Swans match thread
(01-04-2025, 02:39 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:20 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Really poor subs and game management. Not had enough control over the game pretty much all match.

It had nothing to do with a lack of control or game management. it was one sloppy goal conceded. If this was CC in charge you would have just bemoaned our lack of clinical finishing which is the reason we didn’t win. 

Thank fug Williams isn’t our new manager (fingers crossed), they were awful, open, lightweight, tippy tappt football. They got out of jail at the end there was nothing to suggest he would have been a good choice.

I was saying all game we were lacking control, Dekka. Nowt to do with any pre conceived ideas. 

We had a 54% pass completion rate in the final third first half. 

Yes we had chances and we should have made more of it. But our chances were mostly on the back of our players having to make 50/60 yard runs because it was a frantic pass or break into space without us having any controlled possession to allow our players to get advanced of the ball.

We were constantly catching them on the break it wasn’t frantic it was incisive but individual players final touch, pass was poor and tbf so was the pitch. If we had done our usual and taken an eternity to break most of those chances would have been lost as the opposition filtered back into a defensive shape. 

I think you are equating possession with control.
Reply
(01-04-2025, 02:46 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:39 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm really not making Swift a space goat, he had little to do with the equaliser. But the sooner we can either move him on, or find a replacement in January, the better.

I just do not see what he brings. He's a luxury player that doesn't give you anything defensively or organisationally, but we don't even get any creativity from him as recompense.

I know there are Swift fans on here, and I'll probably kop stick as I always do when I'm critical of him, but I'm done with him.

Plays like he’s joined in a 5 a side game on a Monday night with a group of mates

Indeed. "Jed's legs have gone" Yes!! But I at least see intent and purpose about his work.
Reply
(01-04-2025, 02:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:39 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:20 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Really poor subs and game management. Not had enough control over the game pretty much all match.

It had nothing to do with a lack of control or game management. it was one sloppy goal conceded. If this was CC in charge you would have just bemoaned our lack of clinical finishing which is the reason we didn’t win. 

Thank fug Williams isn’t our new manager (fingers crossed), they were awful, open, lightweight, tippy tappt football. They got out of jail at the end there was nothing to suggest he would have been a good choice.

I was saying all game we were lacking control, Dekka. Nowt to do with any pre conceived ideas. 

We had a 54% pass completion rate in the final third first half. 

Yes we had chances and we should have made more of it. But our chances were mostly on the back of our players having to make 50/60 yard runs because it was a frantic pass or break into space without us having any controlled possession to allow our players to get advanced of the ball.

We were constantly catching them on the break it wasn’t frantic it was incisive but individual players final touch, pass was poor and tbf so was the pitch. If we had done our usual and taken an eternity to break most of those chances would have been lost as the opposition filtered back into a defensive shape. 

I think you are equating possession with control.

I agree we looked far more threat today than in a lot of games I've seen, some great interplay between Grant, the wide players and especially Maja.
Reply
(01-04-2025, 02:39 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm really not making Swift a space goat, he had little to do with the equaliser. But the sooner we can either move him on, or find a replacement in January, the better.

I just do not see what he brings. He's a luxury player that doesn't give you anything defensively or organisationally, but we don't even get any creativity from him as recompense.

I know there are Swift fans on here, and I'll probably kop stick as I always do when I'm critical of him, but I'm done with him.
Swift is never a player to bring on when you're trying to hold onto a lead, especially out wide, never won a 50/50 in his life. Not the reason we drew today but part of the reason why we got pinned back near the end.
Reply
We had enough chances to win 2 games today ,thought our transition was good but hampered by the pitch .The chances we had we not exactly open goals ,but probably the final ball or a bit move movement would have been better .Overall another decent away performance but should have beaten a poor Swansea side .A free hit next week but after that 2 winnable homes to come and a new manager should give everyone a boost .
Reply
(01-04-2025, 02:51 PM)Jacko Wrote: Irrespective of the subs, these players retreat on a lead late in games. Nothing to do with instructions. Then they wither. This was Oxford away all over again.

Bartley coming on cold with ten minutes left and pulling up would have been worse than the late equaliser.

I think this is harsh. 

Firstly, we were 0-1 away from home. I think it's perfectly reasonable to go more defensive. That isn't the issue. Secondly, we were an attacking threat and created chances right up until the last couple of minutes of stoppage time. 

As a game plan and performance today, I saw absolutely nothing wrong or to be critical about. It was simply down to sloppy defending and individual errors in not stopping the cross, failing to get to the second ball, stop the second cross, and then failing to deal with a simple header. 

Talk of tactics, and to an extent, subs, are irrelevant. Although, I do agree the subs were not needed, but I don't think you can necessarily point to the changes and say 'thats why we didn't win'.
Reply
(01-04-2025, 02:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:39 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:30 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:20 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Really poor subs and game management. Not had enough control over the game pretty much all match.

It had nothing to do with a lack of control or game management. it was one sloppy goal conceded. If this was CC in charge you would have just bemoaned our lack of clinical finishing which is the reason we didn’t win. 

Thank fug Williams isn’t our new manager (fingers crossed), they were awful, open, lightweight, tippy tappt football. They got out of jail at the end there was nothing to suggest he would have been a good choice.

I was saying all game we were lacking control, Dekka. Nowt to do with any pre conceived ideas. 

We had a 54% pass completion rate in the final third first half. 

Yes we had chances and we should have made more of it. But our chances were mostly on the back of our players having to make 50/60 yard runs because it was a frantic pass or break into space without us having any controlled possession to allow our players to get advanced of the ball.

We were constantly catching them on the break it wasn’t frantic it was incisive but individual players final touch, pass was poor and tbf so was the pitch. If we had done our usual and taken an eternity to break most of those chances would have been lost as the opposition filtered back into a defensive shape. 

I think you are equating possession with control.

Not at all... I never have cared about possession. 

We just disagree about the deliberateness of our pkay I guess. You see it as incisive, I see it as frantic. That's okay. I feel many of our openings came from them being so open that our frantic passes came off. I don't believe we played well and opened them up. Bar the goal. 

We often lacked players in and around the box as we broke without good quality possession so our players had to be very accurate to pick out a player with a final pass. Or the chance came after the ball was carried 40/50/60yards like Molumby and Wallace's. 

If you think we played well though, I am glad, that's what opinions are all about
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(01-04-2025, 02:46 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 02:39 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm really not making Swift a space goat, he had little to do with the equaliser. But the sooner we can either move him on, or find a replacement in January, the better.

I just do not see what he brings. He's a luxury player that doesn't give you anything defensively or organisationally, but we don't even get any creativity from him as recompense.

I know there are Swift fans on here, and I'll probably kop stick as I always do when I'm critical of him, but I'm done with him.

Plays like he’s joined in a 5 a side game on a Monday night with a group of mates

At least twice he had a potential 50-50 on the halfway line and just didn’t bother, backed off towards goal and let them have the ball. Clearly thinks that’s not his job, should never, ever come on when we are 1 goal up.
Reply
Four games post-Carlos, not a single clean sheet. Worried.
Reply
(01-04-2025, 03:01 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Four games post-Carlos, not a single clean sheet. Worried.

Only conceded more than 1 once though. So nothing to worry about really. 

Apart from today we've shown good tactical awareness and defensive structure to be fair. Today was just a poor performance both on and off the pitch.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: