Diakite - he's a tough one. Is he better in midfield than Mowatt, Molumby, Swift, or Price? We can't play all of them. For what it's worth, I think he plays if we go with a back 3, either as one of those 3 or sitting just in front of them but so far this isn't a formation that Mowbray seems to like.

Armstrong I agree with you. It isn't working, opposing teams stop us playing through the middle and are happy for us to get wide knowing that we have nobody in the box to win headers. It's time to start with either Dike or Lankshear, maybe with Armstrong playing off them.

Midfield. I think our issue here is the formation we play. With 4 at the back and 2 wingers, do we go with 1 holding, 1 "no. 10" and one runner, 2 holding, no No. 10, etc etc. I think we need more versatility here (Price is a good start) or do we not play with out and out wide men?

Dike. Agreed, he needs to play. If he isn't ready for at least 45 minutes he shouldn't be in the squad.

Youth - see above, while we have something to play for it's a risk just picking players because they're young and I would suggest that Mowbray doesn't see any of them as being better now than the older players. This may change in the summer.

Someone else mentioned the limited game time being given to Fellows. He had a great start to the season, largely due to linking up very well with Maja either on the end of crosses to the far post or pull backs. Since Maja's injury he's been nowhere near as productive - whether this would change with a bigger centre forward (and Price/Molumby/Mowatt/Swift being in position for the cut backs), hopefully we'll see.
Reply
#10
(03-31-2025, 08:37 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think that's the main feeling I have with everything at West Brom right now, I was very happy with Mowbray coming back but I have not been impressed with a few things that have happened, and I am really trying to understand a few things that are bothering me, and though I have some ideas of my own, want to see if others have any answers since we'll never get them directly.

1. Goalkeeping situation. Though Wildsmith isn't a massive issue, I do not understand why Mowbray has given him so much faith. Played roughly the same amount of games as Griffiths, who is younger, larger and has a higher potential. Griffiths was having an excellent season on loan, why cut it short to sit him on the bench, this is harming the development of what could be a key asset for the club in future, Wildsmith is never going to be worth any real money, worth noting at some clubs this alone could land a manager in trouble. Now Cann has gone on loan, it makes less sense. Better for Cann to stay who is never going to make it as Number 1 and at least get experience of match day here, and let Griffiths develop on loan.

2. Taylor loan. Should have stayed and been used, I'm not as sold on Heggem as many others, think people want to see Jonas Ollson where there simply isn't that player there at all. And playing every single game isn't going to help him either. Taylor would have had valuable game time at the level we want him to be playing right now had he stayed here, and would have helped with the minor defensive injury/suspension crisis we've had.

3. Diakate, MotM one game, abandoned after, more on that later too.

4. Armstrong up front isolated. Mowbray knows him well, so he should know better than anyone this isn't Armstrong's role, he's better out wide cutting in or playing off a more targetman style striker, do one or the other; however, out on the left, he hasn't earned a place over Grant or Johnstone.

5. Midfield. We lack runners, this was sort of solved by CC's tactics because runners in the centre were not wanted or needed. Mowbray needs them. Surely by now, a midfield of Mowatt and Molumby, as good as those players are at what they can do, have proven they can't do what we now need. Styles and Price would certainly be worth looking at, maybe with Diakate and make Swift earn his place properly, Swift can be a key player, but so often flatters to deceive. This is probably the biggest issue right now, and Mowbray seems blind to it.

6. Dike. Is he fit or not? If not, don't put him on the bench, if he is, let him play, I know he'll be desperate to play, and after everything he has a lot to prove, and he's shown enough in glimpses since last injury to show he may yet prove to be worth the heartache so far.

7. Youth. This isn't just Mowbray. Why, Why? WHY? Every single manager who comes to this club comes with a reputation for introducing young players and developing a base for the club to build from. Yet the second they walk through the door here, they suddenly want experience and age over all other attributes. Sunderland's Mowbray would have favoured Griffiths, Taylor and maybe even someone like Whitwell, at least as options. Here, though, no, old guard, always the same old players and nothing changes. Does anyone have an explanation?

Good post Birdmon.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)