Bournemouth game
I understand the frustration at limping out of cup competitions. Do we have a realistic chance of winning either of the cups? No, of course not. But that doesn't mean we should just play a half arsed XI and write it off. A good draw, luck and catching better teams on an off day, and you never know. The reluctance to 'give it a gew' in the cups does frustrate me, but I'm not going to criticise the club for it, as it's a stance the majority of teams in the top two tiers adopt. It's just how modern football is now. It's sad, but that's the reality, unfortunately.

With all that being said, I can't believe (well, I can, actually!) the absolute overreaction to losing to a team that are far better than us and a million miles ahead of us.

If we'd just lost to Woking at home, I'd understand. But perspective is needed. It's hardly disastrous. Disappointing, yes, but I'm not losing sleep over it.

We now concentrate on the league, where we're still in a very strong position. I just can't help but feel there's been far too much negativity about our on pitch results/performances this year, when there really isn't any need. We're at worse performing on par, at best over-achieving. That's not to say there hasn't been poor and disappointing performances/results along the way that have rightfully received criticism.

All things considered, from the need to cut the wages, PSR hanging over us, the bizarre run of draws we've been on, I think we're having a damn good season, and it's still all to play for. The way some folk have carried on you'd think we're all but guaranteed to be relegated to League 1.
Reply
(01-12-2025, 10:06 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I understand the frustration at limping out of cup competitions. Do we have a realistic chance of winning either of the cups? No, of course not. But that doesn't mean we should just play a half arsed XI and write it off. A good draw, luck and catching better teams on an off day, and you never know. The reluctance to 'give it a gew' in the cups does frustrate me, but I'm not going to criticise the club for it, as it's a stance the majority of teams in the top two tiers adopt. It's just how modern football is now. It's sad, but that's the reality, unfortunately.

With all that being said, I can't believe (well, I can, actually!) the absolute overreaction to losing to a team that are far better than us and a million miles ahead of us.

If we'd just lost to Woking at home, I'd understand. But perspective is needed. It's hardly disastrous. Disappointing, yes, but I'm not losing sleep over it.

We now concentrate on the league, where we're still in a very strong position. I just can't help but feel there's been far too much negativity about our on pitch results/performances this year, when there really isn't any need. We're at worse performing on par, at best over-achieving. That's not to say there hasn't been poor and disappointing performances/results along the way that have rightfully received criticism.

All things considered, from the need to cut the wages, PSR hanging over us, the bizarre run of draws we've been on, I think we're having a damn good season, and it's still all to play for. The way some folk have carried on you'd think we're all but guaranteed to be relegated to League 1.
Exactly? How many of those saying we should have done better actually put money on us getting a result there? I certainly wouldn't have risked anything. It was a result that teaches us exactly where we lie in the football pyramid. We never get thumped at our own level, in fact we are always the most likely to win and fans get expectations that are not real. We had a few players hopelessly out of their depth yesterday and it showed.
Reply
It's also the first time in ages we've had 5 put past us (can't remember the last time) and that always looks bad on paper, irrespective of the opposition.
Reply
If we’d put a full strength team out, with a new manager in situ and still got dicked due to collective errors and lack of organisation I’d be slightly more peeved and concerned.

7 changes and a team picked and trained all week by the loan manager and stat analyst has set the reality. That and you need the opposition to have a bad day and miss the chances that come along. They didn’t.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(01-12-2025, 10:45 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: If we’d put a full strength team out, with a new manager in situ and still got dicked due to collective errors and lack of organisation I’d be slightly more peeved and concerned.

7 changes and a team picked and trained all week by the loan manager and stat analyst has set the reality.  That and you need the opposition to have a bad day and miss the chances that come along.  They didn’t.

Correct. To have any chance you need the much stronger opposition to not turn up. If Brentford had applied themselves yesterday then they would have blown Plymouth away too, but they didn't. Bournemouth did, just like Leicester did in spanking QPR and Brighton did in smashing Norwich at home.
Reply
(01-12-2025, 09:25 AM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 09:20 AM)Huggybear Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 06:57 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Does the ‘magic of the FA cup’ refer to mushrooms or something? I honestly don’t know what people expected with no manager, no strikers, Grady and Racic in an XI playing away at a team that sit a point behind City and three behind Chelsea.

I do get the frustration at our repeated lacklustre approaches to cup tournaments each year. But yesterday was really never meant to be. We’ve bigger fish to fry this season and are a nobody’s side at the minute.

I’m not having any of that.We should be competitive and there is no excuse for a drubbing that we took.We know we are playing Bournemouth,so you set the team up accordingly and make it tough for them.Just a question but how did Plymouth get on today at Brentford?
     There have been many occasions where we have faced teams with better players but you set the team up to be organised and competitive.

Exactly I’m fed up with this i expected to lose crap
We were playing a Bournemouth side who were not at full strength
That performance was not acceptable.

Yes, sorry you’re right. I forget how brilliant we’ve been this year and how stable things are at the moment. We should absolutely be going to a top half Prem side in excellent form and beating them.
Reply
Was it Leeds (h) under Big Sam the last time we conceded 5 (five)?
Reply
(01-12-2025, 11:18 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 09:25 AM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 09:20 AM)Huggybear Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 06:57 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Does the ‘magic of the FA cup’ refer to mushrooms or something? I honestly don’t know what people expected with no manager, no strikers, Grady and Racic in an XI playing away at a team that sit a point behind City and three behind Chelsea.

I do get the frustration at our repeated lacklustre approaches to cup tournaments each year. But yesterday was really never meant to be. We’ve bigger fish to fry this season and are a nobody’s side at the minute.

I’m not having any of that.We should be competitive and there is no excuse for a drubbing that we took.We know we are playing Bournemouth,so you set the team up accordingly and make it tough for them.Just a question but how did Plymouth get on today at Brentford?
     There have been many occasions where we have faced teams with better players but you set the team up to be organised and competitive.

Exactly I’m fed up with this i expected to lose crap
We were playing a Bournemouth side who were not at full strength
That performance was not acceptable.

Yes, sorry you’re right. I forget how brilliant we’ve been this year and how stable things are at the moment. We should absolutely be going to a top half Prem side in excellent form and beating them.


If your happy sending a team for just a bit of a kick about
And not worry about the result or indeed the performance
Then we will have to just disagree.
Reply
I had a lousy buffering stream... but I saw a first half where we looked good and matched them.
Even in the second, it was more a question of quick breaks and quality finishing.
We have some good players. Shame some fans have to be negative.
We're perfectly capable of a top 6 finish.
Reply
(01-12-2025, 11:39 AM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 11:18 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 09:25 AM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 09:20 AM)Huggybear Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 06:57 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Does the ‘magic of the FA cup’ refer to mushrooms or something? I honestly don’t know what people expected with no manager, no strikers, Grady and Racic in an XI playing away at a team that sit a point behind City and three behind Chelsea.

I do get the frustration at our repeated lacklustre approaches to cup tournaments each year. But yesterday was really never meant to be. We’ve bigger fish to fry this season and are a nobody’s side at the minute.

I’m not having any of that.We should be competitive and there is no excuse for a drubbing that we took.We know we are playing Bournemouth,so you set the team up accordingly and make it tough for them.Just a question but how did Plymouth get on today at Brentford?
     There have been many occasions where we have faced teams with better players but you set the team up to be organised and competitive.

Exactly I’m fed up with this i expected to lose crap
We were playing a Bournemouth side who were not at full strength
That performance was not acceptable.

Yes, sorry you’re right. I forget how brilliant we’ve been this year and how stable things are at the moment. We should absolutely be going to a top half Prem side in excellent form and beating them.


If your happy sending a team for just a bit of a kick about
And not worry about the result or indeed the performance
Then we will have to just disagree.

I’m not happy at all about getting gubbed 5-1 by anyone. I also fully acknowledge that of all of the major trophies that can be won, a cup is far more easily attainable to a club like us than the EPL. There are of course many a season we haven’t taken either seriously enough (even Megson, who did little wrong, once said he couldn’t stand having to name a side for the first League Cup fixture of the season). 

I do see what you’re saying - games are there to be won and it is embarrassing turning up to have your tummy tickled (albeit by a second string probably worth more than our first). All I’m saying is that - of all the years to perhaps justify not taking it seriously - this one is probably up there, given the incomplete squad and lack of head coach. 

Beyond that, yeah we probably disagree. Really not worth getting upset about this year for me, given the situation we are in.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: