Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(01-20-2025, 10:28 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:20 PM)HLS Wrote: I'd sign him tbf. Think he's done alright but not as a replacement for Bartley. We'll need someone else when he moves on.
I've just watched a certain Ethan Ingram put in a very good display at right back for Dundee against Dundee Utd. There was our back up to Furlong, and wouldn't have cost a penny.
In fairness he didn’t pull up any trees in League Two last season and Salford weren’t fussed about signing him permanently. SPL/League 2 would be a big step up to Champ football.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(01-20-2025, 10:32 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:28 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:20 PM)HLS Wrote: I'd sign him tbf. Think he's done alright but not as a replacement for Bartley. We'll need someone else when he moves on.
I've just watched a certain Ethan Ingram put in a very good display at right back for Dundee against Dundee Utd. There was our back up to Furlong, and wouldn't have cost a penny.
In fairness he didn’t pull up any trees in League Two last season and Salford weren’t fussed about signing him permanently. SPL/League 2 would be a big step up to Champ football.
I remember reading similar comments about Jack Fitzwater when he was at Livingston and he's now at Exeter (and not getting much game time). The reality with Scottish football is that outside of Celtic and Rangers, even the clubs in the SPL are probably at a similar level to League One/League Two sides at best. It's a huge jump from there to Championship football.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
01-20-2025, 11:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-20-2025, 11:04 PM by Peachy.)
(01-20-2025, 10:32 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:28 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:20 PM)HLS Wrote: I'd sign him tbf. Think he's done alright but not as a replacement for Bartley. We'll need someone else when he moves on.
I've just watched a certain Ethan Ingram put in a very good display at right back for Dundee against Dundee Utd. There was our back up to Furlong, and wouldn't have cost a penny.
In fairness he didn’t pull up any trees in League Two last season and Salford weren’t fussed about signing him permanently. SPL/League 2 would be a big step up to Champ football.
TBF Fellows didn't pull up any trees at Crawley in Div 2. He got minutes on and off but wasn't lauded by their management like Taylor at Cheltenham and Palmer at Plymouth who both won player of the season awards.
He came back, got a sniff in pre season, and took his chance and forced his way in but there were certainly no signs at Crawley of what was to come. He played a fair bit at RWB there IIRC.
I'm a big advocate for seeing a kid get a chance in league football. You never know until you put them in the situation. Lots flounder but some thrive on the step up. Nathan Ferguson was another. He never even had a loan before Slav threw him in after seeing him train in pre season.
That's why I'm really keen to see Whitwell get a chance. I think he could be a real player but we won't know until he gets the chance. I'd sooner he comes on for 15 than Swift or Wallace. We know what they can (or can't) do.
I think you'll see Mogga give a few a go before the season is out imo.
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
If we want to be challenging for promotion then Holgate is a liability.I didn’t see Wilder wanting to sign him after his loan there.He is like a walking yellow card because his positioning is so bad.Taylor at some time will get his chance and hopefully take it.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(01-20-2025, 11:03 PM)Peachy Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:32 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:28 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:20 PM)HLS Wrote: I'd sign him tbf. Think he's done alright but not as a replacement for Bartley. We'll need someone else when he moves on.
I've just watched a certain Ethan Ingram put in a very good display at right back for Dundee against Dundee Utd. There was our back up to Furlong, and wouldn't have cost a penny.
In fairness he didn’t pull up any trees in League Two last season and Salford weren’t fussed about signing him permanently. SPL/League 2 would be a big step up to Champ football.
TBF Fellows didn't pull up any trees at Crawley in Div 2. He got minutes on and off but wasn't lauded by their management like Taylor at Cheltenham and Palmer at Plymouth who both won player of the season awards.
He came back, got a sniff in pre season, and took his chance and forced his way in but there were certainly no signs at Crawley of what was to come. He played a fair bit at RWB there IIRC.
I'm a big advocate for seeing a kid get a chance in league football. You never know until you put them in the situation. Lots flounder but some thrive on the step up. Nathan Ferguson was another. He never even had a loan before Slav threw him in after seeing him train in pre season.
That's why I'm really keen to see Whitwell get a chance. I think he could be a real player but we won't know until he gets the chance. I'd sooner he comes on for 15 than Swift or Wallace. We know what they can (or can't) do.
I think you'll see Mogga give a few a go before the season is out imo.
Did Ingram not get injured at Salford? He scored a fine goal for them.
Fitzwater has ongoing illness problems which have held him back.
Agree with you on Whitwell, the other problem is that he is not likely to improve unless he plays
As for Holgate, he is on Premier League wages at Everton and has been for a few years. His wages would be high and he has little chance of re-sale value, so he is the sort of signing we would make!
Posts: 1,717
Threads: 212
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(01-21-2025, 12:59 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (01-20-2025, 11:03 PM)Peachy Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:32 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:28 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:20 PM)HLS Wrote: I'd sign him tbf. Think he's done alright but not as a replacement for Bartley. We'll need someone else when he moves on.
I've just watched a certain Ethan Ingram put in a very good display at right back for Dundee against Dundee Utd. There was our back up to Furlong, and wouldn't have cost a penny.
In fairness he didn’t pull up any trees in League Two last season and Salford weren’t fussed about signing him permanently. SPL/League 2 would be a big step up to Champ football.
TBF Fellows didn't pull up any trees at Crawley in Div 2. He got minutes on and off but wasn't lauded by their management like Taylor at Cheltenham and Palmer at Plymouth who both won player of the season awards.
He came back, got a sniff in pre season, and took his chance and forced his way in but there were certainly no signs at Crawley of what was to come. He played a fair bit at RWB there IIRC.
I'm a big advocate for seeing a kid get a chance in league football. You never know until you put them in the situation. Lots flounder but some thrive on the step up. Nathan Ferguson was another. He never even had a loan before Slav threw him in after seeing him train in pre season.
That's why I'm really keen to see Whitwell get a chance. I think he could be a real player but we won't know until he gets the chance. I'd sooner he comes on for 15 than Swift or Wallace. We know what they can (or can't) do.
I think you'll see Mogga give a few a go before the season is out imo.
Did Ingram not get injured at Salford? He scored a fine goal for them.
Fitzwater has ongoing illness problems which have held him back.
Agree with you on Whitwell, the other problem is that he is not likely to improve unless he plays
As for Holgate, he is on Premier League wages at Everton and has been for a few years. His wages would be high and he has little chance of re-sale value, so he is the sort of signing we would make! Not for me
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(01-20-2025, 11:03 PM)Peachy Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:32 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:28 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (01-20-2025, 10:20 PM)HLS Wrote: I'd sign him tbf. Think he's done alright but not as a replacement for Bartley. We'll need someone else when he moves on.
I've just watched a certain Ethan Ingram put in a very good display at right back for Dundee against Dundee Utd. There was our back up to Furlong, and wouldn't have cost a penny.
In fairness he didn’t pull up any trees in League Two last season and Salford weren’t fussed about signing him permanently. SPL/League 2 would be a big step up to Champ football.
TBF Fellows didn't pull up any trees at Crawley in Div 2. He got minutes on and off but wasn't lauded by their management like Taylor at Cheltenham and Palmer at Plymouth who both won player of the season awards.
He came back, got a sniff in pre season, and took his chance and forced his way in but there were certainly no signs at Crawley of what was to come. He played a fair bit at RWB there IIRC.
I'm a big advocate for seeing a kid get a chance in league football. You never know until you put them in the situation. Lots flounder but some thrive on the step up. Nathan Ferguson was another. He never even had a loan before Slav threw him in after seeing him train in pre season.
That's why I'm really keen to see Whitwell get a chance. I think he could be a real player but we won't know until he gets the chance. I'd sooner he comes on for 15 than Swift or Wallace. We know what they can (or can't) do.
I think you'll see Mogga give a few a go before the season is out imo.
Fair point on Fellows, and I agree we've been too complacent with our spending in recent years to the detriment of our kids' progress. When you can afford to bring in the likes of Holgate, any manager expecting immediate results will take that experience over taking a risk on a kid who has hardly pulled up any trees in League Two.
I think Swift still has a role to play between now and the end of the season, especially as I think Mogga will give him more freedom out of possession than CC did so I expect he'll get the nod over Whitwell and co. Wallace however shouldn't be on the bench any more, harsh but he just doesn't have it in the tank.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
01-21-2025, 10:49 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-21-2025, 10:51 AM by Josh1873.)
This 'give the kids a gew' narrative frustrates me a little.
Fellows and Palmer aren't first XI regulars now because they were given an opportunity due to a policy of bringing through youth players. They're in the team because they're the best options we have. They're there because they're good enough.
There's a reason that Clearly, for example, isn't in the squad regularly. Because he's not good enough.
It's all well and good towing the line of 'play more kids, Tom. They cor be any wuss'. Well, they can and unfortunately, in many cases, they are. It's not football manager! Ultimately those academy lads with the talent and quality will force their way into the team. Whether we have a policy of playing more youth players, or not.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(01-21-2025, 10:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: This 'give the kids a gew' narrative frustrates me a little.
Fellows and Palmer aren't first XI regulars now because they were given an opportunity due to a policy of bringing through youth players. They're in the team because they're the best options we have. They're there because they're good enough.
There's a reason that Clearly, for example, isn't in the squad regularly. Because he's not good enough.
It's all well and good towing the line of 'play more kids, Tom. They cor be any wuss'. Well, they can and unfortunately, in many cases, they are. It's not football manager! Ultimately those academy lads with the talent and quality will force their way into the team. Whether we have a policy of playing more youth players, or not.
The criticism is that a lot of the younger players we have released were good enough. We deemed Field, Azaz, TI and, Wilson to be not good enough and brought in players who were no better, older and with little resale value. Recent examples Button, Rogic, Kelly, M'Villa and probably Cole.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(01-21-2025, 11:28 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (01-21-2025, 10:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: This 'give the kids a gew' narrative frustrates me a little.
Fellows and Palmer aren't first XI regulars now because they were given an opportunity due to a policy of bringing through youth players. They're in the team because they're the best options we have. They're there because they're good enough.
There's a reason that Clearly, for example, isn't in the squad regularly. Because he's not good enough.
It's all well and good towing the line of 'play more kids, Tom. They cor be any wuss'. Well, they can and unfortunately, in many cases, they are. It's not football manager! Ultimately those academy lads with the talent and quality will force their way into the team. Whether we have a policy of playing more youth players, or not.
The criticism is that a lot of the younger players we have released were good enough. We deemed Field, Azaz, TI and, Wilson to be not good enough and brought in players who were no better, older and with little resale value. Recent examples Button, Rogic, Kelly, M'Villa and probably Cole.
Holgate ha splayed at a decent level. Leave him alone.
|