Football making political statements thoughts?
#51
This thread has been a wild ride that's for sure.

Again Morsy has the right not to wear this armband. People have the right to criticise him for it. Although we don't really know why he doesn't want to wear it, because he hasn't told us.

Somehow we got onto criticising the faith of Islam, for things that you could easily criticise the Christian faith for and the secular govt of the UK back in the day, remember section 28 is not so long ago.

Goes to show we all engage with a bit more listening, particularly with people who you disagree with. You might still disagree with them, but at least you will understand why they have their opinions , rather than just jumping immediately to the worst conclusions.
Reply
#52
It’s a lively debate and this is when this board is at its best.
Reply
#53
(12-03-2024, 02:49 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: This thread has been a wild ride that's for sure.

Again Morsy has the right not to wear this armband. People have the right to criticise him for it. Although we don't really know why he doesn't want to wear it, because he hasn't told us.

Somehow we got onto criticising the faith of Islam, for things that you could easily criticise the Christian faith for and the secular govt of the UK back in the day, remember section 28 is not so long ago.

Goes to show we all engage with a bit more listening, particularly with people who you disagree with. You might still disagree with them, but at least you will understand why they have their opinions , rather than just jumping immediately to the worst conclusions.

We do though, the statement from Ipswich was 'due to his religious beliefs'. Last year that was Islam, so I assume that's still the case unless he has converted.

I think it's fine if he doesn't want to wear it, and it's also fine for people to have a problem with that. I think if I was homosexual it probably would bother me to an extent because it suggests he has something against a part of me that I can't control. Then again I may also think that Sam Morsy's opinion really doesn't matter.
Reply
#54
I don't know what to comment on this so I'm just going to start selling tickets for an East Stand showdown next Sunday. Should straighten it all out.
Reply
#55
(12-03-2024, 01:39 PM)Squid Wrote:
(12-03-2024, 11:51 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(12-03-2024, 11:38 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-03-2024, 11:35 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote:
(12-03-2024, 11:31 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: I agree that's another main reason and the two are inextricably linked. This debate is not about Trump though so don't want to derail it, I was just making the point that Morsy as an individual can be condemned, yet it is somewhat taboo to condemn the religion that controls his beliefs. This is a massive issue globally as religion plays such a big part in politics and decision making. And, yes, it is also driven by money.

Just don't draw them a picture to highlight it  Wink .
It's not just one religion though, all mainstream religions are guilty of misogyny, homophobia and intolerance to the beliefs of others. Things that individuals are castigated for, yet the belief system itself is protected. Bizarre.
You are right Bob and we live in what really is a secular society now, where even most of us are lapsed Christians.

Sadly we are being continually forced to pussy foot around Islam, which stands out as being treated completely differently to other faiths. You dare not take the piss out of it.

It's a broadly practiced incredibly intolerant religion that flies in the face of the values of our society. How we deal with it though is a big old problem.

Again though, this would not have been highlighted in this case if this stupid championing of gay people for a weekend had not happened, which brings us back to the main point.

There were anti-Muslim race riots in this country this very summer.


As always, when there are (very frequently) anti-Muslim posts on here, I'm pretty sure none of you would say any of this to the faces of the many practising Muslims working in schools, hospitals or wherever else.


I get that people aren't happy about what Morsy did, but some of the comments in response are rank bigotry.
If daring to criticise a religion that I believe does not try to comply with the way the vast majority of people in this country lives is in your eyes some how censored then that's your opinion, whilst I'd just say it's free speech. However, as ever stuff like anti-Muslim, Islamaphobic etc just gets used to close down genuine debate and concerns about discussions on how this fits in with our society.

Only a couple of weeks ago at a health club I saw a bunch of Muslim lads telling a young woman who told them to get out of the pool that in their religion they don't accept orders from women.

It doesn't mean all Muslims are bad, but it seems based on my own eyes, ears and experience we do seem to have a unique set of issues with this faith, which coincidentally Morsy is part of.

I've met plenty of lovely Muslim people, have some family members now of this religion, but it doesn't stop me from having misgivings about their faith. I'll leave it at that. 

Anyway, the upshot is if we didn't have this stupid wave a flag for the gays nonsense and let them go about their lives without highlighting their sexual leanings then none of this would be necessary.
Reply
#56
(12-03-2024, 01:46 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Thought you were a libertarian?

I'm a liberal. Only people on this board think I'm a libertarian. I have no idea how they've come to that conclusion.

The imposition of campaigns like rainbow laces is straight out the "wrong think" playbook and is generally counter productive.
Reply
#57
(12-03-2024, 01:56 PM)Squid Wrote: Marc Guehi might also be in trouble for writing a political message (I love Jesus*) on a political message (the rainbow armband).

https://archive.is/EjL41



*He's Christian, so presumably doesn't have values which "flies in the face of the values of this country" etc, etc.

We are predominantly a Christian country and have Christian denominations allowing gay relationships and some openly gay clergy. It's already been said he won't get into trouble for this.

Trouble is these shows of tolerance actually just cause more problems than they are worth. I don't think the weekend's Rainbow flag thing has been in any way helpful to one gay person.
Reply
#58
In terms of the OP I agree no-one should be forced into wearing a poppy, a rainbow armband or taking the knee. When someone doesn't do any of these things it shouldn't be assumed they support the IRA (no poppy), are a homophobe (no rainbow armband) or a racist (not taking the knee), but unfortunately this is exactly what happens. While all of this stuff is well intentioned, regrettably it is now doing nothing more than sowing division and as far as football goes it should be stopped. However you will never, ever, take politics completely out of sport, as Russian athletes will tell you.
Reply
#59
Top Muslim Sam Morsy didn't have a problem wearing endorsements for Unibet and 32red.com when playing for Middlesbrough. 

People would have a lot more time and tolerance for individual beliefs if they were applied with even a modicum of consistency. Otherwise people are well within their rights to call Morsy out for this - call a spade a spade, it's only an issue when it involves the gays.
Reply
#60
(12-03-2024, 04:37 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Top Muslim Sam Morsy didn't have a problem wearing endorsements for Unibet and 32red.com when playing for Middlesbrough. 

People would have a lot more time and tolerance for individual beliefs if they were applied with even a modicum of consistency. Otherwise people are well within their rights to call Morsy out for this - call a spade a spade, it's only an issue when it involves the gays.

'...the gays'

FFS sake
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: