Trump vs Zelensky
(03-04-2025, 09:45 AM)DemonicBaggie Wrote: The level of media manipulation and control in the US is akin to state propaganda in places like Russia and North Korea. Truth is nowhere, versions of it are simply created by those in power. This situation has always existed, an example in this country being Murdoch’s plugging of his own political beliefs through a formerly left-leaning rag that he bought called the Sun. Events in the US, again with Murdoch heavily involved but with the addition of Musk, takes things to a whole new level. It begs the question as to the role of ‘democracy’ in this situation, where there is so much mis- and disinformation swilling around that making informed choices becomes ever more challenging. Paradoxically, the more access we have to inter-connectedness the more vulnerable we are to these trends.

That’s about it. Superbly put.

I’d add though that there’s also the impact of other areas of fragmented media that mean there are whole subsections of society who don’t really consume much of care much for anything political or global. Or know much beyond the superficial about any of it. Or care.

I do think it we end up in a hot war, Western Europe will have far fewer willing combatants to the ideology it stands behind than our enemies or opponents will, and they know this.
Reply
Heard a stat yesterday that the GDP of Russia is smaller than that of Texas. It’s one reason why Putin has failed so abysmally in this war and he’ll never succeed. What I don’t understand is Starmer and Macron going on about an American back-stop, we don’t need one. All we need is for European leaders to show some unity and balls and Putin and his fucking useless so-called army gets sent packing.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 09:50 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Heard a stat yesterday that the GDP of Russia is smaller than that of Texas.  It’s one reason why Putin has failed so abysmally in this war and he’ll never succeed.  What I don’t understand is Starmer and Macron going on about an American back-stop, we don’t need one.  All we need is for European leaders to show some unity and balls and Putin and his fucking useless so-called army gets sent packing.

That just depends how effective you think their nukes and other weaponary is and what happens if you use it. The economic thing is relevant but not the whole picture
Reply
(03-04-2025, 08:37 AM)KeithCurle'stoepoke Wrote: I've not got time today to answer everything that has been offered up, but to summarise, the views are entirely skewed to a Western European viewpoint with a clock starting in February 2022.

It is a Ukrainian civil war that has been hot sin e 2014, engineered since the 1990s, and planned since the 1950s. Western corporate interests have seen Ukraine turned into an East German police state, depopulated, and destroyed. And what people want here is more of it. More Plan A despite the fact the longer it goes on, the worse the terms will be, and the more corpses pile up.

You're entitled to your views, but to me they lack context and any sense of realism. You've a paid actor put in place by a billionaire oligarch who made a TV series to get his proxy elected, and you're comparing him to Churchill. The guy is a dupe who was setup from the start to take the fall when Ukraine inevitably got wrecked. Easy to cheer on fighting to the last man from a thousand miles away.

If you're going to do this, Pokey, please show some attention to detail!! I didn't liken Zelensky to Churchill. Western leaders are in the position Churchill was in, deciding whether or not to get involved in a situation which at present doesn't threaten them directly. Both the moral question of right and wrong and the risk of future repeats of the same behaviour by the aggressor are factors to be considered.

You haven't answered my questions - do you think Winston Churchill did the right thing in opposing Hitler and effectively making a World War out of German expansionism? Do you think it would have been okay to let Hitler have Europe so long as he stayed on his side of the Channel? Let's hear what you think instead of what you've read.
Reply
The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.
Reply
All the above would be much more effective if Trump wasn’t effectively undermining everything that NATO relies on to be effective. The certainty that all sides act and that the US is unequivocally a part of that.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 08:50 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I actually respect him for putting his view across and at least trying to substantiate it. I don’t agree with much of it and I think what truths it holds lack critical thinking in acknowledging the vast swathe of issues with considering the opposite viewpoint.

As with everything these days, people seem to struggle to take any sort of holistic view. I don’t think Ukraine is squeaky clean. I just wouldn’t ever see it’s various foibles as a reason to ignore everything that is stacked up in favour of supporting them and resisting the very real danger Putin and Russian poses. Both things can be and are true.

+1 on everything here. These things are never black and white and Russia, as it did in most countries, embedded a lot of its own in certain parts so they would remain "Russian". I remember hearing something prior to the second invasion that in a list of "most corrupt countries in the world" Russia was 6th but Ukraine was above them (maybe 4th). 

Putin played the Nazi card early on appealing that its "own people" were "under attack" in the Donbas. This seemed to be scant opportunism at best but it's understanding what the actual goal is. You'd think it were getting their hands on the same minerals etc. that the US are after but does this mean taking all of the Ukraine. 

I agree with the point that at some point a line will need to be drawn in the sand on which all sides agree. It would be a massive climbdown for Zelensky but the risk is always if Russia is then given the Donbas would there be any risk that Putin would try and push West again. I think there is.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 10:19 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.

That's similar to what Musk has proposed, so that's sufficient reason to disagree with it for me because he's not impartial. Putin's not going to compromise on anything whilst he has Trump and Musk as his chief cheerleaders. Neither should aggressors be rewarded for invading and controlling soverign territory.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 09:50 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Heard a stat yesterday that the GDP of Russia is smaller than that of Texas. It’s one reason why Putin has failed so abysmally in this war and he’ll never succeed. What I don’t understand is Starmer and Macron going on about an American back-stop, we don’t need one. All we need is for European leaders to show some unity and balls and Putin and his fucking useless so-called army gets sent packing.

Generals reckon at least 100k troops are needed, UK and France can't provide that many (UK troop total is only around 70k)... So if between us we can whack 50-75k troops that's why they want the back stop. Plus US intelligence / air support stuff is what's also needed.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 10:36 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(03-04-2025, 10:19 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.

That's similar to what Musk has proposed, so that's sufficient reason to disagree with it for me because he's not impartial. Putin's not going to compromise on anything whilst he has Trump and Musk as his chief cheerleaders. Neither should aggressors be rewarded for invading and controlling soverign territory.

I think Musk is a twat but I'm not going to dismiss everything he ever says just because I don't like him.

There has to be compromise.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)