Wheeling & Dealing
#21
(01-04-2025, 08:25 PM)Jacko Wrote: It's January, you have to make clubs pay a premium in this window or else it isnt worth doing.

Liverpool are quoting clubs £30 million for Ben Doak. There's your starting point for Tom Fellows. Then you negotiate down, rejecting anything under £20 million outright.

Maja, cannot be sold for less than £18 million. See Jack Clarke (winger not a striker).

Heggem you keep, we will not realise his true value in any sale after only 5 months of Championship football.

Palmer is the one we can probably 'afford' to lose given how good Griffiths is (not forgetting Wildsmith who was POTY among GKs in his division last season), but again, it's January,  so £10 million and we can start talking.

None of these players will devalue over the next 5 months, so they can still service PSR if we don't go up.

Re others. You do what you can to get Wallace and Swift off the books, nominal fees and in Wallace's case potentially supplementing his wages.

I'd still keep Diangana.

Agree, except for Maja who will be down to his final 12 months. 

Diangana is keep on the right terms - realise he divides opinion but he’s still one of the few players we have who can play in tight spaces and make things happen, even if he does it less frequently than we’d like. If it was a choice between keeping him, Swift and Wallace there’s no debate IMO.

(01-04-2025, 08:33 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 08:25 PM)Jacko Wrote: It's January, you have to make clubs pay a premium in this window or else it isnt worth doing.

Liverpool are quoting clubs £30 million for Ben Doak. There's your starting point for Tom Fellows. Then you negotiate down, rejecting anything under £20 million outright.

Maja, cannot be sold for less than £18 million. See Jack Clarke (winger not a striker).

Heggem you keep, we will not realise his true value in any sale after only 5 months of Championship football.

Palmer is the one we can probably 'afford' to lose given how good Griffiths is (not forgetting Wildsmith who was POTY among GKs in his division last season), but again, it's January,  so £10 million and we can start talking.

None of these players will devalue over the next 5 months, so they can still service PSR if we don't go up.

Re others. You do what you can to get Wallace and Swift off the books, nominal fees and in Wallace's case potentially supplementing his wages.

I'd still keep Diangana.

Sounds fair and pretty spot on. 

I do however think you have to earn the right to be as bombastic regarding prices. You need the reputation of a club that sells really good, well trained, improved prospects. 

It's a long term strategy in itself. If we flog Fellows for 20. The next fellows we can use his sale and hopeful, onwards performance as evidence of how we develop our young players.

Much like Brighton, Brentford and Crystal Palace.

For now we have a reputation of developing good 18 years olds. And holding onto ageing, declining players.

I think 18 is generous, we make very good 16year olds Big Grin
Reply
#22
People must be seeing a lot more in Heggem than I am. He's alright at this level but is still averaging one major dropped bollock a game. Not sure who's going to be paying multi-millions for that?
Reply
#23
Keep your best players or you circle around the plug hole. Then it all becomes pointless.
Reply
#24
Surprised no one has suggested we sell/release Bartley, who I’d much rather we let go of than Heggem - high wage earner, not particularly good (imo) and offers little threat at set pieces. If we aren’t going up this year as is probably likely, we need to be giving Taylor game time and using Holgate as backup.
Reply
#25
Cash in the entire squad and build the second tier now!!
Reply
#26
(01-04-2025, 11:25 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Keep your best players or you circle around the plug hole. Then it all becomes pointless.

I think this is where is all went wrong during the Brunt, Morrison, Saido, Odemwingie era. 

You have to be willing to sell.

"IMO of course..."
Reply
#27
There was a really good article about the way Brentford did things from a few seasons back. I think it was the seasons when they sold the likes of Andre Grey, Maupay, Scott Hogan and used it to sign the core of their promotion winning squad. It echoes a lot of the sensible points made in this thread.

I'd be really disappointed if Patel, Nestor and Pearce didn't have a view of the squad with a value for each player in mind. Second that value is met, offer is accepted irrespective of timing or who the bid comes in from. With the amount of data available to football clubs it shouldn't be difficult to have at least three replacements for each squad member should they be sold.

Lurker is right, get better at selling players and we become a more viable option for players to come in with a point to prove as the likes of Brentford, Brighton and to a lesser extent Bournemouth now are. It's criminal by the way that those are the clubs we're now aspiring to be like.
Reply
#28
(01-05-2025, 08:38 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 11:25 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Keep your best players or you circle around the plug hole. Then it all becomes pointless.

I think this is where is all went wrong during the Brunt, Morrison, Saido, Odemwingie era. 

You have to be willing to sell.


Agree Lurker.

Keeping your best players may seem to the fans the best option, but then they all age together, and there comes a point where they have no transfer value and have to be replaced with no available resource.

The January window is not a good market for buying clubs. There can be good deals, but if you are buying out of necessity rather than opportunity those deals are few and far between.

When it comes to selling players, you don't want to under value your players , but neither do you want to play hardball. That will only piss off the buying club and far more importantly the player. You gain a reputation for obstructing the progress of players, they won't sign contracts with you.
Reply
#29
The reason why we are reluctant to sell our better players is because our recruitment team are useless at finding quality replacements.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: