Well Done Labour
#41
(03-09-2025, 04:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Is this actually something in place or been announced, or are we discussing something that might happen?

It’s something that ITV leaked and hasn’t been denied. It maybe a softening up exercise but if so that’s a horrible way to deal with people who are terrified of the ramifications of these mooted/leaked cuts.
Reply
#42
So it’s not a real thing - what is the context, if you point me in the right direction I’ll look at what’s been said and respond.
Reply
#43
(03-09-2025, 04:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 02:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 11:50 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The altering of the assessment process is absolutely necessary.

The freeze should only be applied to the better off in my opinion and on that specific point I agree with you. However, the fact that is a benefit that has ballooned out of control is yet another legacy issue that will take time to correct

PIP supports people with long term disability and illness to live as independent life as possible and research has shown fraud in this area is virtually zero. It’s very hard to keep this civil when Labour politicians, members and supporter are actively supporting freezing it for the most vulnerable people in society. Sorry but I think it’s a really horrible position and I’m bring very polite. 

Why aren’t they going after tax evaders? Which one is the biggest problem in the U.K.? John the severely disabled guy from Bilston whose parents may have left him a tiny amount of their savings or company / individual evading tax? This is the politics of the bully, no wonder Kier is so comfortable kissing Trumps ring.

To be honest Derek - your post tells me there is a lot you don’t understand about how it works and who it covers. The issue with it is that it has clumped a load of people under one umbrella that have very differing needs. And the application process is gravely flawed. You are right that it does cover some people that you mention, but a whole breadth of other stuff as well. You really need to understand it fully to make a coherent case.

Jacko - yep, you’re right it would be unworkable to do it the way it that addressing these flaws would ideally allow

I know the system as well as you I guarantee that. You say it’s a flawed system and acknowledge that there are people like John, but then suggest that cuts across the board should be made because it’s too complicated to do otherwise. Sort the system out first don’t punish people like John for the ineptness of a system incapable of nuanced decision making. Btw months ago I said that those like John from Bilston and their carers should be separated from the wider welfare system and ludicrous constant assessments, useless national and local bureaucrats. 

I’m as sceptical as many others on here about those who proclaim anxiety or similar as a reason to go off on long term sickness but by lumping everyone together in the rhetoric like Kendall and co are doing is insulting, degrading and downright nasty.

(03-09-2025, 04:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So it’s not a real thing - what is the context, if you point me in the right direction I’ll look at what’s been said and respond.

It was the headline news in ITV. Context or there’s this article ‘Scroungers and shirkers

Here’s the lead summary… 

Even those with extreme disabilities in the unfit to work category are likely to lose money under new government plans, ITV News Deputy Political Editor, Anushka Asthana reports

My politics haven’t changed, I’m about looking after the most vulnerable and fairness. Some people’s politics have imo simply because the colour of the rosette has changed.
Reply
#44
I agree with you sort the system out first.

What would you do, how would you do it and how long do you think that would take.
Reply
#45
The article is a scaremongering piece of nothing. Let’s wait to see what is actually proposed rather than have an article with lots of ‘May’s’ and sources in it. Nobody wants to punish the most vulnerable and let’s get a system that helps them best.
Reply
#46
(03-09-2025, 07:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The article is a scaremongering piece of nothing. Let’s wait to see what is actually proposed rather than have an article with lots of ‘May’s’ and sources in it. Nobody wants to punish the most vulnerable and let’s get a system that helps them best.

Tell that to the disabled community and the charities and organisations that support them, because they have lost trust in this government long before the ITV story, perhaps this government should ask why they aren’t trusted by people who would naturally look to them for support and vote fur them. Oh and I wonder who ‘leaked’ the story? I dint believe a word this government says and I dint believe they have the best intentions for the most vulnerable.
Reply
#47
What would you do, how would you do it and how long do you think that would take.
Reply
#48
(03-09-2025, 08:56 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: What would you do, how would you do it and how long do you think that would take.

Hi Proth.
Reply
#49
(03-09-2025, 08:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 07:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The article is a scaremongering piece of nothing. Let’s wait to see what is actually proposed rather than have an article with lots of ‘May’s’ and sources in it. Nobody wants to punish the most vulnerable and let’s get a system that helps them best.

Tell that to the disabled community and the charities and organisations that support them, because they have lost trust in this government long before the ITV story, perhaps this government should ask why they aren’t trusted by people who would naturally look to them for support and vote fur them. Oh and I wonder who ‘leaked’ the story? I dint believe a word this government says and I dint believe they have the best intentions for the most vulnerable.

What would you do? We’re at the start of the road to getting a normal government again. We have fought to get rid of instant bullshit politics from self interested morons who would say anything and have a government who don’t use ‘look over there’ politics. They’re trying to fix a broken system and although there is nothing that you can show that they have done to the vulnerable you are outraged that there is an article that says what they might do. 

Can you point to one thing that they have done that hurts the vulnerable. and as asked many times, what would you do?
Reply
#50
(03-09-2025, 09:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 08:56 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: What would you do, how would you do it and how long do you think that would take.

Hi Proth.

It’s just got a bit of an old man shouts at cloud aspect to it now Dekka.

For the record, given uprating won’t be suspended until April 2026 at the earliest, I’d propose they use that time to clear both of the current backlogs (new applications and reviews) and move applications that are primarily based around mental health to face to face interview with a requirement for more substantial evidence. I’d segregate the points system compared to physical disability and review the very narrow and simplistic four different rates that exist. That could both save money overall but improve payments for the type of claimant you refer to.

Simply shouting on this board about how unfair it all is when it hasn’t even been disclosed yet is just a bit vacuous
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: