Palmer - Adequate or Incredible?
#21
There's more to keeping than saving shots. Catching crosses, on the ball skill, communication, organising corners, distribution.

Palmer does pretty much all of these very well.
Reply
#22
(02-05-2025, 09:32 AM)HLS Wrote: There's more to keeping than saving shots. Catching crosses, on the ball skill, communication, organising corners, distribution.

Palmer does pretty much all of these very well.

There is you're right, and he performed adequately in most areas.m which are quantified. 

   

Above is his scout report Vs other championship keepers. He is half way in terms of shot stopping, cross stopping and his distribution was as we probably all knew his weakness. 

Being as the club put so much emphasis on data I am unsurprised we have let him go, and that the buying club haven't seen him as a 10 million quid keeper. I didn't realise how average his performance was tbh.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#23
Griffiths may well go on to surpass Palmer, by all accounts he has a much higher ceiling than him, but he will require patience and in the short term it does look like we have weakened ourselves in the goalkeeping department.

However as I said elsewhere, that's the calculated gamble the club have taken in order to bring in the attacking reinforcements we've desperately needed.
Reply
#24
He is a good keeper. His 2 glaring weaknesses are distribution and occasionally gets beaten too easily at his near post. Major strengths Crosses, Shot Stopping, 1 on 1s, organisation.

I'm confident in 5 years time (ie when they're the same age) Griffiths will be playing at a much higher level.
Reply
#25
(02-05-2025, 09:32 AM)HLS Wrote: There's more to keeping than saving shots. Catching crosses, on the ball skill, communication, organising corners, distribution.

Palmer does pretty much all of these very well.

Not to mention factors like the confidence and reassurance he gives the defence in front him, things which you can’t put a numerical value to and shows that certain data only gives a limited view of things.
Reply
#26
(02-05-2025, 10:46 AM)Jacko Wrote: He is a good keeper. His 2 glaring weaknesses are distribution and occasionally gets beaten too easily at his near post. Major strengths Crosses, Shot Stopping, 1 on 1s, organisation.

I'm confident in 5 years time (ie when they're the same age) Griffiths will be playing at a much higher level.

No, they'll still be the same difference in age in 5 years' time.  Big Grin
Reply
#27
Palmer's been adequate IMO - some great things and some very poor things. I trust the Board to have got the best deal that they felt they could achieve for him in the prevailing circumstances, which they largely inherited of course.

Overall, I think the dealings in this window leave us much better placed to attain the goal of reaching the play-offs. I hope Alex does well at Ipswich, except when they play us!
Reply
#28
I'd say Palmer is pretty much a 7 out of 10 every game. He's a very solid, unspectacular keeper who makes few mistakes. He gives his defence confidence and as a fan I had complete confidence in him too.

I think Griffiths is a better shot stopper, but don't think he's yet as good at dominating his area and talking to his defence, but that's something that will come with experience.

Palmer is the better of the two at this point in time, but I'd like to think Griffiths will attain a level above Palmer in a couple of years.
Reply
#29
(02-05-2025, 09:52 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-05-2025, 09:32 AM)HLS Wrote: There's more to keeping than saving shots. Catching crosses, on the ball skill, communication, organising corners, distribution.

Palmer does pretty much all of these very well.

There is you're right, and he performed adequately in most areas.m which are quantified. 



Above is his scout report Vs other championship keepers. He is half way in terms of shot stopping, cross stopping and his distribution was as we probably all knew his weakness. 

Being as the club put so much emphasis on data I am unsurprised we have let him go, and that the buying club haven't seen him as a 10 million quid keeper. I didn't realise how average his performance was tbh.

Fair enough. Perhaps my view is skewed from Button's time as number 1.
Reply
#30
I thought Palmer became a better keeper (including the near post problem) when Walsh was sacked and Abad became the coach. I've no idea if Myhill is a good coach, but all our keepers deserve the best Albion can get.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: