Grant
#31
(02-03-2025, 10:06 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 09:56 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 08:25 AM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: Tony is reminding me of an embarrassing old relative that comes out with comments that are inappropriate, unnecessary & a little crass

Interesting irony as this is how I view your sudden reemergence any time we have a bad result.

What was Mowbray supposed to say "Yes, Grant is right and I will play him from now on" - he simply said that MJ is currently in form and has the shirt but if KG works hard there's no reason why he won't feature.

Say nothing.

Say "its a squad game and we're going to need everyone"

Say "Everyone needs to work hard in training and they will get their chance to impress"

Don't say:
"As I've explained to him - I think Mikey Johnston is damaging enough teams that I'm not sure you're going to knock him out of the team at the moment."

Mowbray's obviously very enthusiastic to be back, which is great, but some conversations should remain private. That's without taking into account that KG has been in line for player of the season. If I was Grant listening to that I'd be thinking "Hang on a minute, I've scored as many goals as Johnston, Fellows, Wallace and Swift combined".

I get what you're saying and it's a little clumsy but I don't think he's closed the door to Grant, just said that MJ has impressed him!

If TM's comments have led to Grant wanting to leave, we're better off without that attitude.
Reply
#32
(02-03-2025, 10:31 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:06 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 09:56 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 08:25 AM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: Tony is reminding me of an embarrassing old relative that comes out with comments that are inappropriate, unnecessary & a little crass

Interesting irony as this is how I view your sudden reemergence any time we have a bad result.

What was Mowbray supposed to say "Yes, Grant is right and I will play him from now on" - he simply said that MJ is currently in form and has the shirt but if KG works hard there's no reason why he won't feature.

Say nothing.

Say "its a squad game and we're going to need everyone"

Say "Everyone needs to work hard in training and they will get their chance to impress"

Don't say:
"As I've explained to him - I think Mikey Johnston is damaging enough teams that I'm not sure you're going to knock him out of the team at the moment."

Mowbray's obviously very enthusiastic to be back, which is great, but some conversations should remain private. That's without taking into account that KG has been in line for player of the season. If I was Grant listening to that I'd be thinking "Hang on a minute, I've scored as many goals as Johnston, Fellows, Wallace and Swift combined".

I get what you're saying and it's a little clumsy but I don't think he's closed the door to Grant, just said that MJ has impressed him!

If TM's comments have led to Grant wanting to leave, we're better off without that attitude.

Totally agree. 

His body language was awful when he came on v Plymouth.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#33
Whatever Karlan Grant does - unless it's scoring goals - he's always going to be criticized on here. It seems to be a bored rule. Mowbray shouldn't have made his thoughts public. Grant should be playing ahead of Wallace in the "false 9" role. It's comedic how posters who have slagged Jed off all season are now saying they'd prefer him "giving 100%" then Grant with his "attitude". We've seen nothing but 100% effort and some pretty good play from Grant this season, but we click back into space-goating mode in a millisecond.

And it seems we're experts on body language now as well. Reminds me of an old mate who was denied a promotion in the civil service because "he didn't wear a proper business tie".
Reply
#34
(02-03-2025, 10:48 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Whatever Karlan Grant does - unless it's scoring goals - he's always going to be criticized on here. It seems to be a bored rule. Mowbray shouldn't have made his thoughts public. Grant should be playing ahead of Wallace in the "false 9" role. It's comedic how posters who have slagged Jed off all season are now saying they'd prefer him "giving 100%" then Grant with his "attitude". We've seen nothing but 100% effort and some pretty good play from Grant this season, but we click back into space-goating mode in a millisecond.

As is normally the case, both sides are half right. 

Grant should be starting up top considering we have no forwards. How it looks is up for debate, but he should have been in. 

But - IF, Grant has saw his arse about being told he won't be nailed on to play on the left and it's effected his body language training and performance. it's out of order.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#35
(02-03-2025, 10:48 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Whatever Karlan Grant does - unless it's scoring goals - he's always going to be criticized on here. It seems to be a bored rule. Mowbray shouldn't have made his thoughts public. Grant should be playing ahead of Wallace in the "false 9" role. It's comedic how posters who have slagged Jed off all season are now saying they'd prefer him "giving 100%" then Grant with his "attitude". We've seen nothing but 100% effort and some pretty good play from Grant this season, but we click back into space-goating mode in a millisecond.

And it seems we're experts on body language now as well. Reminds me of an old mate who was denied a promotion in the civil service because "he didn't wear a proper business tie".

Quite… I think it’s to do with them feeling the need to protect either the club or manager from criticism. It makes no fugging difference to them either way but hey-ho.
Reply
#36
Grant didn't appear to lack effort at Plymouth. That defence had done a good job nullifying Mikey 2nd half, Grant was really in a no win situation. Styles played him the odd hospital pass as well and was having a rare off day in behind KG. We probably should have played Grant central/left WITH Mikey.
Reply
#37
(02-03-2025, 10:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:48 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Whatever Karlan Grant does - unless it's scoring goals - he's always going to be criticized on here. It seems to be a bored rule. Mowbray shouldn't have made his thoughts public. Grant should be playing ahead of Wallace in the "false 9" role. It's comedic how posters who have slagged Jed off all season are now saying they'd prefer him "giving 100%" then Grant with his "attitude". We've seen nothing but 100% effort and some pretty good play from Grant this season, but we click back into space-goating mode in a millisecond.

As is normally the case, both sides are half right. 

Grant should be starting up top considering we have no forwards. How it looks is up for debate, but he should have been in. 

But - IF, Grant has saw his arse about being told he won't be nailed on to play on the left and it's effected his body language training and performance. it's out of order.

Can we stick to the facts, we don’t know what Grant has or hasn’t said we just have a bunch of gossips making stuff up or passing on rumour from dodgy Twatter sources.
Reply
#38
(02-03-2025, 10:52 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Grant didn't appear to lack effort at Plymouth.  That defence had done a good job nullifying Mikey 2nd half, Grant was really in a no win situation.  Styles played him the odd hospital pass as well and was having a rare off day in behind KG.  We probably should have played Grant central/left WITH Mikey.

Yep, IMO Grant playing up top in a 4-4-2 or as a 10, are better options than Swift or Diangana, particularly if it means we leave Mikey on the pitch
Reply
#39
(02-03-2025, 10:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:48 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Whatever Karlan Grant does - unless it's scoring goals - he's always going to be criticized on here. It seems to be a bored rule. Mowbray shouldn't have made his thoughts public. Grant should be playing ahead of Wallace in the "false 9" role. It's comedic how posters who have slagged Jed off all season are now saying they'd prefer him "giving 100%" then Grant with his "attitude". We've seen nothing but 100% effort and some pretty good play from Grant this season, but we click back into space-goating mode in a millisecond.

As is normally the case, both sides are half right. 

Grant should be starting up top considering we have no forwards. How it looks is up for debate, but he should have been in. 

But - IF, Grant has saw his arse about being told he won't be nailed on to play on the left and it's effected his body language training and performance. it's out of order.

Can we stick to the facts, we don’t know what Grant has or hasn’t said we just have a bunch of gossips making stuff up or passing on rumour from dodgy Twatter sources.

Thats why I tried to highlight the "IF". As I suggested earlier in the thread. I don't think there's owt to see from ToMos perspective. He's just suggested MJ is playing really well, which he is. 

I only commented as his body language, I felt, was off when he came on. Lots of puffing and blowing, round shouldered, not the same intensity in his pressing as we have been seeing. BUT, to be fair tactically I think he was stitched up abit second half and as a tenant was poor so couldn't have been easy to come on and try and make an impact with all being said.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#40
(02-03-2025, 10:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-03-2025, 10:48 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Whatever Karlan Grant does - unless it's scoring goals - he's always going to be criticized on here. It seems to be a bored rule. Mowbray shouldn't have made his thoughts public. Grant should be playing ahead of Wallace in the "false 9" role. It's comedic how posters who have slagged Jed off all season are now saying they'd prefer him "giving 100%" then Grant with his "attitude". We've seen nothing but 100% effort and some pretty good play from Grant this season, but we click back into space-goating mode in a millisecond.

As is normally the case, both sides are half right. 

Grant should be starting up top considering we have no forwards. How it looks is up for debate, but he should have been in. 

But - IF, Grant has saw his arse about being told he won't be nailed on to play on the left and it's effected his body language training and performance. it's out of order.

Can we stick to the facts, we don’t know what Grant has or hasn’t said we just have a bunch of gossips making stuff up or passing on rumour from dodgy Twatter sources.

Are you new here?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: