Positives
#11
Styles in my view being overrated, he’s done quite well but not sure why anyone singles him out after yesterday?

In my view too lightweight for a full back in the Championship. Decent on the ball, but that position needs much more than that. Furlong for instance has the attributes if a good full back at Championship level, I’m not sure Styles has
Reply
#12
(01-12-2025, 12:59 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: OK, this is a thread about positives. I've seen the spacegoating of Holgate, who was a little weak for Bournemouth's second goal. Did anyone else notice Furlong's (lack of) contribution to the first and fifth goals? Or is he immune from criticism when Holgate is there to take the blame? What about their third, when Grant got back quicker and further than any of our defenders except Styles? Did anything Diangana did from start to finish have any positive outcome? Are we so keen for Taylor to succeed that we can't mention his apparent over-confidence - or do we excuse that as nerves?

Positives for me today. We've seen that Diakite and Molumby are our best CM pairing, if we didn't know already. We've seen that Taylor isn't (yet) a big improvement on Bartley or Heggem. We've seen what Diangana and Wallace can offer - and it isn't much. We kept at it, the shape was good as was the workrate. Conceding 5 goals with a makeshift defence against a Prem side is ugly but not unexpected. Nothing we saw today was a cause for alarm - - - except - - - 

Josh Maja. "Rested" or held back to avoid him being Cup-tied? He was the missing link in our play today. Is he going to be the cash cow in this window? I hope not.
Great post
Reply
#13
(01-12-2025, 12:59 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: OK, this is a thread about positives. I've seen the spacegoating of Holgate, who was a little weak for Bournemouth's second goal. Did anyone else notice Furlong's (lack of) contribution to the first and fifth goals? Or is he immune from criticism when Holgate is there to take the blame? What about their third, when Grant got back quicker and further than any of our defenders except Styles? Did anything Diangana did from start to finish have any positive outcome? Are we so keen for Taylor to succeed that we can't mention his apparent over-confidence - or do we excuse that as nerves?

Positives for me today. We've seen that Diakite and Molumby are our best CM pairing, if we didn't know already. We've seen that Taylor isn't (yet) a big improvement on Bartley or Heggem. We've seen what Diangana and Wallace can offer - and it isn't much. We kept at it, the shape was good as was the workrate. Conceding 5 goals with a makeshift defence against a Prem side is ugly but not unexpected. Nothing we saw today was a cause for alarm - - - except - - - 

Josh Maja. "Rested" or held back to avoid him being Cup-tied? He was the missing link in our play today. Is he going to be the cash cow in this window? I hope not.

Good post. Hard to argue with any of that although the CM partnership IMO should be Molumby + AN Other depending on opponent as Mowatt offers more in an attacking sense than Diakite. Still it's good to have options.

I would be shocked if Maja was sold this window though.
Reply
#14
(01-12-2025, 01:11 AM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: Styles in my view being overrated, he’s done quite well but not sure why anyone singles him out after yesterday?

In my view too lightweight for a full back in the Championship. Decent on the ball, but that position needs much more than that. Furlong for instance has the attributes if a good full back at Championship level, I’m not sure Styles has

After yesterday's performance I too don't get the gushing over Styles performance.  He was weak defensively and so much came through that left side of our defence. Frabotta should have been give  the game yesterday with Styles ahead of him in midfield.  Styles is a decent player but is only a moderate full back. It might serve him in the championship but at the higher level he is way below par.
Reply
#15
Styles gets away with LB in the champ for sure and he definitely wouldnt in the prem. He has been an improvement on the last few seasons on Townsend though thats for sure
Reply
#16
Mowatt needs to start performing. Currently I would be starting Molumby & Diakite

I'm another who thinks the Styles love in is a bit OTT. Would Taylor look better next to a wise old head like Bartley & move Heggem back to left back.
.
Maja a major miss to how we play yesterday.
Reply
#17
Fair play on drawing some positives from what was the most insipid Albion display since the Bruce era.

We certainly have some players still capable of pushing for promotion in this blob of a league but the use of the loans and how the new gaffer performs will be critical. He needs to hit the ground running and we need to develop a much stronger mentality.
Reply
#18
Our fans were superb yesterday, never expected anything but a dicking and backed Bournemouth -2 goals. Good day out, they were very clinical on the break, we badly missed Moloumby and Diakite. Says a lot that Frabotta and Cole didn’t start and was slightly disappointed we didn’t play Whitwell. Team needs a freshen up and new manager looks well timed.
Reply
#19
Would say the only positive was the fans who travelled and never stopped singing.I thought for the first time we went completely away from how Corberan would set us up.
I don’t understand why we start a goalkeeper who as far as I know hasn’t had any game time ,he doesn’t play in the 23’s so all he literally does is training sessions.The poor lad looked so rusty it was untrue,he was certainly at fault for the first two goals along with others.
Reply
#20
Not a great deal of positives yesterday, in all fairness.

I disregard the result, because it doesn't really matter. A loss is a loss in the cup. But the non performance by so many players was a concern. The lack of shape and organisation was also a concern.

The only positives I can draw are Diakites performance when he came on and Fellows looked perfectly at home against Prem opposition.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: