(01-23-2025, 11:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Ultimately the government took the easier and less chaotic route to what they would have had to do anyway. As the banks were so big there would have been a massive payout through the FSCS - it was a choice in 'nationalising private debt' or paying out through FSCS.
No, it wasn't. You're right it was the easier route, but is the chaos it's wrought ever since justified taking the easy way out? I think not.
(01-23-2025, 09:25 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Mr P's obsession with nationalising private debt is ridiculous and not nationalising Nat West, Norther Rock etc would have led to utter chaos, people not being paid not being able to buy food etc it's just fucking silly.
Can you explain to me why that would have happened? Because depositor protection could have been printed, essentially. You didn't need to retain completely failed institutions to do that.
Yes, you would have wiped out thousands of highly leveraged borrowers - almost all in commercial property, but I've never witnessed anyone shed a tear for property developers - and I was one for 15 years.
Riddle me this - one of the Irish NAMA funds I worked to stabilise and refinance in 2009 was (like thousands) based in IoM to avoid UK tax, owed £450m and had £250m in assets. Please provide a reason, any reason, why that debt should have been nationalised rather than called in, the assets liquidated and the borrowers bankrupted?
This is why we had zero interest rates for so long, to get delinquent funds out of the soup - and the byproduct was huge leverage by the already wealthy and a massive and still growing gulf in intergenerational inequality. Bravo, eh?
Drip, drip - I see Rachel is about to relax the wholly counter-productive non-dom rules she introduced.
Reality bites, eh?