Diakite Watch
#41
It’s almost like a 45min cameo isn’t best to judge a new player, and fans should have cut him some slack after Sheff wed

Sometimes players coming to a new country, a new club, a different ethos, tactics etc need a few months to settle in
Reply
#42
(01-01-2025, 08:42 PM)Sliced Wrote: So you're not allowed to comment on a players performance until they've played a certain amount of minutes? Why not just let people have opinions on what they are seeing with their eyes.

I don't see any problem saying "X looks out of his depth" when a player looks out of his depth and then being wrong about it. Of course he might still come good, and frequently the opposite happens too.

I remember saying on Grant's debut "finally looks like we've got a proper quality forward" when it turned out Grant was way out of his depth at Prem level, there's no difference.

Is this how things are in your world? Your son takes his first wobbly ride on a bike and you say "Fucking hell mate, you're shite aren't you?" New starters at work get to be heckled by you as they find their way around the place? "This twat didn't even know where the toilets were on his first day!"

Just a question - what's wrong with holding back on your opinions until you've had enough time to form them properly?
Reply
#43
(01-02-2025, 10:05 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-01-2025, 08:42 PM)Sliced Wrote: So you're not allowed to comment on a players performance until they've played a certain amount of minutes? Why not just let people have opinions on what they are seeing with their eyes.

I don't see any problem saying "X looks out of his depth" when a player looks out of his depth and then being wrong about it. Of course he might still come good, and frequently the opposite happens too.

I remember saying on Grant's debut "finally looks like we've got a proper quality forward" when it turned out Grant was way out of his depth at Prem level, there's no difference.

Is this how things are in your world? Your son takes his first wobbly ride on a bike and you say "Fucking hell mate, you're shite aren't you?" New starters at work get to be heckled by you as they find their way around the place? "This twat didn't even know where the toilets were on his first day!"

Just a question - what's wrong with holding back on your opinions until you've had enough time to form them properly?
This is all getting a bit silly now. The kid analogy would apply to a kid kicking a ball for the first time, not a qualified professional, and the new starter might not know where the toilets are, but they would be expected to back up the basics of the claims on their CV, especially after being with the "company" for a few months.

This is a forum, predominantly for observations and opinions on WBA FC and everything that goes with it, and that is all that has happened. People have observed his performance and commented accordingly, in real time. Pretty much everyone who criticised him has admired his resilience and improvement, so I'm not sure why it's still being used as a stick to beat fans with just because they stated something that was true at the time.

The opinion of him is pretty much unanimously positive at the moment, can't we just enjoy that.  Big Grin
Reply
#44
(01-02-2025, 10:18 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:05 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-01-2025, 08:42 PM)Sliced Wrote: So you're not allowed to comment on a players performance until they've played a certain amount of minutes? Why not just let people have opinions on what they are seeing with their eyes.

I don't see any problem saying "X looks out of his depth" when a player looks out of his depth and then being wrong about it. Of course he might still come good, and frequently the opposite happens too.

I remember saying on Grant's debut "finally looks like we've got a proper quality forward" when it turned out Grant was way out of his depth at Prem level, there's no difference.

Is this how things are in your world? Your son takes his first wobbly ride on a bike and you say "Fucking hell mate, you're shite aren't you?" New starters at work get to be heckled by you as they find their way around the place? "This twat didn't even know where the toilets were on his first day!"

Just a question - what's wrong with holding back on your opinions until you've had enough time to form them properly?
This is all getting a bit silly now. The kid analogy would apply to a kid kicking a ball for the first time, not a qualified professional, and the new starter might not know where the toilets are, but they would be expected to back up the basics of the claims on their CV, especially after being with the "company" for a few months.

This is a forum, predominantly for observations and opinions on WBA FC and everything that goes with it, and that is all that has happened. People have observed his performance and commented accordingly, in real time. Pretty much everyone who criticised him has admired his resilience and improvement, so I'm not sure why it's still being used as a stick to beat fans with just because they stated something that was true at the time.

The opinion of him is pretty much unanimously positive at the moment, can't we just enjoy that.  Big Grin

Amen, brother Fossil.
Reply
#45
So the conclusion to the Diakite thread is that Grant was shit, but isn't any more   Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#46
Great post BF.

I have Diakite some stick for his Sheff performance but glad to see he may be a very decent player with my own eyes yesterday. Be a real boost if we have a genuine decent third option in that role and looks like we may well have
Reply
#47
(01-01-2025, 08:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-01-2025, 05:55 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: I hope those that castigated mercilessly were there to see him play today.
Some of the comments were beyond belief. Hang your heads in shame.
If he's good enough time will tell. He certainly looks to possess enough to be a success.

Agreed it was way OTT.

Do you?

(09-28-2024, 12:35 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 12:32 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-28-2024, 12:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: If I hear anyone even suggest replacing either Mowatt or Molumby with either of these two again I'll be amazed.

Genuinely up there as one of the worst performances by a midfield pairing I've ever seen.

They both definitely need some time to adapt to this league. I thought Racic looked good against Plymouth but he’s been very poor today. Diakite showing just how immature he is. Positioning is poor, not getting his head up to look before passing, lots of work needed with him, but has raw attributes.

We’ve also been unlucky that Weds have had a huge slice for fortune early on. On another day we go in at HT at 0-0

They have been bloody awful… if you’re a central midfielder you don’t need to know the league to show for the ball.


That was from 09-28-2024.

Actually a few on here shitting on Diakite and Racic in this thread 45 minutes after their first start in the league. Seems a bit hypocritical and premature.

https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/showthread....#pid712998
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: