COP 29
#21
No, and nothing I've said even remotely suggested that. Learn to read.
Reply
#22
(11-12-2024, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Town gas is the way forward? Seriously? That's from coal, has a low energy density and the industries that made producing it as a byproduct through coal gasification have moved on so producing it would be prohibitively expensive.

The UK has also never had the resources to match the US on gas/petrol prices. The US has significantly more refineries and they're fucking massive over there. We don't have the space, plus the productive North Sea oil wells aren't even in the UK EEZ.

As for gas in pipes, that is literally the most economical way to transport it. LNG is expensive to store, transport and regasify, piping in gas from Norway is as cheap a supply of gas as we can get.

The economic argument for the UK energy markets are wind, interconnectors with Norway/France and pumped storage like pumped hydro.

We were set up for Town Gas as a bi-product, but it was all dismantled.

Gas in pipes may be efficient but we are held to ransom.

When North Sea oil and gas qas prominent in the 1970's we were promised cheap oil and gas. That pillock is now closing the fields, committing us to unachievable targets whilst the rest of the modern world is still using gas and oil .
.
The man is fucking dangerous
Reply
#23
(11-13-2024, 02:01 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Town gas is the way forward? Seriously? That's from coal, has a low energy density and the industries that made producing it as a byproduct through coal gasification have moved on so producing it would be prohibitively expensive.

The UK has also never had the resources to match the US on gas/petrol prices. The US has significantly more refineries and they're fucking massive over there. We don't have the space, plus the productive North Sea oil wells aren't even in the UK EEZ.

As for gas in pipes, that is literally the most economical way to transport it. LNG is expensive to store, transport and regasify, piping in gas from Norway is as cheap a supply of gas as we can get.

The economic argument for the UK energy markets are wind, interconnectors with Norway/France and pumped storage like pumped hydro.

We were set up for Town Gas as a bi-product, but it was all dismantled.

Gas in pipes may be efficient but we are held to ransom.

When North Sea oil and gas qas prominent in the 1970's we were promised cheap oil and gas. That pillock is now closing the fields, committing us to unachievable targets whilst the rest of the modern world is still using gas and oil .
.
The man is fucking dangerous

The industrial processes that made town gas a by-product through coal gasification are uneconomical. Why do you want to go back to 1930s industrial processes that are inefficient and cost businesses more money? Town gas is so inefficient that you would see better yields from hydrogen produced through SMR of natural gas, and even that is so prohibitively expensive in 2024 that trials to do that are falling flat on their arses due to cost. We're not living in a time when ammonia and organic chemicals are made from coal tar anymore.

The 1970s were 50 years ago, peak production in the North Sea was 25 years ago. Those oil wells were closing long before this government came in and gas is the primary reason for high energy prices in this country. You are not living in 1994 anymore, why do you think a 30-year old energy strategy is remotely relevant today?
Reply
#24
(11-13-2024, 12:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, and nothing I've said even remotely suggested that. Learn to read.

Then I don't care for whatever point you're trying to make. The state will rob us blind carbon or no carbon.
Reply
#25
(11-13-2024, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:01 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Town gas is the way forward? Seriously? That's from coal, has a low energy density and the industries that made producing it as a byproduct through coal gasification have moved on so producing it would be prohibitively expensive.

The UK has also never had the resources to match the US on gas/petrol prices. The US has significantly more refineries and they're fucking massive over there. We don't have the space, plus the productive North Sea oil wells aren't even in the UK EEZ.

As for gas in pipes, that is literally the most economical way to transport it. LNG is expensive to store, transport and regasify, piping in gas from Norway is as cheap a supply of gas as we can get.

The economic argument for the UK energy markets are wind, interconnectors with Norway/France and pumped storage like pumped hydro.

We were set up for Town Gas as a bi-product, but it was all dismantled.

Gas in pipes may be efficient but we are held to ransom.

When North Sea oil and gas qas prominent in the 1970's we were promised cheap oil and gas. That pillock is now closing the fields, committing us to unachievable targets whilst the rest of the modern world is still using gas and oil .
.
The man is fucking dangerous

The industrial processes that made town gas a by-product through coal gasification are uneconomical. Why do you want to go back to 1930s industrial processes that are inefficient and cost businesses more money? Town gas is so inefficient that you would see better yields from hydrogen produced through SMR of natural gas, and even that is so prohibitively expensive in 2024 that trials to do that are falling flat on their arses due to cost. We're not living in a time when ammonia and organic chemicals are made from coal tar anymore.

The 1970s were 50 years ago, peak production in the North Sea was 25 years ago. Those oil wells were closing long before this government came in and gas is the primary reason for high energy prices in this country. You are not living in 1994 anymore, why do you think a 30-year old energy strategy is remotely relevant today?

I bet you have a beard and drive a Tesla milk float.

The world isn't ready for this whilst cheap Fossil fuels are still available.

When the Saudi's start drilling in December this will see further reductions in oil prices. It will also cripple Putin-s war economy.
Reply
#26
(11-13-2024, 02:26 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:01 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Town gas is the way forward? Seriously? That's from coal, has a low energy density and the industries that made producing it as a byproduct through coal gasification have moved on so producing it would be prohibitively expensive.

The UK has also never had the resources to match the US on gas/petrol prices. The US has significantly more refineries and they're fucking massive over there. We don't have the space, plus the productive North Sea oil wells aren't even in the UK EEZ.

As for gas in pipes, that is literally the most economical way to transport it. LNG is expensive to store, transport and regasify, piping in gas from Norway is as cheap a supply of gas as we can get.

The economic argument for the UK energy markets are wind, interconnectors with Norway/France and pumped storage like pumped hydro.

We were set up for Town Gas as a bi-product, but it was all dismantled.

Gas in pipes may be efficient but we are held to ransom.

When North Sea oil and gas qas prominent in the 1970's we were promised cheap oil and gas. That pillock is now closing the fields, committing us to unachievable targets whilst the rest of the modern world is still using gas and oil .
.
The man is fucking dangerous

The industrial processes that made town gas a by-product through coal gasification are uneconomical. Why do you want to go back to 1930s industrial processes that are inefficient and cost businesses more money? Town gas is so inefficient that you would see better yields from hydrogen produced through SMR of natural gas, and even that is so prohibitively expensive in 2024 that trials to do that are falling flat on their arses due to cost. We're not living in a time when ammonia and organic chemicals are made from coal tar anymore.

The 1970s were 50 years ago, peak production in the North Sea was 25 years ago. Those oil wells were closing long before this government came in and gas is the primary reason for high energy prices in this country. You are not living in 1994 anymore, why do you think a 30-year old energy strategy is remotely relevant today?

I bet you have a beard and drive a Tesla milk float.

The world isn't ready for this whilst cheap Fossil fuels are still available.

When the Saudi's start drilling in December this will see further reductions in oil prices. It will also cripple Putin-s war economy.

I drive a mid-2000s VW Golf GTI, I'm also currently looking at buying a used RS4 Avant to replace it. Your assumptions about me are, yet again, way off. I do have a beard though, because I'm not living in the 1950s like you are though that would explain why you think coal gas is viable.

Cheap fossil fuels are not a thing anymore for the UK, the UK has one of the most expensive energy markets in the world because of our reliance on fossil fuels and decisions over decades to prioritise fossil fuel investment over nuclear because of stupid short-termist decisions that have come home to roost, what Saudi Arabia does is irrelevant so long as the push factor from there is isolated from the UK NBP spot price, which it is as there's no pipeline to connect the gulf to the European market.
Reply
#27
(11-13-2024, 02:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:26 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:01 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 09:16 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Town gas is the way forward? Seriously? That's from coal, has a low energy density and the industries that made producing it as a byproduct through coal gasification have moved on so producing it would be prohibitively expensive.

The UK has also never had the resources to match the US on gas/petrol prices. The US has significantly more refineries and they're fucking massive over there. We don't have the space, plus the productive North Sea oil wells aren't even in the UK EEZ.

As for gas in pipes, that is literally the most economical way to transport it. LNG is expensive to store, transport and regasify, piping in gas from Norway is as cheap a supply of gas as we can get.

The economic argument for the UK energy markets are wind, interconnectors with Norway/France and pumped storage like pumped hydro.

We were set up for Town Gas as a bi-product, but it was all dismantled.

Gas in pipes may be efficient but we are held to ransom.

When North Sea oil and gas qas prominent in the 1970's we were promised cheap oil and gas. That pillock is now closing the fields, committing us to unachievable targets whilst the rest of the modern world is still using gas and oil .
.
The man is fucking dangerous

The industrial processes that made town gas a by-product through coal gasification are uneconomical. Why do you want to go back to 1930s industrial processes that are inefficient and cost businesses more money? Town gas is so inefficient that you would see better yields from hydrogen produced through SMR of natural gas, and even that is so prohibitively expensive in 2024 that trials to do that are falling flat on their arses due to cost. We're not living in a time when ammonia and organic chemicals are made from coal tar anymore.

The 1970s were 50 years ago, peak production in the North Sea was 25 years ago. Those oil wells were closing long before this government came in and gas is the primary reason for high energy prices in this country. You are not living in 1994 anymore, why do you think a 30-year old energy strategy is remotely relevant today?

I bet you have a beard and drive a Tesla milk float.

The world isn't ready for this whilst cheap Fossil fuels are still available.

When the Saudi's start drilling in December this will see further reductions in oil prices. It will also cripple Putin-s war economy.

I drive a mid-2000s VW Golf GTI, I'm also currently looking at buying a used RS4 Avant to replace it. Your assumptions about me are, yet again, way off. I do have a beard though, because I'm not living in the 1950s like you are though that would explain why you think coal gas is viable.

Cheap fossil fuels are not a thing anymore for the UK, the UK has one of the most expensive energy markets in the world because of our reliance on fossil fuels and decisions over decades to prioritise fossil fuel investment over nuclear because of stupid short-termist decisions that have come home to roost, what Saudi Arabia does is irrelevant so long as the push factor from there is isolated from the UK NBP spot price, which it is as there's no pipeline to connect the gulf to the European market.

Your carbon footprint is bigger than mine with cars, and that's saying something.

I was funding the REC's in the mid 90's and also had a funding line into Nuclear Electric. The problem wasn't over reliance on fossil, it was the complete lack of investment by overseas owners to replace ageing kit.

Once the Magnox reactors had gone, there was very little left. Our utility companies should never have been privatised (including water - I used to fund Severn Trent, Welsh Water and South West Water) and now we pay the price.

With regard to Saudi oil, it will have an impact on global markets, which will inevitably lead to a worldwide reduction in oil price. That can only be a good thing if the Indians are buying Russian oil below their effective extraction price.
Reply
#28
(11-13-2024, 03:06 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:26 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:01 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: We were set up for Town Gas as a bi-product, but it was all dismantled.

Gas in pipes may be efficient but we are held to ransom.

When North Sea oil and gas qas prominent in the 1970's we were promised cheap oil and gas. That pillock is now closing the fields, committing us to unachievable targets whilst the rest of the modern world is still using gas and oil .
.
The man is fucking dangerous

The industrial processes that made town gas a by-product through coal gasification are uneconomical. Why do you want to go back to 1930s industrial processes that are inefficient and cost businesses more money? Town gas is so inefficient that you would see better yields from hydrogen produced through SMR of natural gas, and even that is so prohibitively expensive in 2024 that trials to do that are falling flat on their arses due to cost. We're not living in a time when ammonia and organic chemicals are made from coal tar anymore.

The 1970s were 50 years ago, peak production in the North Sea was 25 years ago. Those oil wells were closing long before this government came in and gas is the primary reason for high energy prices in this country. You are not living in 1994 anymore, why do you think a 30-year old energy strategy is remotely relevant today?

I bet you have a beard and drive a Tesla milk float.

The world isn't ready for this whilst cheap Fossil fuels are still available.

When the Saudi's start drilling in December this will see further reductions in oil prices. It will also cripple Putin-s war economy.

I drive a mid-2000s VW Golf GTI, I'm also currently looking at buying a used RS4 Avant to replace it. Your assumptions about me are, yet again, way off. I do have a beard though, because I'm not living in the 1950s like you are though that would explain why you think coal gas is viable.

Cheap fossil fuels are not a thing anymore for the UK, the UK has one of the most expensive energy markets in the world because of our reliance on fossil fuels and decisions over decades to prioritise fossil fuel investment over nuclear because of stupid short-termist decisions that have come home to roost, what Saudi Arabia does is irrelevant so long as the push factor from there is isolated from the UK NBP spot price, which it is as there's no pipeline to connect the gulf to the European market.

Your carbon footprint is bigger than mine with cars, and that's saying something.

I was funding the REC's in the mid 90's and also had a funding line into Nuclear Electric. The problem wasn't over reliance on fossil, it was the complete lack of investment by overseas owners to replace ageing kit.

Once the Magnox reactors had gone, there was very little left. Our utility companies should never have been privatised (including water - I used to fund Severn Trent, Welsh Water and South West Water) and now we pay the price.

With regard to Saudi oil, it will have an impact on global markets, which will inevitably lead to a worldwide reduction in oil price. That can only be a good thing if the Indians are buying Russian oil below their effective extraction price.

I bought my car used and I tend to only drive it on weekends. I've also invested in a couple of companies looking at efuels so I can continue driving ICE cars, out of hope more than any expectation of return.

You thinking like it's the 1990s is what I am trying to say. The picture in the 1990s is very different to what it is now, in the 1990s we were at the tail-end of the "Rush for Gas". Natural gas was cheap, UK North Sea oil and gas was approaching peak output. That isn't the case anymore, the only fossil fuels that aren't prohibitively expensive for the UK are derived from crude and that's because shipping oil is so much easier and cheaper than gas making it a much more global market, but oil isn't and has never been a significant component in our energy mix. The cost of nuclear in the 1980s and 1990s was high relative to CCGT, coupled with the lack of flexibility with nuclear to scale compared with gas, so the private sector was never going to fund replacing the Magnox reactors with PWR reactors. Energy utility companies I'm perfectly content with privatising (there's genuine market competition in the supplier market) but the generation and transmission side of CEGB should have stayed publicly owned. But ultimately, that's redundant to my point. The LCOE of new nuclear is on par or even below CCGT now, that's how expensive fossil fuels are for electricity generation.

Saudi oil extraction will bring down global oil prices, because oil is cheap to transport. Gas is a different issue, it's not easy to transport gas and without a pipeline the push and pull factors on the wider Eurasian gas market will be minimal. It may benefit Spain as Spain is tied to the MENA gas market more than the Eurasian one but, again, that isn't really relevant to what effects the UK NBD spot price. The effect of Russia was big because Russian gas is piped in directly into Eastern and Central Europe, reducing demand on Norwegian gas.

I speak as someone who works on this every day and has to produce cost models to inform stakeholders and clients, if the UK wants cheaper energy then the path to that is moving away from fossil fuels for heat and power. That includes more renewables, more nuclear and - a critical issue that is often underplayed - transmission. That's why the markets here have shifted away, they were doing that before the change in government.
Reply
#29
(11-13-2024, 03:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 03:06 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:26 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-13-2024, 02:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The industrial processes that made town gas a by-product through coal gasification are uneconomical. Why do you want to go back to 1930s industrial processes that are inefficient and cost businesses more money? Town gas is so inefficient that you would see better yields from hydrogen produced through SMR of natural gas, and even that is so prohibitively expensive in 2024 that trials to do that are falling flat on their arses due to cost. We're not living in a time when ammonia and organic chemicals are made from coal tar anymore.

The 1970s were 50 years ago, peak production in the North Sea was 25 years ago. Those oil wells were closing long before this government came in and gas is the primary reason for high energy prices in this country. You are not living in 1994 anymore, why do you think a 30-year old energy strategy is remotely relevant today?

I bet you have a beard and drive a Tesla milk float.

The world isn't ready for this whilst cheap Fossil fuels are still available.

When the Saudi's start drilling in December this will see further reductions in oil prices. It will also cripple Putin-s war economy.

I drive a mid-2000s VW Golf GTI, I'm also currently looking at buying a used RS4 Avant to replace it. Your assumptions about me are, yet again, way off. I do have a beard though, because I'm not living in the 1950s like you are though that would explain why you think coal gas is viable.

Cheap fossil fuels are not a thing anymore for the UK, the UK has one of the most expensive energy markets in the world because of our reliance on fossil fuels and decisions over decades to prioritise fossil fuel investment over nuclear because of stupid short-termist decisions that have come home to roost, what Saudi Arabia does is irrelevant so long as the push factor from there is isolated from the UK NBP spot price, which it is as there's no pipeline to connect the gulf to the European market.

Your carbon footprint is bigger than mine with cars, and that's saying something.

I was funding the REC's in the mid 90's and also had a funding line into Nuclear Electric. The problem wasn't over reliance on fossil, it was the complete lack of investment by overseas owners to replace ageing kit.

Once the Magnox reactors had gone, there was very little left. Our utility companies should never have been privatised (including water - I used to fund Severn Trent, Welsh Water and South West Water) and now we pay the price.

With regard to Saudi oil, it will have an impact on global markets, which will inevitably lead to a worldwide reduction in oil price. That can only be a good thing if the Indians are buying Russian oil below their effective extraction price.

I bought my car used and I tend to only drive it on weekends. I've also invested in a couple of companies looking at efuels so I can continue driving ICE cars, out of hope more than any expectation of return.

You thinking like it's the 1990s is what I am trying to say. The picture in the 1990s is very different to what it is now, in the 1990s we were at the tail-end of the "Rush for Gas". Natural gas was cheap, UK North Sea oil and gas was approaching peak output. That isn't the case anymore, the only fossil fuels that aren't prohibitively expensive for the UK are derived from crude and that's because shipping oil is so much easier and cheaper than gas making it a much more global market, but oil isn't and has never been a significant component in our energy mix. The cost of nuclear in the 1980s and 1990s was high relative to CCGT, coupled with the lack of flexibility with nuclear to scale compared with gas, so the private sector was never going to fund replacing the Magnox reactors with PWR reactors. Energy utility companies I'm perfectly content with privatising (there's genuine market competition in the supplier market) but the generation and transmission side of CEGB should have stayed publicly owned. But ultimately, that's redundant to my point. The LCOE of new nuclear is on par or even below CCGT now, that's how expensive fossil fuels are for electricity generation.

Saudi oil extraction will bring down global oil prices, because oil is cheap to transport. Gas is a different issue, it's not easy to transport gas and without a pipeline the push and pull factors on the wider Eurasian gas market will be minimal. It may benefit Spain as Spain is tied to the MENA gas market more than the Eurasian one but, again, that isn't really relevant to what effects the UK NBD spot price. The effect of Russia was big because Russian gas is piped in directly into Eastern and Central Europe, reducing demand on Norwegian gas.

I speak as someone who works on this every day and has to produce cost models to inform stakeholders and clients, if the UK wants cheaper energy then the path to that is moving away from fossil fuels for heat and power. That includes more renewables, more nuclear and - a critical issue that is often underplayed - transmission. That's why the markets here have shifted away, they were doing that before the change in government.

It just doesn't feel like we are ready yet to fully commit to anything other than Fossil fuels. What happens when the sun doesn't shine, or the wind doesn't blow - like the last few weeks? Milliband's plan is going to see prices increase before they come down.

If I have read correctly, China still generates 2/3 of its electricity from Fossil fuels, so there must be a model to make this work. Cheap Russian oil maybe?
Reply
#30
The technology is there. Obstructive planning and stupid funding are the issues. Build another interconnector to France, another to Norway and one to Morocco and we have the capability to pool power resources taking advantage of Norwegian hydro, Moroccan solar and French nuclear while also selling British wind power. Build the planned pumped storage and we can better manage lulls in renewables while better utilising renewable capacity. Build Hinkley Point C and Sizewell C (and hopefully more) and we can get a higher baseload and sell excess to Germany and Denmark (alongside excess wind) through the planned interconnector there. Heat networks are perfect for cities like Leeds, Glasgow, Birmingham and Manchester to reduce gas heating demand, Copenhagen is a perfect example of that (and there are plans to do that, Birmingham city centre already uses a heat network in of itself). Transmission is hardly a novel technology and we need to upgrade transmission and delivery points. A significant cost to doing all of that is literally just obstructive planning, not even labour shortages or capital funding.

Fossil fuels are why energy is expensive in the UK, we need to move away from them not just for carbon but also for energy security and lower energy costs.

As for China, a third of Chinese power is renewable, installed renewable capacity is increasing exponentially there alongside nuclear and Chinese solar panels are cheap as chips. I'm really not worried about them, the bigger issue globally is Europe deciding to abandon decarbonisation despite the cost and energy security benefits and an American President that believes in "Clean Coal", might as well believe in Father Christmas.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: