Better, worse or the same…
#31
(03-30-2025, 01:37 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:17 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:13 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 12:55 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Since Mowbrays appointment, there has been a number of posters who have been critical or very sceptical of him. The vast majority of it has been about his ability as a football manager, which is fine this is a football message board.

But I would argue that increasingly posters who think this way have had to jump through increasingly smaller hoops to make any relevant/valid point.

My view there hasn't been any real difference in terms of results and quality of performance since  his arrival, from those seen before he came.

By concentrating on Mowbray we are in danger of missing the point, and that is the squad needs improvement . Where are our strengths, what are our weaknesses. What are the priorities for the summer.

Every team needs to improve or at least look to improve its squad. However you can’t just say a manager has neither a positive or negative effect on a squad. If that were the case, we would never have overtook Wolves under GM and Leicester would have finished top eight when they won the Prem. At best TM hasn’t made us better.

Surely just matching a future Champions League manager means he's doing a great job though?

Or maybe neither of them are that great and the squad has found it's level?

Only a few people on here have said CC is a Champions League Manager, I wasn’t particularly upset he left. However to replace him with TM…
Then I think we actually agree!  Smile

Mowbray clearly wasn't our first choice, nor mine, but he's here until the end of the season so slagging him off, especially his record from years past, is just pointless. Some need to remember that the only reason he is here at all is because there beloved messiah fucked of at Christmas leaving us in the shit.

I'd rather focus my energy on supporting TM than trying to turn CC into some Mythical, Tactical God. Especially when their records here are practically identical.

They either both did / are doing, well with the squad they had / have or they are equally shit. You simply can't put one on a pedestal and the other in the gutter, it just doesn't add up.  Big Grin

You can put one in the Champions League and one in the bin though.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#32
(03-30-2025, 02:13 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:37 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:17 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:13 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Every team needs to improve or at least look to improve its squad. However you can’t just say a manager has neither a positive or negative effect on a squad. If that were the case, we would never have overtook Wolves under GM and Leicester would have finished top eight when they won the Prem. At best TM hasn’t made us better.

Surely just matching a future Champions League manager means he's doing a great job though?

Or maybe neither of them are that great and the squad has found it's level?

Only a few people on here have said CC is a Champions League Manager, I wasn’t particularly upset he left. However to replace him with TM…
Then I think we actually agree!  Smile

Mowbray clearly wasn't our first choice, nor mine, but he's here until the end of the season so slagging him off, especially his record from years past, is just pointless. Some need to remember that the only reason he is here at all is because there beloved messiah fucked of at Christmas leaving us in the shit.

I'd rather focus my energy on supporting TM than trying to turn CC into some Mythical, Tactical God. Especially when their records here are practically identical.

They either both did / are doing, well with the squad they had / have or they are equally shit. You simply can't put one on a pedestal and the other in the gutter, it just doesn't add up.  Big Grin

You can put one in the Champions League and one in the bin though.
How?
I don’t get it?
Reply
#33
(03-30-2025, 01:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: What has actually hurt is is the 5 games between managers. If we had continued CCs ppg (35 from 22 by the way) we'd now have 62 points and would have finished relatively comfortably in the play-offs on 73 points. So between the caretakers and Mogga we're 5 points below par from 17 games. Now Brunt and Abella only ticked us over at 1.2 ppg and used up 5 matches. So by some logic Corberán's ppg continuing until the end of the season less Brunt and Abella 5 matches, then crucially plus 6 points. We should end up with 71.2 points. It means he needs to take 14 points from the last 7 games for par and that's title winning form. If he matches CC we get in the play-offs, if he doesn't we likely don't.

Working just in case: 1.591 x 41 + 6 =  71.23

To extrapolate.

Corberán 73 point season
Mowbray 61 point season
Caretakers 55 point season

He isn't matching him currently.
Reply
#34
(03-30-2025, 02:42 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: What has actually hurt is is the 5 games between managers. If we had continued CCs ppg (35 from 22 by the way) we'd now have 62 points and would have finished relatively comfortably in the play-offs on 73 points. So between the caretakers and Mogga we're 5 points below par from 17 games. Now Brunt and Abella only ticked us over at 1.2 ppg and used up 5 matches. So by some logic Corberán's ppg continuing until the end of the season less Brunt and Abella 5 matches, then crucially plus 6 points. We should end up with 71.2 points. It means he needs to take 14 points from the last 7 games for par and that's title winning form. If he matches CC we get in the play-offs, if he doesn't we likely don't.

Working just in case: 1.591 x 41 + 6 =  71.23

To extrapolate.

Corberán 73 point season
Mowbray 61 point season
Caretakers 55 point season

He isn't matching him currently.
Can’t argue, but a fairer reflection would be the same number of games, counting backwards from CC’s departure and forward from TM’s arrival. 
No point including caretakers.
Reply
#35
(03-30-2025, 02:52 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:42 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: What has actually hurt is is the 5 games between managers. If we had continued CCs ppg (35 from 22 by the way) we'd now have 62 points and would have finished relatively comfortably in the play-offs on 73 points. So between the caretakers and Mogga we're 5 points below par from 17 games. Now Brunt and Abella only ticked us over at 1.2 ppg and used up 5 matches. So by some logic Corberán's ppg continuing until the end of the season less Brunt and Abella 5 matches, then crucially plus 6 points. We should end up with 71.2 points. It means he needs to take 14 points from the last 7 games for par and that's title winning form. If he matches CC we get in the play-offs, if he doesn't we likely don't.

Working just in case: 1.591 x 41 + 6 =  71.23

To extrapolate.

Corberán 73 point season
Mowbray 61 point season
Caretakers 55 point season

He isn't matching him currently.
Can’t argue, but a fairer reflection would be the same number of games, counting backwards from CC’s departure and forward from TM’s arrival. 
No point including caretakers.

Not for me, the season is the season. As someone else said, yes he's matching him if you take away Corberán's wins. The irony is if he matches Corberán's start to the season from now we'll get there comfortably.
Reply
#36
(03-30-2025, 02:58 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:52 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:42 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: What has actually hurt is is the 5 games between managers. If we had continued CCs ppg (35 from 22 by the way) we'd now have 62 points and would have finished relatively comfortably in the play-offs on 73 points. So between the caretakers and Mogga we're 5 points below par from 17 games. Now Brunt and Abella only ticked us over at 1.2 ppg and used up 5 matches. So by some logic Corberán's ppg continuing until the end of the season less Brunt and Abella 5 matches, then crucially plus 6 points. We should end up with 71.2 points. It means he needs to take 14 points from the last 7 games for par and that's title winning form. If he matches CC we get in the play-offs, if he doesn't we likely don't.

Working just in case: 1.591 x 41 + 6 =  71.23

To extrapolate.

Corberán 73 point season
Mowbray 61 point season
Caretakers 55 point season

He isn't matching him currently.
Can’t argue, but a fairer reflection would be the same number of games, counting backwards from CC’s departure and forward from TM’s arrival. 
No point including caretakers.

Not for me, the season is the season. As someone else said, yes he's matching him if you take away Corberán's wins. The irony is if he matches Corberán's start to the season from now we'll get there comfortably.
Yes but, if you do it over an uneven number of games, the ppg gets skewed. Someone could have 2ppg over 30 games but be behind his replacement who wins his first 3.
Reply
#37
(03-30-2025, 03:06 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:58 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:52 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:42 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 01:49 PM)Jacko Wrote: What has actually hurt is is the 5 games between managers. If we had continued CCs ppg (35 from 22 by the way) we'd now have 62 points and would have finished relatively comfortably in the play-offs on 73 points. So between the caretakers and Mogga we're 5 points below par from 17 games. Now Brunt and Abella only ticked us over at 1.2 ppg and used up 5 matches. So by some logic Corberán's ppg continuing until the end of the season less Brunt and Abella 5 matches, then crucially plus 6 points. We should end up with 71.2 points. It means he needs to take 14 points from the last 7 games for par and that's title winning form. If he matches CC we get in the play-offs, if he doesn't we likely don't.

Working just in case: 1.591 x 41 + 6 =  71.23

To extrapolate.

Corberán 73 point season
Mowbray 61 point season
Caretakers 55 point season

He isn't matching him currently.
Can’t argue, but a fairer reflection would be the same number of games, counting backwards from CC’s departure and forward from TM’s arrival. 
No point including caretakers.

Not for me, the season is the season. As someone else said, yes he's matching him if you take away Corberán's wins. The irony is if he matches Corberán's start to the season from now we'll get there comfortably.
Yes but, if you do it over an uneven number of games, the ppg gets skewed. Someone could have 2ppg over 30 games but be behind his replacement who wins his first 3.

I would have agreed after 5/6 games of ToMo, but there's a fair sample size now. I would disregard the caretakers.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#38
(03-30-2025, 11:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 11:05 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 10:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 08:22 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Fair post. There really is little difference between CC’s last 12 and Mowbray’s first 12.
Our away form has always been an issue so anyone claiming that we wouldn’t have lost to Norwich under CC is just deluded. Nor can they claim that we wouldn’t have drawn with Hull at home, as this season has been littered with such results.
The squad is no better, with only Price being a genuine success and the future champions league quip is just daft. He may, he may not. At this moment he very much is not, however! Lamp Frankard is but no one wanted him!
We’ll finish around the 70 point mark so nothings changed on that score.
Whilst its correct to criticise TM now, he shouldn’t, and won’t, be judged until the end of the season, so those who seem so keen for him to fail just to be proven right are ridiculous IMVHO. Will they boycott Wembley if we get there or just turn up in Corberan masks?

We should be getting to the playoffs, the squad is in the top six in the division. TM has had one promotion with the best squad and biggest wage bill and that’s about it at this level. I hear the argument he can make young players better, that’s fine but ultimately we need promotion and soon, the longer we linger in this division the less likely that is to happen. If we fail to reach the playoffs this year, there can be no excuses it’s a failure and I doubt given the current manager record that will improve next season… quite the contrary.

How do you know that our squad is in the top 6 in the division?
I see this a lot. But to know that, you'd have to spend a lot of time watching Bristol city, Cardiff, Sunderland  Coventry , Millwall....
I bet you don't.

Ok, if you want to make excuses that our squad isn’t in the top six then, I will point to the fact Megson, Hodgson and even Pulis (fir two seasons) got teams punching all above the quality of their respective squads weight. It was the input of those managers who made the positive difference. TM arguably made our playoff squad punch below its weight and even our promotion was built on one of the lowest points totals ever. He’s a bang average midtable Champ manager imo. If he proves me wrong great, but let’s stop trying to argue we have a squad that is only good enough to finish 10,9,8,7 in the league.
I don't want to make excuses for anything.I really don't know how our squad compares to that of others..is my point.
There's only one way I know to find out, and that's the final league table.
Unless you watch every team a lot. And are a good judge of course too.
But, despite a poor performance yesterday, I'll make my mind up at the end of the season.
Last live game I saw we more than matched arguably the best team in the league, Leeds!
Reply
#39
(03-30-2025, 03:20 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 03:06 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:58 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:52 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 02:42 PM)Jacko Wrote: To extrapolate.

Corberán 73 point season
Mowbray 61 point season
Caretakers 55 point season

He isn't matching him currently.
Can’t argue, but a fairer reflection would be the same number of games, counting backwards from CC’s departure and forward from TM’s arrival. 
No point including caretakers.

Not for me, the season is the season. As someone else said, yes he's matching him if you take away Corberán's wins. The irony is if he matches Corberán's start to the season from now we'll get there comfortably.
Yes but, if you do it over an uneven number of games, the ppg gets skewed. Someone could have 2ppg over 30 games but be behind his replacement who wins his first 3.

I would have agreed after 5/6 games of ToMo, but there's a fair sample size now. I would disregard the caretakers.
Disagree, sample has to be the same size.
Reply
#40
(03-30-2025, 03:38 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 11:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 11:05 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 10:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-30-2025, 08:22 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Fair post. There really is little difference between CC’s last 12 and Mowbray’s first 12.
Our away form has always been an issue so anyone claiming that we wouldn’t have lost to Norwich under CC is just deluded. Nor can they claim that we wouldn’t have drawn with Hull at home, as this season has been littered with such results.
The squad is no better, with only Price being a genuine success and the future champions league quip is just daft. He may, he may not. At this moment he very much is not, however! Lamp Frankard is but no one wanted him!
We’ll finish around the 70 point mark so nothings changed on that score.
Whilst its correct to criticise TM now, he shouldn’t, and won’t, be judged until the end of the season, so those who seem so keen for him to fail just to be proven right are ridiculous IMVHO. Will they boycott Wembley if we get there or just turn up in Corberan masks?

We should be getting to the playoffs, the squad is in the top six in the division. TM has had one promotion with the best squad and biggest wage bill and that’s about it at this level. I hear the argument he can make young players better, that’s fine but ultimately we need promotion and soon, the longer we linger in this division the less likely that is to happen. If we fail to reach the playoffs this year, there can be no excuses it’s a failure and I doubt given the current manager record that will improve next season… quite the contrary.

How do you know that our squad is in the top 6 in the division?
I see this a lot. But to know that, you'd have to spend a lot of time watching Bristol city, Cardiff, Sunderland  Coventry , Millwall....
I bet you don't.

Ok, if you want to make excuses that our squad isn’t in the top six then, I will point to the fact Megson, Hodgson and even Pulis (fir two seasons) got teams punching all above the quality of their respective squads weight. It was the input of those managers who made the positive difference. TM arguably made our playoff squad punch below its weight and even our promotion was built on one of the lowest points totals ever. He’s a bang average midtable Champ manager imo. If he proves me wrong great, but let’s stop trying to argue we have a squad that is only good enough to finish 10,9,8,7 in the league.
I don't want to make excuses for anything.I really don't know how our squad compares to that of others..is my point.
There's only one way I know to find out, and that's the final league table.
Unless you watch every team a lot. And are a good judge of course too.
But, despite a poor performance yesterday, I'll make my mind up at the end of the season.
Last live game I saw we more than matched arguably the best team in the league, Leeds!

But this theory is flawed there’s multiple reasons a club finishes where it does and whilst one of the main ones is the quality of squad, others include injuries, suspensions and the manager(s). In many of our most successful seasons we haven’t had a squad that reflected where we finished if the managers input was neutral, likewise in some of our poorest (hi Bruce). The team hasn’t been thrashed by any of the top six because it’s a top six quality squad that isn’t producing performances consistently and I’d argue that’s every bit as much down to the managers as it is a reflection of the squads ability. 

The table doesn’t tell a lie, but it doesn’t tell you the whole picture either when it comes to why a club finishes where it does.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: