Ram us in the Pink Match Thread
We have not won at Pride Park since Rob Hulse was playing for us. Now after one game that we narrowly lost… we start the ‘it’s a midtable squad’, ‘we would have got something if CC was in charge’ ‘papering over the cracks’ the first point and last point are subjective and as yet unproven the second point is impossible to prove.

Let’s see who and where we are at the end of the season before we do the Mystic Meg stuff.

Last point any club who loses its management team whilst doing ‘ok’ is going to find itself in a state of flux waiting for the new manager to give them some direction and certainty all be it for what 18mths on average. This results at this time proves absolutely fug all about the squad. It just proves we have been left in the lurch by CC and looking for a new manager.
Reply
(12-26-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We have not won at Pride Park since Rob Hulse was playing for us. Now after one game that we narrowly lost… we start the ‘it’s a midtable squad’, ‘we would have got something if CC was in charge’ ‘papering over the cracks’ the first point and last point are subjective and as yet unproven the second point is impossible to prove.

Let’s see who and where we are at the end of the season before we do the Mystic Meg stuff.

Last point any club who loses its management team whilst doing ‘ok’ is going to find itself in a state of flux waiting for the new manager to give them some direction and certainty all be it for what 18mths on average. This results at this time proves absolutely fug all about the squad. It just proves we have been left in the lurch and looking for a new manager.

Spot on
Reply
I wouldn’t mind the result if it had been Sheffield Utd. They’re flying high but why did our first game without CC gave to be away against these bastards?! I hate Derby and the entire slum that is that shitty town. And yes I do know the Blades’ result.
Reply
(12-26-2024, 07:30 PM)aj21 Wrote: Tell you what will happen - we will employ a manager and this squad will be fine. It’s not great but they are an honest enough bunch and the new manager might take the shackles off a bit and we might win some games

This. 

It could be argued that he created as many chasms as he papered over. We still lack a second striker. We signed one absolutely no better than the one we let go and never play him. We signed a useless winger from Villa. We signed a blonde Volvo 340 to replace Yok. We made substitutions and unnecessary team selections that cost us points. 

Yes - he’s a likeable hardworking man. I’m sad to see him go. But some of our lot are heaping praise on a man who simply didn’t finish the job and has wanted out since summer. I really want us to get the next appointment right moreso than ever now, just so that people realise that we haven’t just lost a superhero - just a man who wanted to manage another club more than this one.

3 wins in 16. It wasn’t the stuff of fairytales. Get a fucking grip and remember that we’re West Bromwich Albion FC, not Corberan Manlove FC.
Reply
Managers come and go and the important thing is to have a structure where they can’t derail the club too much.
It seems that we knew CC would be going and I think we’ve been sounding folks out for a while.
I hope it’s a speedy appointment.
Reply
(12-26-2024, 07:34 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We have not won at Pride Park since Rob Hulse was playing for us. Now after one game that we narrowly lost… we start the ‘it’s a midtable squad’, ‘we would have got something if CC was in charge’ ‘papering over the cracks’ the first point and last point are subjective and as yet unproven the second point is impossible to prove.

Let’s see who and where we are at the end of the season before we do the Mystic Meg stuff.

Last point any club who loses its management team whilst doing ‘ok’ is going to find itself in a state of flux waiting for the new manager to give them some direction and certainty all be it for what 18mths on average. This results at this time proves absolutely fug all about the squad. It just proves we have been left in the lurch and looking for a new manager.

It's not today's result that forms my opinion, I expected to lose today even with CC, it's boxing day, away to Derby.
Reply
(12-26-2024, 07:33 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:26 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:20 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:15 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:11 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: This...

The problem is CC was papering over the chasms we had within the squad after a suicidal 5-6 years. 

We now need to understand we are unlikely to have that coaching advantage and our lot will need to suck their gob stoppers and wait for the rebuild.

Is correct, we have a mid table squad which was well coached and managed by the best in the league. Now we have that squad without a manager.

Our squad is unbalanced and in trouble if Maja gets injured but our first team is easily top 8

Holgate, Ajayi, this Swift, we have no left back that's really even top half natural in the position, Molumby is a work horse, no real technique. It's certainly high mid table, but I don't see it as a playoff squad at all, as we found last season when we got there.

We're not playing in the Prem. Holgate walks into most championship teams, Swift has one of the best Assist and goal scoring records of a midfielder in the champ in the past few years, we have Furlong who was touted (IMO erroneously) as the best lb in the league a couple of months ago and our wide options stand up to pretty much every other team in the league.

And the notion that Molumby is just a work horse is a trope from about 3 years ago. He also gets into the vast majority of Champ teams easily.

There's 3 teams that have stronger squads than the rest of the league, but you're on another planet if you think the likes of Swansea, Sheffield Wednesday, Bristol City and Milwall (the teams sitting in mid to upper mid table at the moment) have better squads than we do.

Our squad is competent and decent. 

We lack real match winners and unpredictability. Which was what was the target to change in the summer with Diakite, MJ etc. players in areas of the pitch we are desperately lacking. MJ is showing signs but that's been off set by Jed, Grady and Swifty losing their legs and contributions and us not having a decent second CF again. 

We are a good hard working team, but we need to change the dynamics of it and if will take a couple of windows more, with it without CC. But we need to accept we won't have that continuity and solidity potentially. Of course we may get somebody akin to him and all will be okay but it's much more concerning than it is exciting to say the least.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
Them spawny cunts should be wearing claret & blue.

Trust the Brom to ruin xmas.

Wink
Reply
(12-26-2024, 07:37 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:33 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:26 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:20 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:15 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Is correct, we have a mid table squad which was well coached and managed by the best in the league. Now we have that squad without a manager.

Our squad is unbalanced and in trouble if Maja gets injured but our first team is easily top 8

Holgate, Ajayi, this Swift, we have no left back that's really even top half natural in the position, Molumby is a work horse, no real technique. It's certainly high mid table, but I don't see it as a playoff squad at all, as we found last season when we got there.

We're not playing in the Prem. Holgate walks into most championship teams, Swift has one of the best Assist and goal scoring records of a midfielder in the champ in the past few years, we have Furlong who was touted (IMO erroneously) as the best lb in the league a couple of months ago and our wide options stand up to pretty much every other team in the league.

And the notion that Molumby is just a work horse is a trope from about 3 years ago. He also gets into the vast majority of Champ teams easily.

There's 3 teams that have stronger squads than the rest of the league, but you're on another planet if you think the likes of Swansea, Sheffield Wednesday, Bristol City and Milwall (the teams sitting in mid to upper mid table at the moment) have better squads than we do.

Our squad is competent and decent. 

We lack real match winners and unpredictability. Which was what was the target to change in the summer with Diakite, MJ etc. players in areas of the pitch we are desperately lacking. MJ is showing signs but that's been off set by Jed, Grady and Swifty losing their legs and contributions and us not having a decent second CF again. 

We are a good hard working team, but we need to change the dynamics of it and if will take a couple of windows more, with it without CC. But we need to accept we won't have that continuity and solidity potentially. Of course we may get somebody akin to him and all will be okay but it's much more concerning than it is exciting to say the least.

I think CC is great, but I honestly think this is partially down to him. We've got some of the most creative wingers in the league and I don't agree that Grady has lost his legs, he's lost his confidence.
Reply
(12-26-2024, 07:37 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:33 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:26 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:20 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-26-2024, 07:15 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Is correct, we have a mid table squad which was well coached and managed by the best in the league. Now we have that squad without a manager.

Our squad is unbalanced and in trouble if Maja gets injured but our first team is easily top 8

Holgate, Ajayi, this Swift, we have no left back that's really even top half natural in the position, Molumby is a work horse, no real technique. It's certainly high mid table, but I don't see it as a playoff squad at all, as we found last season when we got there.

We're not playing in the Prem. Holgate walks into most championship teams, Swift has one of the best Assist and goal scoring records of a midfielder in the champ in the past few years, we have Furlong who was touted (IMO erroneously) as the best lb in the league a couple of months ago and our wide options stand up to pretty much every other team in the league.

And the notion that Molumby is just a work horse is a trope from about 3 years ago. He also gets into the vast majority of Champ teams easily.

There's 3 teams that have stronger squads than the rest of the league, but you're on another planet if you think the likes of Swansea, Sheffield Wednesday, Bristol City and Milwall (the teams sitting in mid to upper mid table at the moment) have better squads than we do.

Our squad is competent and decent. 

We lack real match winners and unpredictability. Which was what was the target to change in the summer with Diakite, MJ etc. players in areas of the pitch we are desperately lacking. MJ is showing signs but that's been off set by Jed, Grady and Swifty losing their legs and contributions and us not having a decent second CF again. 

We are a good hard working team, but we need to change the dynamics of it and if will take a couple of windows more, with it without CC. But we need to accept we won't have that continuity and solidity potentially. Of course we may get somebody akin to him and all will be okay but it's much more concerning than it is exciting to say the least.

Exactly.

We're very workhorse like, even the other teams mentioned have players that are inventive and create play. We just don't.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: