Griffiths in goal
#61
The club is still in debt , Griffiths is said to be a saleable asset but the longer he is on the bench the more his value will drop . Wildsmith offers us no resale value. From a business point of view alone it doesn’t make sense.
Reply
#62
(03-14-2025, 06:53 AM)The Price is Right Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 10:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: A player makes a mistake. The manager sticks with him...is good management.

There were plenty on here telling us that Button was a better GK than Johnston not long ago.... till he started playing.

In the long term it's Griffiths, but let's not denigrate Wildsmith's abilities. Unless we're looking for a scapegoat of course.

Wildsmith is shit - a blind Mon could see that.

Thank you for sharing your deep insights with us Archbishop.
Reply
#63
(03-14-2025, 06:59 AM)Faggits_n_Payse Wrote: The club is still in debt , Griffiths is said to be a saleable asset but the longer he is on the bench the more his value will drop . Wildsmith offers us no resale value. From a business point of view alone it doesn’t make sense.

Is this correct as we got Wildsmith on a free from Derby (out of contract), so any sale would be profit.
Reply
#64
Good to see Spandau massively off the mark in his assessments of Wildsmith's performances thus far. Keep up the good work.
Reply
#65
(03-14-2025, 10:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Good to see Spandau massively off the mark in his assessments of Wildsmith's performances thus far. Keep up the good work.

Edited for you:-

Good to see Mowbray massively off the mark in his assessments of Wildsmith's performances thus far. Keep up the good work.
Reply
#66
Anyone remember Foster's mistake v Villa?
Cost us the game.
Yet Foster is the best GK I've seen at the Albion.

Players make mistakes... decades ago I remember a pre War sage saying something like "if no-one ever made a mistake every game would end 0-0".
Reply
#67
(03-14-2025, 10:42 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Anyone remember Foster's mistake v Villa?
Cost us the game......

Having successfully managed to block that image from my memory for years I've just had a flashback. There was no need for that you know. My day will be irrevocably worse now than it would have been. I just want you to know that if anything untoward happens to me today, such as a piano falling on my head from a great height, I will hold you entirely responsible in the next life. If there is one. Some posts should come with public health warnings  Tongue .
Reply
#68
(03-14-2025, 10:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Good to see Spandau massively off the mark in his assessments of Wildsmith's performances thus far. Keep up the good work.

Whose mark am I off? Yours?

I'll get over it as your opinion is not really any more relevant than any others on here, including mine.

I'm saving Wildsmith is average/underwhelming and has made one obvious clanger, with a couple of uncertain moments to add to the mix. I'm also saying I'd rather Griffiths in goal. I'm also saying fans are scrutinising him more than most keepers as we wanted and expected Griffiths.

Sorry I'm not blaming him for exactly all the goals you are. It is massively off the mark not doing this as clearly your opinion is 100 percent right.
Reply
#69
(03-14-2025, 10:42 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Anyone remember Foster's mistake v Villa?
Cost us the game.
Yet Foster is the best GK I've seen at the Albion.

Players make mistakes... decades ago I remember a pre War sage saying something like "if no-one ever made a mistake every game would end 0-0".

Foster had several years of good performances for us before that mistake though, Wildsmith does not and he's been very iffy in the games before Burnley
Reply
#70
Of course players make mistakes. They're human. I don't think anyone is denying this. If Wildsmith had had an average and quiet first 6 games, then made an error, reasonable people would accept that as part and parcel of the game. It happens.

What people can't accept is that he's making numerous errors, at least 3 of which have led to opposition goals, and he IS costing us points. All this while we have an exciting young prospect sat on the bench, twiddling his thumbs, while he watches the guy who is keeping him on the bench throw in goals!

It's not just a one off mistake. There is no evidence, so far, that there is a keeper worthy of the no.1 spot of a team chasing promotion. Reasonable people are rightly questioning the delusional decision of persisting with him.

I'm not sure why the above is so hard to understand?

I think there's an OK keeper there, he has made some good saves at important times in games. But that is seemingly a rarity rather than the norm. 6/7 games is obviously too early to form an outright judgement, and I'm all for patience, but not when we're chasing promotion with only 10 games left and clearly a superior alternative waiting for their turn.

He'll be a very good backup GK for us. But not a no.1. That's my far too early to judge opinion.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)