All time Albion stinkers
#51
(02-06-2025, 04:22 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Button must be the most recent to add to the list? He made even Carson seem half competent by comparison.

Button was invisible and indeed see-through, not exactly good traits to have as a Goal Keeper. Carson just had crisp packet hands, but he's got two Champions League medals and won the EPL 4 times.

Hold on, I need to buy me nipper some crisps.
Reply
#52
(02-06-2025, 03:23 PM)lemon Wrote: Scott Carson
Andy McDermott
Andy Townsend

Harsh on all three - especially Carson.
Reply
#53
Brown Ideye
Sherjill Macdonald
Zhang Yuning
Reply
#54
Chris Adamson
Paul Crichton
Reply
#55
(02-06-2025, 09:19 PM)Evenolderfella Wrote:
(02-06-2025, 05:59 PM)Llandudno Baggie Wrote:
(02-06-2025, 05:47 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2025, 04:01 PM)Peachy Wrote: Bang for buck Daniel Sturridge has to be right up there. Huge loan fee and pings his hammy on debut iirc. Not necessarily his fault but a stinker of a transfer. Especially given his prior injury record.

David Mills Britain’s most expensive footballer in 1979 £500k transfer from Middlesbrough and he was fucking shite, not even a pffft for buck.

You just beat me to it as i was scrolling through.

That's how ambitious and exciting we were. 

Younger posters - imagine Albion paying a British record fee to enhance an already great side, and getting pretty much bugger all for the money.

We had just won away to Arsenal on Boxing day when we signed him, and i thought weem gunna win the league what a bloody letdown, after he had looked so good for Boro

Honestly didnt think he was that bad just didnt get much of a chance and didnt play many games iirc as bomber was still banging goals in for fun at the time. 
Remember round about the same time brought a goalkeeper Dave Stewart a scots International from leeds though wow he is far better than Godden,,,, never ever played a first team game and just sort of disappeared.
Reply
#56
Scott Carson really wasn't that bad. He did however have to play behind one of the worst defences we've ever had at PL level.
Reply
#57
(02-06-2025, 06:10 PM)baggpuss Wrote: Seem to remember Nacer Chadli being decent for Belgium but on the sick for us and 13 mil?
This is the one for me.
Not because he was a bad player. He had talent.
But because he couldn't be arsed with us.
Never played well after the first few matches.
Then took the piss, taking our money (lots of it).
Then pretended to be injured for his last season, before playing well for Belgium in the world cup.

I can forgive most on here for not being very good. But not Chadli for taking the piss out of all of us.
Reply
#58
(02-06-2025, 02:43 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(02-06-2025, 02:38 PM)Duffers Wrote: Even though he was a free transfer Anelka still has to be the worst signing in the club's history.

looked miserable to be here from the very start, took a massive wage, contributed absolutely fuck all on the pitch and actively damaged the club's image with all that quenelle bullshit.

Disagree. Until La Quennelle, he looked a player, he was always a mopey sod, but he still looked a very good player. Can't forgive him for using our platform to air those views though.

Although the quenelle had been created as an anti-Jewish gesture, Anelka didn't use it in that context, if he is to be believed. Which the disciplinary panel did.

He used it as a sign to say fuck off to Steve Clarke, who had just been sacked.

Clarke bought him in as a marquee signing and that is how Anelka saw himself too. But Clarke quickly dropped Anelka after realising he wasn't up to the pace of the Premier League anymore. This obviously put Anelka's nose out of joint and he decided to use his goal(s) at West Ham to send a message to Clarke.
Reply
#59
(02-07-2025, 10:40 AM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(02-06-2025, 02:43 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(02-06-2025, 02:38 PM)Duffers Wrote: Even though he was a free transfer Anelka still has to be the worst signing in the club's history.

looked miserable to be here from the very start, took a massive wage, contributed absolutely fuck all on the pitch and actively damaged the club's image with all that quenelle bullshit.

Disagree. Until La Quennelle, he looked a player, he was always a mopey sod, but he still looked a very good player. Can't forgive him for using our platform to air those views though.

Although the quenelle had been created as an anti-Jewish gesture, Anelka didn't use it in that context, if he is to be believed. Which the disciplinary panel did.

He used it as a sign to say fuck off to Steve Clarke, who had just been sacked.

Clarke bought him in as a marquee signing and that is how Anelka saw himself too. But Clarke quickly dropped Anelka after realising he wasn't up to the pace of the Premier League anymore. This obviously put Anelka's nose out of joint and he decided to use his goal(s) at West Ham to send a message to Clarke.
Forgive my ignorance but how does that particular gesture say anything at all to Steve Clarke (who was perfectly entitled to drop Annelka as he was desperate)? Annelka was the most UN Albion signing of that period when we were good at finding Odemwingies and Mulumbys. As for the quenelle, no one knew what it was until that fat lump Samuel from the tabloids was all over it, the fat lump.
Reply
#60
Didn't it turn out Anelka was rather friendly with the anti-Jewish bloke who invented it?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)