The News Years Behind WBAUnofficial
#11
It’s almost as if it’s a complex problem of which that may be some - but not all - of the solution. And that not sorting it out in itself would be less helpful than doing so.
Reply
#12
(12-16-2024, 12:12 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(12-16-2024, 11:57 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-16-2024, 08:30 AM)Pontificator Wrote: Osborne had a clear plan to return the economy to a surplus, largely abandoned before and after the catastophe of Brexit. The damage to services by his failed policy was pretty much done and the decline of UK accelerated after 2016. Tory ideology has done for us.The complexities of the housing market are there to behold. Thatcher began the shit show and the Torys in power for three quarters of the last 45 years have meddled with it continually. To argue that that Darren Jones and Rachel Reeves are students and don't understand business is stupid. We've seen the real world and we are where we are because of fuckwits. Fuck the Tories and fuck Brexit

Well, what kind of idiot thinks that by pushing for more planning permission that more houses will be built? The simply do not understand supply and demand.

I don't recall Charles Lynton trying to build too many houses either.

If planning permission becomes easier to get, doesn't the supply go up?  I will admit that I've never ran a business though so this is a complex area for me.

Supply goes up if you can find people to build them (new house builds have been declining for years, and that isn't due to lack of planning, see previous comments), and you can find people prepared to commit to mortgages, when mortgage rates aren't dropping as quickly as many hoped. There are still millions coming off cheap fixed rates who won't be moving as well, because their payments are going up - they can't afford to trade up.

Easier Planning is the least of the building industries worries, and material costs are going through the roof as well. I'm amazed that any idiot thought Planning Reform was the silver bullet. It is certainly needed, but the outcome won't be loads of new homes as a consequence.
Reply
#13
(12-14-2024, 07:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Well colour me shocked...
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5yg1471rwpo

Surely this is a massive indictment of the previous govt not the current one.
Reply
#14
(12-16-2024, 02:59 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(12-14-2024, 07:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Well colour me shocked...
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5yg1471rwpo

Surely this is a massive indictment of the previous govt not the current one.

Why? Is it any Government's job to force a private employer to develop building sites and employ workers? What are you going to do, force them to train and recruit brickies in the private sector?

The problem is with National Housebuilders. They want a minimum 20% profit out of any scheme. They tailor supply to demand, and build accordingly. They will do that under a Tory/Labour/Reform government, it makes no difference.
Reply
#15
I'm not certain that anyone thought planning reform was the silver bullet, it isn't as binary as that. As you say it is a welcome step in the right direction and probably the only lever the government can pull at the moment. There is little that can be done immediately for the staffing shortages, that is a result of the long term problems in training and immigration policies (including Brexit), and as for material costs there is little that can be done there apart from make trade as frictionless as possible - both of these have had steps taken to solve.

This is a long term strategy to improve the foundations and that is what is needed at this point in time.
Reply
#16
(12-16-2024, 02:59 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(12-14-2024, 07:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Well colour me shocked...
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c5yg1471rwpo

Surely this is a massive indictment of the previous govt not the current one.

No, it a criticism of all politicians who appear to think you can switch construction on and off at will.
Reply
#17
(12-16-2024, 03:22 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm not certain that anyone thought planning reform was the silver bullet, it isn't as binary as that. As you say it is a welcome step in the right direction and probably the only lever the government can pull at the moment. There is little that can be done immediately for the staffing shortages, that is a result of the long term problems in training and immigration policies (including Brexit), and as for material costs there is little that can be done there apart from make trade as frictionless as possible - both of these have had steps taken to solve.

This is a long term strategy to improve the foundations and that is what is needed at this point in time.

Improve the foundations - I see what you did there  Big Grin Big Grin

The only way you are going to build the required number of houses is by Local Authorities commencing building programmes. But with Thatcher's Right to Buy scheme, and then the "hive off" into Housing Associations (which also run themselves for profit -  the Chief Exec of Accord was paid over £250K last year according to the Accounts), then that ship sailed 4 decades ago.

I agree it is a major problem, but the solution of setting Local Councils targets, and simplifying planning isn't going to go anywhere near to achieving it. I suppose blaming the Local Councils will give narrative, because Labour won't be controlling many of them come May.
Reply
#18
(12-16-2024, 03:22 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm not certain that anyone thought planning reform was the silver bullet, it isn't as binary as that. As you say it is a welcome step in the right direction and probably the only lever the government can pull at the moment. There is little that can be done immediately for the staffing shortages, that is a result of the long term problems in training and immigration policies (including Brexit), and as for material costs there is little that can be done there apart from make trade as frictionless as possible - both of these have had steps taken to solve.

This is a long term strategy to improve the foundations and that is what is needed at this point in time.

Planning reform is not the only lever the government can pull - far from it.

Carrot and stick on taxation / incentives is as great an issue which is why a Land Value Tax could be of huge benefit to encourage development and discourage land banking.

Equally Stamp Duty is a tax on labour mobility, downsizing and aspiration. Scrap it.

Because of the legacy issues the main reason behind the UK's ability to build huge numbers of homes in the 1950s and 1960s is not often talked about. Why do you think we were able to build so many homes in those 2 decades with an acute shortage of labour because of the war? Precisely, system building that didn't require skilled trades in the same volume. We need to start having that conversation again - having learned the downside risks of how it turned out last time (BISF, Wimpey No Fines, Unity etc)
Reply
#19
(12-16-2024, 03:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-16-2024, 03:22 PM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm not certain that anyone thought planning reform was the silver bullet, it isn't as binary as that. As you say it is a welcome step in the right direction and probably the only lever the government can pull at the moment. There is little that can be done immediately for the staffing shortages, that is a result of the long term problems in training and immigration policies (including Brexit), and as for material costs there is little that can be done there apart from make trade as frictionless as possible - both of these have had steps taken to solve.

This is a long term strategy to improve the foundations and that is what is needed at this point in time.

Planning reform is not the only lever the government can pull - far from it.

Carrot and stick on taxation / incentives is as great an issue which is why a Land Value Tax could be of huge benefit to encourage development and discourage land banking.

Equally Stamp Duty is a tax on labour mobility, downsizing and aspiration. Scrap it.

Because of the legacy issues the main reason behind the UK's ability to build huge numbers of homes in the 1950s and 1960s is not often talked about. Why do you think we were able to build so many homes in those 2 decades with an acute shortage of labour because of the war? Precisely, system building that didn't require skilled trades in the same volume. We need to start having that conversation again - having learned the downside risks of how it turned out last time (BISF, Wimpey No Fines, Unity etc)

But we've come along way from HAC, Wimpey No Fines, etc. All those units were built for good profits for the builders.

Howe about Pre-fabs, or Caravans??  Big Grin
Reply
#20
I genuinely think pre fabs should be part of the solution
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)