Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
Good post. We feel very much one step forward and two steps backwards at the moment and that's a major cause of frustration.
Very much agree on Armstrong and our midfield. Everyone has been crying out for weeks that Armstrong needs a big man alongside him to make the ball stick and yet match after match goes by and he's a passenger.
Sometimes for a striker, it's not just the number of goals they score, but that they can score the types of goals nobody else in the team can. Austin was like that. Didn't score that many, but they were usually match winners. Armstrong might be the same, but he needs to get that service.
Posts: 9,642
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
Superb post. Whilst I think some of the criticism about TM has been ridiculous, you've pointed out his flaws so far very articulately, and they're also the frustrations I share. Particularly with Griffiths and the cutting short of his loan just to plonk him on the bench. That is absolutely scandalous.
Posts: 289
Threads: 26
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(03-31-2025, 08:37 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think that's the main feeling I have with everything at West Brom right now, I was very happy with Mowbray coming back but I have not been impressed with a few things that have happened, and I am really trying to understand a few things that are bothering me, and though I have some ideas of my own, want to see if others have any answers since we'll never get them directly.
1. Goalkeeping situation. Though Wildsmith isn't a massive issue, I do not understand why Mowbray has given him so much faith. Played roughly the same amount of games as Griffiths, who is younger, larger and has a higher potential. Griffiths was having an excellent season on loan, why cut it short to sit him on the bench, this is harming the development of what could be a key asset for the club in future, Wildsmith is never going to be worth any real money, worth noting at some clubs this alone could land a manager in trouble. Now Cann has gone on loan, it makes less sense. Better for Cann to stay who is never going to make it as Number 1 and at least get experience of match day here, and let Griffiths develop on loan.
2. Taylor loan. Should have stayed and been used, I'm not as sold on Heggem as many others, think people want to see Jonas Ollson where there simply isn't that player there at all. And playing every single game isn't going to help him either. Taylor would have had valuable game time at the level we want him to be playing right now had he stayed here, and would have helped with the minor defensive injury/suspension crisis we've had.
3. Diakate, MotM one game, abandoned after, more on that later too.
4. Armstrong up front isolated. Mowbray knows him well, so he should know better than anyone this isn't Armstrong's role, he's better out wide cutting in or playing off a more targetman style striker, do one or the other; however, out on the left, he hasn't earned a place over Grant or Johnstone.
5. Midfield. We lack runners, this was sort of solved by CC's tactics because runners in the centre were not wanted or needed. Mowbray needs them. Surely by now, a midfield of Mowatt and Molumby, as good as those players are at what they can do, have proven they can't do what we now need. Styles and Price would certainly be worth looking at, maybe with Diakate and make Swift earn his place properly, Swift can be a key player, but so often flatters to deceive. This is probably the biggest issue right now, and Mowbray seems blind to it.
6. Dike. Is he fit or not? If not, don't put him on the bench, if he is, let him play, I know he'll be desperate to play, and after everything he has a lot to prove, and he's shown enough in glimpses since last injury to show he may yet prove to be worth the heartache so far.
7. Youth. This isn't just Mowbray. Why, Why? WHY? Every single manager who comes to this club comes with a reputation for introducing young players and developing a base for the club to build from. Yet the second they walk through the door here, they suddenly want experience and age over all other attributes. Sunderland's Mowbray would have favoured Griffiths, Taylor and maybe even someone like Whitwell, at least as options. Here, though, no, old guard, always the same old players and nothing changes. Does anyone have an explanation?
Frustration is the perfect description and all of those points completely resonate. Alas, it's frustration bordering on ambivalence for me. Metaphorically married to the Albion for 49 years but at the moment feels like we're not talking to each other at tea time and having a few nights apart, with me on the settee! The relationship needs a footballing version of a trip to Ann Summers to get it back on track. Though in Tone's case he'd probably prefer the less embarrassing option of ordering via Lovehoney under a pseudonym.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Another knocking Mowbray just for the sake of it post.
Loads of your points apply to the pre Corberan era as well, Taylor was loaned out, Diakite and academy players under utilised.
Wildsmith v Griffiths, as it happens I would have gone with Griffiths, but the defence is as dependable as it was when Palmer was with us.
Dike who knows where his fitness is, and caution is the better option.
With the benefit of hindsight, signing Armstrong maybe a mistake, how often do loaning players from the premier league in January work, they are usually lacking in match fitness and confidence.
Is Mowbray infallible, no.Which manager us? But he is consistently picking up criticism for getting very similar results and performances that his predecessor did.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(04-01-2025, 06:56 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Another knocking Mowbray just for the sake of it post.
Loads of your points apply to the pre Corberan era as well, Taylor was loaned out, Diakite and academy players under utilised.
Wildsmith v Griffiths, as it happens I would have gone with Griffiths, but the defence is as dependable as it was when Palmer was with us.
Dike who knows where his fitness is, and caution is the better option.
With the benefit of hindsight, signing Armstrong maybe a mistake, how often do loaning players from the premier league in January work, they are usually lacking in match fitness and confidence.
Is Mowbray infallible, no.Which manager us? But he is consistently picking up criticism for getting very similar results and performances that his predecessor did.
Not really aiming it to be knocking for the sake of it. I was keen on Mowbray returning and hope it works out. I was also a massive fan of CC and yes, there are points I could have made under CC too, difference was I felt things were by design or part of a plan with CC, under Mowbray I've not got that confidence yet. As said it's more frustrations over actual pure "he's so wrong" style points.
Posts: 516
Threads: 23
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
1
The main problem is a lack of creativity in midfield,no way should mowatt and molumby be in the same team .other teams know that all they have to do is double up on our wide players hence we don’t create anything
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(03-31-2025, 08:37 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think that's the main feeling I have with everything at West Brom right now, I was very happy with Mowbray coming back but I have not been impressed with a few things that have happened, and I am really trying to understand a few things that are bothering me, and though I have some ideas of my own, want to see if others have any answers since we'll never get them directly.
1. Goalkeeping situation. Though Wildsmith isn't a massive issue, I do not understand why Mowbray has given him so much faith. Played roughly the same amount of games as Griffiths, who is younger, larger and has a higher potential. Griffiths was having an excellent season on loan, why cut it short to sit him on the bench, this is harming the development of what could be a key asset for the club in future, Wildsmith is never going to be worth any real money, worth noting at some clubs this alone could land a manager in trouble. Now Cann has gone on loan, it makes less sense. Better for Cann to stay who is never going to make it as Number 1 and at least get experience of match day here, and let Griffiths develop on loan.
2. Taylor loan. Should have stayed and been used, I'm not as sold on Heggem as many others, think people want to see Jonas Ollson where there simply isn't that player there at all. And playing every single game isn't going to help him either. Taylor would have had valuable game time at the level we want him to be playing right now had he stayed here, and would have helped with the minor defensive injury/suspension crisis we've had.
3. Diakate, MotM one game, abandoned after, more on that later too.
4. Armstrong up front isolated. Mowbray knows him well, so he should know better than anyone this isn't Armstrong's role, he's better out wide cutting in or playing off a more targetman style striker, do one or the other; however, out on the left, he hasn't earned a place over Grant or Johnstone.
5. Midfield. We lack runners, this was sort of solved by CC's tactics because runners in the centre were not wanted or needed. Mowbray needs them. Surely by now, a midfield of Mowatt and Molumby, as good as those players are at what they can do, have proven they can't do what we now need. Styles and Price would certainly be worth looking at, maybe with Diakate and make Swift earn his place properly, Swift can be a key player, but so often flatters to deceive. This is probably the biggest issue right now, and Mowbray seems blind to it.
6. Dike. Is he fit or not? If not, don't put him on the bench, if he is, let him play, I know he'll be desperate to play, and after everything he has a lot to prove, and he's shown enough in glimpses since last injury to show he may yet prove to be worth the heartache so far.
7. Youth. This isn't just Mowbray. Why, Why? WHY? Every single manager who comes to this club comes with a reputation for introducing young players and developing a base for the club to build from. Yet the second they walk through the door here, they suddenly want experience and age over all other attributes. Sunderland's Mowbray would have favoured Griffiths, Taylor and maybe even someone like Whitwell, at least as options. Here, though, no, old guard, always the same old players and nothing changes. Does anyone have an explanation?
Good post Birdie, genuine frustration rather than anti-TM rhetoric.
1. Agree, was strange to break the loan and not play Griffiths, especially given Wildsmith's errors since.
2. Disagree. Taylor is not ready for the intensity of our current situation, IMO. Plus we are well covered in that area.
3. Diakite was MotM in a back 3 and we haven't played that way since, although not sure why. There's too many ahead of him in CM in Mpwbray's mind, I think, but I would like to see him more involved.
4. Agree. Armstrong was a pretty much, universally recognised, quality signing, but we are not playing to his strengths. But, I have to say he hasn't really impressed either on or off the ball, so not sure his heart's in it, although that may be grossly unfair.
5. Agree. Swift's day has been and gone. Yes he finds the odd moment of brilliance, but his all round game is too slow and out of sync with those around him. Price is a shoe in and I think Mowbray agrees and Saturday's absence may just have been down to fitness levels (something much toted as being a critical algorithym under CC) due to the International break. I would like to see a 3 of Price Diakite and Mowatt.
6. Don't see any way he is fit, if he was he'd be getting more minutes. This directly impacts the starting 11, and therefore point 4, as Lankshear is not genuine competition for Armstrong.
7. All coaches are reluctant to introduce youth, especially at a critical point in the season. Only Diakite can genuinely be disgruntled at his amount of game time IMO. Sadly, the only way we see youth come through will be next season IF we fail to get promoted. If we go up it will be another barren year.
Them's my onions anyway.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Don't think anyone can disagree r.e. Wildsmith - there's been five goals since he's come into the team that he's been at fault for.
The Taylor situation is classic hindsight, he showed in the Bournemouth game that he's not ready really at the level we need. That said by the time the season is done Holgate will have made 30 appearances for, would that game time have been better served in Taylor's development? I'd say there is certainly an argument to say so.
