Trump vs Zelensky
Whenever anyone writes a list of countries like:

"Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Yemen, Syria" and claims that everything that happened in those countries is solely a result of Western interference, I know that they are not very well-informed.

Also, such arguments always have this weird dichotomy, whereby Russia is super strong (therefore Ukraine shouldn't bother to fight them), but also seems to find the likes of Estonia being in NATO massively threatening.

The other part where the argument falls down is that Russia Invaded Ukraine.

First in 2014 in Crimea

Then in 2022 in the "Special Military Operation"

They clearly thought Ukraine would be little more than Chechnya mk II but they reckoned without the size and ability of Ukraine to fight and the revulsion felt by Europe, approximately half of which has experience of being a Russian satellite state in living and unfond memory. At this point Russia might want to to truly reflect upon exactly, nearly 40 years after the fall of the Iron Curtain, it remains as hated by it's neighbours as ever.
Reply
For peace both sides need to feel the need to end it. Putin has all but been endorsed in his invasion by Trump and therefore has no reason to negotiate a settlement, just push on with his invasion.

Europe should tell Trump to fuck off and support Ukraine with weapons (front line and long distance) and finance. Troops at this stage would be a step too far.

THEN negotiations can start on Russia leaving, Ukraine agreeing NATO is not for them and Crimea can be a naval port.

Russia are to blame for the war but there is some truth in that the West provoked Russia with e giving countries on their border to join NATO. There’s always been an unwritten rule that those countries would act as a buffer. So, we’re not entirely blameless but ultimately it’s Putin who has taken this action and Putin who was emboldened from his 2014 invasion of Crimea. That wasn’t because of NATO.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(03-02-2025, 11:15 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: For peace both sides need to feel the need to end it.  Putin has all but been endorsed in his invasion by Trump and therefore has no reason to negotiate a settlement, just push on with his invasion.

Europe should tell Trump to fuck off and support Ukraine with weapons (front line and long distance) and finance.  Troops at this stage would be a step too far.

THEN negotiations can start on Russia leaving, Ukraine agreeing NATO is not for them and Crimea can be a naval port.

Russia are to blame for the war but there is some truth in that the West provoked Russia with e giving countries on their border to join NATO.  There’s always been an unwritten rule that those countries would act as a buffer.  So, we’re not entirely blameless but ultimately it’s Putin who has taken this action and Putin who was emboldened from his 2014 invasion of Crimea.  That wasn’t because of NATO.

While we most of us agree with the sentiments, the serious way to deal with the bully and the war hero is what Starmer's doing. Negotiate a way between them. Doesn't make for "great TV" as the oaf in the White House has it. But it's more likely to get a proper peace deal.
Reply
^ absolutely.

"Meeting jaw to jaw is better than war..."
Reply
(03-02-2025, 08:11 AM)KeithCurle'stoepoke Wrote: I'll try and give my point of view on the opinions raised.

What would be your solution. Is it side with Russia and to allow them to keep what they've taken? 
If so, do you trust Putin to stop there?
Reply
(03-02-2025, 11:28 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 11:15 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: For peace both sides need to feel the need to end it.  Putin has all but been endorsed in his invasion by Trump and therefore has no reason to negotiate a settlement, just push on with his invasion.

Europe should tell Trump to fuck off and support Ukraine with weapons (front line and long distance) and finance.  Troops at this stage would be a step too far.

THEN negotiations can start on Russia leaving, Ukraine agreeing NATO is not for them and Crimea can be a naval port.

Russia are to blame for the war but there is some truth in that the West provoked Russia with e giving countries on their border to join NATO.  There’s always been an unwritten rule that those countries would act as a buffer.  So, we’re not entirely blameless but ultimately it’s Putin who has taken this action and Putin who was emboldened from his 2014 invasion of Crimea.  That wasn’t because of NATO.

While we most of us agree with the sentiments, the serious way to deal with the bully and the war hero is what Starmer's doing. Negotiate a way between them. Doesn't make for "great TV" as the oaf in the White House has it. But it's more likely to get a proper peace deal.

I agree, but right now what does Putin gain from negotiations?  He needs to be brought to the table, if he thinks he can win and take Ukraine because Trump has walked away then why settle now.

Putin needs to know there’s the threat of a long drawn battle ahead, not a country deprived of weapons and support that he can push through.

The talks have to continue, but with the understanding that Ukraine is not weak, otherwise it can’t negotiate very well.  Trump has just done Putin’s bidding for him in weakening Ukraine’s position.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(03-02-2025, 11:15 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: For peace both sides need to feel the need to end it.  Putin has all but been endorsed in his invasion by Trump and therefore has no reason to negotiate a settlement, just push on with his invasion.

Europe should tell Trump to fuck off and support Ukraine with weapons (front line and long distance) and finance.  Troops at this stage would be a step too far.

THEN negotiations can start on Russia leaving, Ukraine agreeing NATO is not for them and Crimea can be a naval port.

Russia are to blame for the war but there is some truth in that the West provoked Russia with e giving countries on their border to join NATO.  There’s always been an unwritten rule that those countries would act as a buffer.  So, we’re not entirely blameless but ultimately it’s Putin who has taken this action and Putin who was emboldened from his 2014 invasion of Crimea.  That wasn’t because of NATO.

I e never for one minute believed Putin is threatened by NATO. It didn’t bother him when he used chemical weapons on British Soil.
Reply
(03-02-2025, 11:39 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 08:11 AM)KeithCurle'stoepoke Wrote: I'll try and give my point of view on the opinions raised.

What would be your solution. Is it side with Russia and to allow them to keep what they've taken? 
If so, do you trust Putin to stop there?

Exactly Richbaggie. Putin needed stopping years ago, the only way to get at him now is by the continued embargo on Russia. Unfortunately the big orange moron has now scuppered that. As for KeithCurlespoke, I respect many of your points but see no genuine justification for Russia's expansionism nor Putin's vindictive aggression in many foreign countries. A decent politician should harness Russia's mineral wealth and employ it's enormous manpower to the benefit of the majority of Russians, not for the wealth of complicit oligarchs.
Reply
(03-02-2025, 01:39 PM)HugeHons Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 11:15 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: For peace both sides need to feel the need to end it.  Putin has all but been endorsed in his invasion by Trump and therefore has no reason to negotiate a settlement, just push on with his invasion.

Europe should tell Trump to fuck off and support Ukraine with weapons (front line and long distance) and finance.  Troops at this stage would be a step too far.

THEN negotiations can start on Russia leaving, Ukraine agreeing NATO is not for them and Crimea can be a naval port.

Russia are to blame for the war but there is some truth in that the West provoked Russia with e giving countries on their border to join NATO.  There’s always been an unwritten rule that those countries would act as a buffer.  So, we’re not entirely blameless but ultimately it’s Putin who has taken this action and Putin who was emboldened from his 2014 invasion of Crimea.  That wasn’t because of NATO.

I e never for one minute believed Putin is threatened by NATO. It didn’t bother him when he used chemical weapons on British Soil.

Using chemical weapons as they did is somewhat different to an invasion.  He’s no reason to feel threatened but the argument has always been Western forces could be stacked on his borders and that’s something he’d wish to avoid. 

It also gives him an excuse/reason to expand into Ukraine.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
What border are Russian forces stacked on? Why wouldn’t those that don’t want to be part of Russia have armed forces on their own border?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)