Make Gaza Great Again
(02-26-2025, 09:16 AM)Squid Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 08:57 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Can either Proth or Ponty now explain why Israel is attacking Damascus? They literally just formed a western-aligned government and looked to be starting the transition to a liberal democracy - what the actual fuck are Israel playing at?!

They are actively trying to destabilise the country/provoke retaliation to give themselves an excuse to annex more Syrian territory.

If the Western countries fail to condemn this while defending Ukraine against similar aggression, it will be seen by many countries as the gross hypocrisy that it is.

At this point, Israel is a rogue state and should be treated as such.

That last sentence sums it up and is at the root of all the difficulties - the failure to recognise that Israel and Jews have the right to exist - bellend
Reply
(02-26-2025, 09:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 08:57 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Can either Proth or Ponty now explain why Israel is attacking Damascus? They literally just formed a western-aligned government and looked to be starting the transition to a liberal democracy - what the actual fuck are Israel playing at?!

Not that I ever claimed to speak for Israel (!) - they don't appear to be "attacking Damascus", and personally I'll believe that Islamists are either "Western aligned" or transitioning to "liberal democracy" when I see it.  

It appears Israel is using the conflagration in Syria to press demands both diplomatically and forcibly for a demilitarised zone in the south of Syria, worried that in most cases something tends to fill a power vaccuum. And it's all good for Bibi personally.

Not to say that I agree with any of it, but I can see their point.

https://m.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-843758

Airstrikes in southern Damascus. I'd call that attacking, unless you want to be pedantic over the definition of Damascus.

Syria have been nothing but accomodating to the West since the fall of Assad, they're on track to become a western-aligned liberal democracy if this course continues - which is why sanctions are being lifted by the West and they're currently scheduling elections. Israel is threatening that objective as well as creating a situation where Syria will want to retaliate and halt that march to democracy.
Reply
(02-26-2025, 09:37 AM)Squid Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 09:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 08:57 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Can either Proth or Ponty now explain why Israel is attacking Damascus? They literally just formed a western-aligned government and looked to be starting the transition to a liberal democracy - what the actual fuck are Israel playing at?!

Not that I ever claimed to speak for Israel (!) - they don't appear to be "attacking Damascus", and personally I'll believe that Islamists are either "Western aligned" or transitioning to "liberal democracy" when I see it.  

It appears Israel is using the conflagration in Syria to press demands both diplomatically and forcibly for a demilitarised zone in the south of Syria, worried that in most cases something tends to fill a power vaccuum. And it's all good for Bibi personally.

Not to say that I agree with any of it, but I can see their point.

They are already illegally occupying a chunk of Syrian territory against international law and that still isn't enough for them. Now they have launched into an unprovoked attack, killing at least two Syrian soldiers, even after the leaders of that country have publicly stated that they have no interest in attacking  Israel.

You keep trying to justify might makes right. Long term, it will be the path to suicide for Israel.

I doubt they are moving out of the Heights as they have some cracking vineyards there
Reply
(02-26-2025, 09:40 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 09:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 08:57 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Can either Proth or Ponty now explain why Israel is attacking Damascus? They literally just formed a western-aligned government and looked to be starting the transition to a liberal democracy - what the actual fuck are Israel playing at?!

Not that I ever claimed to speak for Israel (!) - they don't appear to be "attacking Damascus", and personally I'll believe that Islamists are either "Western aligned" or transitioning to "liberal democracy" when I see it.  

It appears Israel is using the conflagration in Syria to press demands both diplomatically and forcibly for a demilitarised zone in the south of Syria, worried that in most cases something tends to fill a power vaccuum. And it's all good for Bibi personally.

Not to say that I agree with any of it, but I can see their point.

https://m.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-843758

Airstrikes in southern Damascus. I'd call that attacking, unless you want to be pedantic over the definition of Damascus.

Syria have been nothing but accomodating to the West since the fall of Assad, they're on track to become a western-aligned liberal democracy if this course continues - which is why sanctions are being lifted by the West and they're currently scheduling elections. Israel is threatening that objective as well as creating a situation where Syria will want to retaliate and halt that march to democracy.


"Since #Assad's defeat, #Syria's interim gov't has intercepted ~13 weapons shipments destined for #Hezbollah in #Lebanon & crippled its drug smuggling empire; while removing dozens of concealed #IRGC arms caches.

All while declaring regional non-aggression."
https://x.com/Charles_Lister/status/1894...XRGug&s=19

But apparently it's fine for them to be bombed back to the stone age, anyway. Very little coverage of these bombings in Western media and as of yet, no political condemnation.
Reply
(02-26-2025, 09:40 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: https://m.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-843758

Airstrikes in a town 20km south ern of Damascus. I'd call that attacking, unless you want to be pedantic over the definition of Damascus.

Syria have been nothing but accomodating to the West since the fall of Assad, they're on track to become a western-aligned liberal democracy if this course continues - which is why sanctions are being lifted by the West and they're currently scheduling elections. Israel is threatening that objective as well as creating a situation where Syria will want to retaliate and halt that march to democracy.

I've corrected that for you. Syria is a failed state which has little choice but to be accommodating to a major power. They're hardly likely to choose Russia after its support for Assad. Syria doesn't have the capacity to retaliate. It knows that, so does Israel. Realpolitik, eh?
Reply
(02-26-2025, 09:47 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-26-2025, 09:40 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: https://m.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-843758

Airstrikes in a town 20km south ern of Damascus. I'd call that attacking, unless you want to be pedantic over the definition of Damascus.

Syria have been nothing but accomodating to the West since the fall of Assad, they're on track to become a western-aligned liberal democracy if this course continues - which is why sanctions are being lifted by the West and they're currently scheduling elections. Israel is threatening that objective as well as creating a situation where Syria will want to retaliate and halt that march to democracy.

I've corrected that for you. Syria is a failed state which has little choice but to be accommodating to a major power. They're hardly likely to choose Russia after its support for Assad. Syria doesn't have the capacity to retaliate. It knows that, so does Israel. Realpolitik, eh?

20km is fuck all, and it's nowhere near the border. That is properly pedantic.

And Syria not having a choice is the point, there's no benefit to us or Israel in attacking them, outside trying to provoke Syria to act irrationally and retaliate.
Reply
Israel obviously thinks there is. Israel also knows the liberal west has bigger problems to contemplate.
Reply
What is the benefit then? Trying to provoke Syria into a response so that Bibi and the far-right government can justify a formal incursion? What has Syria done that could possibly upset Israel since the fall of Assad?

And this has an impact in the West, not least disrupting our attempts to encourage Syrian refugees to return to Syria.
Reply
Ask the Israelis not me. I'm still trying to work out the perceived benefit to Hamas of October 7th.
Reply
(02-26-2025, 11:04 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Ask the Israelis not me. I'm still trying to work out the perceived benefit to Hamas of October 7th.

Strange. You’re notably quite well read and vocal in matters affecting Israel. We should revert once you’ve had the chance.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)