Carlos to Valencia
(12-24-2024, 09:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Let’s see, this reaction to a manager leaving is way ott. We have a good squad who can easily get into the play-offs. It’s hardly the doomsday  scenario some are describing.

Totally disagree. The measure of a manager for me;
Can he arrest a slide? Tick, we were rock bottom after Carlos 1st 90 minutes.
Does he improve individuals as players? Tick, numerous example but Bartley, Furlong and (formerly) Matt Phillips are the best examples.
Can he work under financial pressure? Tick.
Do all players give the full 100% effort? Tick
Is there a definite identity/plan? Tick. Despite injuries and suspensions e.g.a totally different back 4 away at top of the league)we got  a result.
Is there ongoing improvement at the club. Tick, the aforementioned 30% cut in wages and the loss of 2 key players and a total overhaul yet we have the same points as last season.
Carlos leaving  might not make the doomsday scenario you mention but we've all been around long enough to see it can. All too easily.
Reply
(12-24-2024, 09:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 08:53 AM)Pontificator Wrote: There is absolutely no doubt that the players have bought into CC's dedication, knowledge and preperation. Its apparent in the way they play and the way they all take responsibilty for the work they do. I would point to the improvement in Kyle Bartley who was supberb on Sunday. From a player who I thought should have been sacked after that Blues game and a player who simply could not do what he does now under big Dave, he is our VVD. I am bereft that CC is on his way. I doubt he can be replaced in the mind of many of our players

Agree, the more I think about it the worse it gets.  We either get someone in who will start from scratch with a new style, very disruptive, or someone who tries to have the team play like CC but can’t do it as well.  V depressing prospects IMO.

Or we could appoint someone with similar principles and style, but does it better. 

I don't think we'll appoint someone that wants to play a completely different style, that would be absolute madness. But if we did, this group of players are capable of playing more attacking. 

I'm a massive CC fan, I don't want him to move on, I believe he's the best fit for us right now, but I'm also not going to worry myself too much about his departure. I'm sure Shilen will get this appointment right, and who knows, it could work out for the best. 

CC isn't a Messiah, he's far from perfect. I'm not as concerned as some people seem to be!
Reply
(12-24-2024, 10:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Let’s see, this reaction to a manager leaving is way ott. We have a good squad who can easily get into the play-offs. It’s hardly the doomsday  scenario some are describing.

Totally disagree. The measure of a manager for me;
Can he arrest a slide? Tick, we were rock bottom after Carlos 1st 90 minutes.
Does he improve individuals as players? Tick, numerous example but Bartley, Furlong and (formerly) Matt Phillips are the best examples.
Can he work under financial pressure? Tick.
Do all players give the full 100% effort? Tick
Is there a definite identity/plan? Tick. Despite injuries and suspensions e.g.a totally different back 4 away at top of the league)we got  a result.
Is there ongoing improvement at the club. Tick, the aforementioned 30% cut in wages and the loss of 2 key players and a total overhaul yet we have the same points as last season.
Carlos leaving  might not make the doomsday scenario you mention but we've all been around long enough to see it can. All too easily.

Agreed he’s done a good job in difficult circumstances but I’m far too old to care one way or the other. He will get well paid, we will move on and he will no doubt get a cap and a clap in ten years or so time.
Reply
(12-24-2024, 11:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 10:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Let’s see, this reaction to a manager leaving is way ott. We have a good squad who can easily get into the play-offs. It’s hardly the doomsday  scenario some are describing.

Totally disagree. The measure of a manager for me;
Can he arrest a slide? Tick, we were rock bottom after Carlos 1st 90 minutes.
Does he improve individuals as players? Tick, numerous example but Bartley, Furlong and (formerly) Matt Phillips are the best examples.
Can he work under financial pressure? Tick.
Do all players give the full 100% effort? Tick
Is there a definite identity/plan? Tick. Despite injuries and suspensions e.g.a totally different back 4 away at top of the league)we got  a result.
Is there ongoing improvement at the club. Tick, the aforementioned 30% cut in wages and the loss of 2 key players and a total overhaul yet we have the same points as last season.
Carlos leaving  might not make the doomsday scenario you mention but we've all been around long enough to see it can. All too easily.

Agreed he’s done a good job in difficult circumstances but I’m far too old to care one way or the other. He will get well paid, we will move on and he will no doubt get a cap and a clap in ten years or so time.
I won't sleep until Steve Bruce rules himself out....
Reply
(12-24-2024, 11:12 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 11:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 10:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Let’s see, this reaction to a manager leaving is way ott. We have a good squad who can easily get into the play-offs. It’s hardly the doomsday  scenario some are describing.

Totally disagree. The measure of a manager for me;
Can he arrest a slide? Tick, we were rock bottom after Carlos 1st 90 minutes.
Does he improve individuals as players? Tick, numerous example but Bartley, Furlong and (formerly) Matt Phillips are the best examples.
Can he work under financial pressure? Tick.
Do all players give the full 100% effort? Tick
Is there a definite identity/plan? Tick. Despite injuries and suspensions e.g.a totally different back 4 away at top of the league)we got  a result.
Is there ongoing improvement at the club. Tick, the aforementioned 30% cut in wages and the loss of 2 key players and a total overhaul yet we have the same points as last season.
Carlos leaving  might not make the doomsday scenario you mention but we've all been around long enough to see it can. All too easily.

Agreed he’s done a good job in difficult circumstances but I’m far too old to care one way or the other. He will get well paid, we will move on and he will no doubt get a cap and a clap in ten years or so time.
I won't sleep until Steve Bruce rules himself out....
A relative was a manager at Greggs by The Hawthorns.She is leaving at New Year, think Bruce will need assurances about her replacement before coming back.
Reply
(12-24-2024, 11:02 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 08:53 AM)Pontificator Wrote: There is absolutely no doubt that the players have bought into CC's dedication, knowledge and preperation. Its apparent in the way they play and the way they all take responsibilty for the work they do. I would point to the improvement in Kyle Bartley who was supberb on Sunday. From a player who I thought should have been sacked after that Blues game and a player who simply could not do what he does now under big Dave, he is our VVD. I am bereft that CC is on his way. I doubt he can be replaced in the mind of many of our players

Agree, the more I think about it the worse it gets.  We either get someone in who will start from scratch with a new style, very disruptive, or someone who tries to have the team play like CC but can’t do it as well.  V depressing prospects IMO.

Or we could appoint someone with similar principles and style, but does it better. 

I don't think we'll appoint someone that wants to play a completely different style, that would be absolute madness. But if we did, this group of players are capable of playing more attacking. 

I'm a massive CC fan, I don't want him to move on, I believe he's the best fit for us right now, but I'm also not going to worry myself too much about his departure. I'm sure Shilen will get this appointment right, and who knows, it could work out for the best. 

CC isn't a Messiah, he's far from perfect. I'm not as concerned as some people seem to be!

Completely agree. Some of these views seem to think that there is no other coach in the world who could do what Carlos is doing at the club. It really is the epitome of pant wetting. He's a good coach and done an excellent job. There are also plenty of other people out there capable of doing the same or better. I just really can't be bothered these days to get so upset about something that ultimately is hardly the biggest crisis in life.
Reply
(12-24-2024, 11:29 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 11:02 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:35 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 08:53 AM)Pontificator Wrote: There is absolutely no doubt that the players have bought into CC's dedication, knowledge and preperation. Its apparent in the way they play and the way they all take responsibilty for the work they do. I would point to the improvement in Kyle Bartley who was supberb on Sunday. From a player who I thought should have been sacked after that Blues game and a player who simply could not do what he does now under big Dave, he is our VVD. I am bereft that CC is on his way. I doubt he can be replaced in the mind of many of our players

Agree, the more I think about it the worse it gets.  We either get someone in who will start from scratch with a new style, very disruptive, or someone who tries to have the team play like CC but can’t do it as well.  V depressing prospects IMO.

Or we could appoint someone with similar principles and style, but does it better. 

I don't think we'll appoint someone that wants to play a completely different style, that would be absolute madness. But if we did, this group of players are capable of playing more attacking. 

I'm a massive CC fan, I don't want him to move on, I believe he's the best fit for us right now, but I'm also not going to worry myself too much about his departure. I'm sure Shilen will get this appointment right, and who knows, it could work out for the best. 

CC isn't a Messiah, he's far from perfect. I'm not as concerned as some people seem to be!

Completely agree. Some of these views seem to think that there is no other coach in the world who could do what Carlos is doing at the club. It really is the epitome of pant wetting. He's a good coach and done an excellent job. There are also plenty of other people out there capable of doing the same or better. I just really can't be bothered these days to get so upset about something that ultimately is hardly the biggest crisis in life.

Completely agree. I just want to reiterate, in case any of the pant wetters jump on me, I absolutely love CC, and really don't want to lose him. But if/when he goes, I just won't worry about it whatsoever.
Reply
(12-24-2024, 10:12 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 10:03 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Let’s see, this reaction to a manager leaving is way ott. We have a good squad who can easily get into the play-offs. It’s hardly the doomsday  scenario some are describing.

Easily is an absolute stretch. You sound like the idiots who sit behind me expecting us to smash teams every week. 

It's not doomsday, a new manager has got some good tools. But he's also a couple of injuries away from real problems in key areas. I expect other rivals will strengthen better than us in January.

When did I have a pop at you? You just have a different opinion on the strength of squad we have. When have I on here ever said we should be ‘smashing teams’? You don’t have to smash teams in this mediocre/flat in terms of quality league to be in a position to make the play-offs, you can lose or draw several games and still be in with a chance. 

Every club outside perhaps the top three are one or two key players away from struggling to maintain the same standard that are when they are in the team. I’ve seen most of the Championship now and I’ve not seen a team that is outstanding let alone six better than us. 

I’m not going to get up or down about a manager leaving it happens, we move on and CC isn’t irreplaceable. Some think we are punching above our weight with CC I think we are around where we would be given the squad with a number of managers capable of achieving similar results.
 
I disagree that getting to play offs is easy. It really isn't. That's what I disagreed with.

I'm pretty relaxed about him going. I don't get attached to players or managers these days.
Reply
(12-24-2024, 11:22 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 11:12 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 11:10 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 10:56 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Let’s see, this reaction to a manager leaving is way ott. We have a good squad who can easily get into the play-offs. It’s hardly the doomsday  scenario some are describing.

Totally disagree. The measure of a manager for me;
Can he arrest a slide? Tick, we were rock bottom after Carlos 1st 90 minutes.
Does he improve individuals as players? Tick, numerous example but Bartley, Furlong and (formerly) Matt Phillips are the best examples.
Can he work under financial pressure? Tick.
Do all players give the full 100% effort? Tick
Is there a definite identity/plan? Tick. Despite injuries and suspensions e.g.a totally different back 4 away at top of the league)we got  a result.
Is there ongoing improvement at the club. Tick, the aforementioned 30% cut in wages and the loss of 2 key players and a total overhaul yet we have the same points as last season.
Carlos leaving  might not make the doomsday scenario you mention but we've all been around long enough to see it can. All too easily.

Agreed he’s done a good job in difficult circumstances but I’m far too old to care one way or the other. He will get well paid, we will move on and he will no doubt get a cap and a clap in ten years or so time.
I won't sleep until Steve Bruce rules himself out....
A relative was a manager at Greggs by The Hawthorns.She is leaving at New Year, think Bruce will need assurances about her replacement before coming back.

I’m surprised her role wasn’t made resistant the day Ron left the club.
Reply
https://youtube.com/shorts/ldwOZCfgNa0?s...XLKKzHXf3B

Too soon?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)