Diakite is a weird one and given the reaction of the fans to him, would be an easy way to win favour with those not yet convinced by Mowbray (dropping Wildsmith also falls into this category). I too would like to see Diakite given some game time in place of Molumby, who I remain unconvinced by despite his commitment.
Armstrong is a good player at this level but that does not mean he was the player we needed. We needed a Maja/Dike replacement, someone capable of playing the lone role. Armstrong came in and has been accommodated to the detriment of our other attacking options. The real loser being Karlan Grant who was on course to be one of our POTS contenders just prior to Christmas, now he can't get a kick.
I don't dislike Swift as much as others. However, Mowbray's obsession with turning him into the focal point of our team is strange and is a further symptom of him picking up the baton from Carlos and trying to change things where they didn't need changing. All the chat about "falling back in love with football" is Bruce level soundbites and takes away from the diligent work that was done by the previous manager to turn us from bottom of the league into PO contenders.
It's clear as day Dike has one last full pre-season to prove his fitness is sustainable. Lankshear is willing and slightly more suited than the lad from West Ham last season but he too is not the answer.
The youth point is neither here nor there. All well and good saying we're at the business end of the season, but so were Sunderland when they turned up here under Mowbray with a team of kids and turned us over. Perhaps our prospects just aren't as good as we keep telling ourselves they are? Griffiths and Taylor being the two obvious exceptions who should be in the team/squad in place of Wildsmith and Holgate.
I think when you take the points above and combine them with the fact we seem to have gone from one of the most organised, well drilled sides in the division to a bit of rabble then the concerns over the job being done by TM are more than valid. We're picking up a similar amount of points but it feels more through individual moments rather than by design and for a club in our position that is not a sustainable way to go about it.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(03-31-2025, 08:37 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think that's the main feeling I have with everything at West Brom right now, I was very happy with Mowbray coming back but I have not been impressed with a few things that have happened, and I am really trying to understand a few things that are bothering me, and though I have some ideas of my own, want to see if others have any answers since we'll never get them directly.
1. Goalkeeping situation. Though Wildsmith isn't a massive issue, I do not understand why Mowbray has given him so much faith. Played roughly the same amount of games as Griffiths, who is younger, larger and has a higher potential. Griffiths was having an excellent season on loan, why cut it short to sit him on the bench, this is harming the development of what could be a key asset for the club in future, Wildsmith is never going to be worth any real money, worth noting at some clubs this alone could land a manager in trouble. Now Cann has gone on loan, it makes less sense. Better for Cann to stay who is never going to make it as Number 1 and at least get experience of match day here, and let Griffiths develop on loan.
2. Taylor loan. Should have stayed and been used, I'm not as sold on Heggem as many others, think people want to see Jonas Ollson where there simply isn't that player there at all. And playing every single game isn't going to help him either. Taylor would have had valuable game time at the level we want him to be playing right now had he stayed here, and would have helped with the minor defensive injury/suspension crisis we've had.
3. Diakate, MotM one game, abandoned after, more on that later too.
4. Armstrong up front isolated. Mowbray knows him well, so he should know better than anyone this isn't Armstrong's role, he's better out wide cutting in or playing off a more targetman style striker, do one or the other; however, out on the left, he hasn't earned a place over Grant or Johnstone.
5. Midfield. We lack runners, this was sort of solved by CC's tactics because runners in the centre were not wanted or needed. Mowbray needs them. Surely by now, a midfield of Mowatt and Molumby, as good as those players are at what they can do, have proven they can't do what we now need. Styles and Price would certainly be worth looking at, maybe with Diakate and make Swift earn his place properly, Swift can be a key player, but so often flatters to deceive. This is probably the biggest issue right now, and Mowbray seems blind to it.
6. Dike. Is he fit or not? If not, don't put him on the bench, if he is, let him play, I know he'll be desperate to play, and after everything he has a lot to prove, and he's shown enough in glimpses since last injury to show he may yet prove to be worth the heartache so far.
7. Youth. This isn't just Mowbray. Why, Why? WHY? Every single manager who comes to this club comes with a reputation for introducing young players and developing a base for the club to build from. Yet the second they walk through the door here, they suddenly want experience and age over all other attributes. Sunderland's Mowbray would have favoured Griffiths, Taylor and maybe even someone like Whitwell, at least as options. Here, though, no, old guard, always the same old players and nothing changes. Does anyone have an explanation?
Some interesting points, Birdy.
I dont agree on points; 2 & 7, though, and on Swift (which I will post a seperate fred about later). Our yoof have not shown anything to me when I have watched to suggest they can step up, Taylor included. Taylor being out on loan is best for his development this seaosn if we are going to need him next year.
The points about the CM and CF issues are, however, spot on, mate.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
Good post Birdy
I was OK about Mogga coming back. It felt a good fit but I am having doubts now. They say 10 games is a fair amount of games to judge a new manager and I'd say that at the moment he's creating more questions than giving us answers. We are earning roughly the same points as we were under CC but Mogga has had the benefit of what was on paper, a decent January window.
I still think we'll just about limp home into the play offs but he needs to utilise the squad better from here on in.
|