Well Done Labour
#51
Reality is biting for Labour, that’s all.
Reply
#52
Legacy is biting, that’s the reality. Tories and Brexit was a devastating combination.
Reply
#53
(03-09-2025, 09:10 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 08:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 07:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The article is a scaremongering piece of nothing. Let’s wait to see what is actually proposed rather than have an article with lots of ‘May’s’ and sources in it. Nobody wants to punish the most vulnerable and let’s get a system that helps them best.

Tell that to the disabled community and the charities and organisations that support them, because they have lost trust in this government long before the ITV story, perhaps this government should ask why they aren’t trusted by people who would naturally look to them for support and vote fur them. Oh and I wonder who ‘leaked’ the story? I dint believe a word this government says and I dint believe they have the best intentions for the most vulnerable.

What would you do? We’re at the start of the road to getting a normal government again. We have fought to get rid of instant bullshit politics from self interested morons who would say anything and have a government who don’t use ‘look over there’ politics. They’re trying to fix a broken system and although there is nothing that you can show that they have done to the vulnerable you are outraged that there is an article that says what they might do. 

Can you point to one thing that they have done that hurts the vulnerable. and as asked many times, what would you do?

Let’s turn this on its head as we are using the ‘gotcha’ question of ‘what would you do’. What have Labour currently done to help the most disabled or their carers who have seen services cut to the bone fir 14  now nearly 15yrs? What have Labour communicated to the general public with their messaging? Oh that’s right ‘more difficult decisions, Steve Stride-esque messaging about lazy, workshy people on benefits without any nuance whatsoever between the myriad of people they are lumping together. Threats and leaks to the press about cuts. 

The fact the disabled community don’t trust the Labour Party, the most pertinent question should why? Particularly given most would have voted for them at the last election less than a year ago. 

If you want some things I’d do… firstly I would do an impact assessment on what proposed cuts would mean and how their ‘solutions’ will help. I would ask the question what pressure cuts to benefits would have on other services such as health, housing and social care. Has Kendall done this? Can she show evidence she has? She couldn’t answer that question when asked by the BBC yesterday. 

Secondly It is possible to separate the most disabled and their carers and shield them from any cuts to their PIP and related benefits by virtue of all the hoops and degrading, expensive and futile assessments they are asked to undertake constantly even though they’re never going get better or suddenly become able to work. Heck that might even save the government money it can put towards some drones and bombs. 

Thirdly I’d ask the actual people who are going to be at the sharp end of these decisions such as charities, and pesky experts what they would do tackle the problems. Something that charities and experts have said they have failed to do and are ignoring their warnings, 

Fourthly I’d look to tackle the reasons why so many people are on long term sick before I just cut the budget with some feeble idea around job coaches.

Last im more than happy to cut benefit to those who are genuinely taking the micky but that is not going to save billions of pounds but optics eh?!
Reply
#54
Why do you think so many people are on long term sickness benefits?
Reply
#55
(03-09-2025, 09:52 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Why do you think so many people are on long term sickness benefits?

You would have to ask them, why do you think they are?
Reply
#56
You said you’d like to tackle the reasons. What do you think those reasons are constituted of?

In answer to your question that’s fairly obvious, they are the claimants of the said benefits
Reply
#57
Steve Stride was Club Secretary at Villa in the 1980s. What’s he got to do with anything?
Reply
#58
(03-09-2025, 10:01 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: You said you’d like to tackle the reasons. What do you think those reasons are constituted of?

In answer to your question that’s fairly obvious, they are the claimants of the said benefits

Being facetious isn’t answering the question. I don’t know the answer as I said.  Why do you think so many people are claiming sickness benefit?

(03-09-2025, 10:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Steve Stride was Club Secretary at Villa in the 1980s. What’s he got to do with anything?

Sorry easy mix those two Vile people up.
Reply
#59
It wasn’t facetious at all, it was responding to your overly egged belief that anyone wanting a debate must be some sort of hidden believer that many claimants are fraudulent. I dont believe that at all. I was trying to have a sensible conversation and gave your fairly loaded question a factual answer.

I’d say the reasons include

Covid (mental and physical impact)

Perverse incentives

A flawed UC system

Overwhelmed doctors

Ageing society

People making sensible choices when faced with weighing up risk and reward
Reply
#60
(03-09-2025, 10:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry easy mix those two Vile people up.

Arf. True dat

(03-09-2025, 10:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Why do you think so many people are claiming sickness benefit?

Because they can?

Because there's been a massive rise in the diagnosis of all sorts of shit which used to be classed as "life"?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)