Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Signing Holgate would be a return to the flawed transfer policy that got us into this PSR mess.
He’s a serviceable emergency loan signing to add some nous and cover several positions but he’s already likely to be on big wages, doesn’t have the best injury record and he’s not going to get any better. He’d want a 3+ year deal and any player that came in on that type of contract would have to improve us, and he won’t.
Decent year’s loan to get us out of a mess, but nothing more, and I’m a fan of his. He showed under Ancelotti he’s a capable CB even at PL level but he’s not captured anything like that form for 3 years now and it’s too expensive of a risk that he will ever get close to it again.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
He gives us cover for Furlong at right back as well as at centre half. On the right wages I'd be happy with this. Ajayi will almost certainly be gone in the summer and it'll be interesting to see if Bartley plays enough before the end of the season to trigger an extension of his contract for a further year. I thought Holgate looked more reliable at right back in his first spell than he has being played in the centre this year. A bit like Ajayi he does have the occasional error in him but so do most defenders at this level including Heggem who appears to have a pass from any criticism at all.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
I don’t think Holgate is anywhere near as bad as some are making out. He’s a good squad addition and versatile enough for two positions.
Posts: 1,039
Threads: 48
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
I'd sign him tbf. Think he's done alright but not as a replacement for Bartley. We'll need someone else when he moves on.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
Don't think he's good enough certainly at CB, he's not hopeless but is very unreliable and often at fault in some way for a lot of the goals we concede. Possibly ok at full back but we need better if we're looking to progress.