Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
11-13-2024, 08:00 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2024, 08:01 AM by Pontificator.)
(11-13-2024, 07:42 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 07:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.
I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc. I understand that there are concerns about vulnerable people being taken advantage of, but surely it is within reason and not 'too' difficult to implement (why would it be more difficult than Power of Attorneys for financial and health, where you have to have checks by relevant professionals). I just believe the right to not suffer in unimaginable pain with no chance of improvement should be a basic human right.
So when you are in any or one of those situations, someone will decide that you are a burden and someone will murder you. Can't you see what's wrong with this?
It is not illegal to commit suicide. indeed it is a right you have had since 1961 - it is illegal to "assist" someone and rightly so. I have done my power of attorney for health & wealth, there is absolutely no way you will ever have yourself "offed" by this method
No, because it would be my choice and a choice I'd like to make officially when I'm not in that situation, i.e now, and while I'm compos mentis. If I was able to sign a power of attorney to that affect today, I would.
We're not advocating some scumbag nephew signing forms to end his aunts life against her wishes to gain access to her fortune, here. We're talking about heavily regulated consent which is made when you're in full control of your mind.
So you will appoint someone in a POA to make a decision that you should be murdered. That is just bizarre
https://x.com/LBC/status/1856411987632079252
Posts: 9,644
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
11-13-2024, 08:05 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2024, 08:09 AM by Josh1873.)
I can only think of dementia where you end up in a situation where you have no life, and are a burden on family, and don't have control of your mind, where I feel like I, when I'm sound of mind, now, I wouldn't want to carry on living and would want to be killed as humanely and pain free as possible.
Every other situation, I believe you'd be of sound mind and could make that decision yourself.
I'm not so sure coercion is as big an issue as is being made out. For me, the legislation I want to see is in the situation where there's no way back AND you're sound of mind, then YOU should have a choice to die peacefully.
As said above, the only possible grey area would be when you suffer with dementia. When you're sound of mind no one wants to end their life not recognising their loved ones and not even knowing your own name. This is obviously the most continuous issue. We all know that if in this situation we'd all want to die. But who makes the choice and when is difficult. There should be a separate legislation for this due to the lack of consent when the patient is in the advanced stages of dementia.
But for now, there should be absolutely no reason why legislation can't be brought in for cases where the patient is absolutely sound of mind.
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-13-2024, 08:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I can only think of dementia where you end up in a situation where you have no life, and are a burden on family, and don't have control of your mind, where I feel like I, when I'm sound of mind, now, I wouldn't want to carry on living and would want to be killed as humanely and pain free as possible.
Every other situation, I believe you'd be of sound mind and could make that decision yourself.
I'm not so sure coercion is as big an issue as is being made out. For me, the legislation I want to see is in the situation where there's no way back AND you're sound of mind, then YOU should have a choice to die peacefully.
As said above, the only possible grey area would be when you suffer with dementia. When you're sound of mind no one wants to end their life not recognising their loved ones and not even knowing your own name. This is obviously the most continuous issue. We all know that if in this situation we'd all want to die. But who makes the choice and when is difficult. There should be a separate legislation for this due to the lack of consent when the patient is in the advanced stages of dementia.
But for now, there should be absolutely no reason why legislation can't be brought in for cases where the patient is absolutely sound of mind.
FFS there is nothing stopping you from offing yourself, its not illegal. Appointing someone to murder you is and that ain't gonna change
Posts: 7,452
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
For people to “off” themselves, if they wished to, they would need to be capable of commuting such an act. Which is the whole point of the bill, that by the point they need help they can’t and aren’t.
It’s really not that complicated.
Posts: 9,644
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
I can't believe I'm reading someone advocating committing suicide.
We're talking about assisted dying which is done medically, humanely and as pain free as possible in situations where you are in unimaginable pain and are terminally ill/dying.
I don't see the correlation personally.
Posts: 8,002
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-13-2024, 08:00 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-13-2024, 07:42 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 07:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.
I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc. I understand that there are concerns about vulnerable people being taken advantage of, but surely it is within reason and not 'too' difficult to implement (why would it be more difficult than Power of Attorneys for financial and health, where you have to have checks by relevant professionals). I just believe the right to not suffer in unimaginable pain with no chance of improvement should be a basic human right.
So when you are in any or one of those situations, someone will decide that you are a burden and someone will murder you. Can't you see what's wrong with this?
It is not illegal to commit suicide. indeed it is a right you have had since 1961 - it is illegal to "assist" someone and rightly so. I have done my power of attorney for health & wealth, there is absolutely no way you will ever have yourself "offed" by this method
No, because it would be my choice and a choice I'd like to make officially when I'm not in that situation, i.e now, and while I'm compos mentis. If I was able to sign a power of attorney to that affect today, I would.
We're not advocating some scumbag nephew signing forms to end his aunts life against her wishes to gain access to her fortune, here. We're talking about heavily regulated consent which is made when you're in full control of your mind.
So you will appoint someone in a POA to make a decision that you should be murdered. That is just bizarre
https://x.com/LBC/status/1856411987632079252 I don't get the murder thing. Whether pre-consensual or not, nothing would ever be allowed to be decided without medical / legal authorisation. The grabby nephew couldn't just rock up and say "Right I'm skint, let's off him" .
Even in the case of dementia, a medical professional would have to ordain that I was no longer able to be cared for adequately by myself or family and needed professional care. That would be the point that my pre-dementia wishes would kick in.
As Josh says, with physical illness I would be making my own decision in real time, so no murdering going on there.
The key to any legislation, for me, is choice. We should be able to establish a process where you can, safely, opt in or opt out.
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
I thought assisted dying was merciful, now it’s terrifying
Michael Coren
Tuesday November 12 2024, 9.00pm, The Times
I’m an Anglican priest in Canada, and contrary to what some might believe, being a vicar is more about funerals and comforting the dying than sherry and sandwiches. It’s one of the privileges of the vocation to offer support to people who are profoundly ill or close to life’s end. But I’ve also seen enough pain and loss of hope that when Canada introduced Medical Assistance in Dying (Maid) in 2016 I was supportive.
A strictly controlled, highly monitored and limited form of assisted dying seemed humane and compassionate. It would apply, I assumed, to those relatively rare cases where people can no longer tolerate the agony (it’s untrue that all pain can be controlled) or where death was imminent and the patient terrified of dying alone and in fear.
What has evolved, however, is something terrifyingly different. More than 46,000 people have died through Maid and there’s an exponential growth in its use. In 2021, there were around 10,000 cases, a 30 per cent increase within a year. It’s estimated that 4.1 per cent of all deaths are now through Maid.
Something ideological has crept its way into all this, and I’ve encountered supporters of the system who seem committed not to easing human suffering but redefining human existence. I say this not as a moral conservative but a progressive Christian. Nor am I alone. Inclusion Canada works on behalf of people with learning disabilities. Its executive vice president Krista Carr said recently, “We are witnessing an alarming trend where people with disabilities are seeking assisted suicide due to social deprivation, poverty and lack of essential supports.”
This is crucial. Contrary to what some British proponents of assisted dying have claimed, opposition is far from exclusively religious. The loudest rejection in Canada is now from the disabled, poor and marginalised. Hardly surprising when a poll last year found that 27 per cent of Canadians said poverty or homelessness could be considered valid reasons for applying for Maid.
Canada and Britain share many similarities; one is a publicly funded health system under constant strain. In British Columbia, Dan Quayle, a 52-year-old cancer patient, chose Maid. His partner, Kathleen Carmichael, said: “The oncologist would come in and say, ‘We’re pretty backlogged right now; so hang in there.’” He couldn’t.
It’s undeniable that what was proposed as enlightened and overdue has taken on a frightening form of its own, with even mental health now proposed as a qualification for assisted dying. Clichés aside, some slopes really are grimly slippery.
Posts: 9,644
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
11-13-2024, 09:11 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2024, 09:14 AM by Josh1873.)
(11-13-2024, 09:04 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (11-13-2024, 08:00 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-13-2024, 07:42 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (11-13-2024, 07:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.
I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc. I understand that there are concerns about vulnerable people being taken advantage of, but surely it is within reason and not 'too' difficult to implement (why would it be more difficult than Power of Attorneys for financial and health, where you have to have checks by relevant professionals). I just believe the right to not suffer in unimaginable pain with no chance of improvement should be a basic human right.
So when you are in any or one of those situations, someone will decide that you are a burden and someone will murder you. Can't you see what's wrong with this?
It is not illegal to commit suicide. indeed it is a right you have had since 1961 - it is illegal to "assist" someone and rightly so. I have done my power of attorney for health & wealth, there is absolutely no way you will ever have yourself "offed" by this method
No, because it would be my choice and a choice I'd like to make officially when I'm not in that situation, i.e now, and while I'm compos mentis. If I was able to sign a power of attorney to that affect today, I would.
We're not advocating some scumbag nephew signing forms to end his aunts life against her wishes to gain access to her fortune, here. We're talking about heavily regulated consent which is made when you're in full control of your mind.
So you will appoint someone in a POA to make a decision that you should be murdered. That is just bizarre
https://x.com/LBC/status/1856411987632079252 I don't get the murder thing. Whether pre-consensual or not, nothing would ever be allowed to be decided without medical / legal authorisation. The grabby nephew couldn't just rock up and say "Right I'm skint, let's off him" .
Even in the case of dementia, a medical professional would have to ordain that I was no longer able to be cared for adequately by myself or family and needed professional care. That would be the point that my pre-dementia wishes would kick in.
As Josh says, with physical illness I would be making my own decision in real time, so no murdering going on there.
The key to any legislation, for me, is choice. We should be able to establish a process where you can, safely, opt in or opt out.
We're also talking about situations where you're dying anyway. Anyone who has designs of getting their hands on inheritance wouldn't have to wait too long. So I'm really not sure coercion is an issue. Why risk being caught murdering for the sake of waiting weeks or months?
I've made that point clumsily and worded it insensitively - I'm aware, but the point remains.
I also think people are missing the point that we're advocating choice and free will, which has to be stringently verified by professionals, in cases where your outlook is bleak and painful.
I'm reading some of these responses as if we're advocating forcing someone, who is healthy and has years to live, to kill themselves!
Posts: 8,002
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-13-2024, 09:10 AM)Pontificator Wrote: I thought assisted dying was merciful, now it’s terrifying
Michael Coren
Tuesday November 12 2024, 9.00pm, The Times
I’m an Anglican priest in Canada, and contrary to what some might believe, being a vicar is more about funerals and comforting the dying than sherry and sandwiches. It’s one of the privileges of the vocation to offer support to people who are profoundly ill or close to life’s end. But I’ve also seen enough pain and loss of hope that when Canada introduced Medical Assistance in Dying (Maid) in 2016 I was supportive.
A strictly controlled, highly monitored and limited form of assisted dying seemed humane and compassionate. It would apply, I assumed, to those relatively rare cases where people can no longer tolerate the agony (it’s untrue that all pain can be controlled) or where death was imminent and the patient terrified of dying alone and in fear.
What has evolved, however, is something terrifyingly different. More than 46,000 people have died through Maid and there’s an exponential growth in its use. In 2021, there were around 10,000 cases, a 30 per cent increase within a year. It’s estimated that 4.1 per cent of all deaths are now through Maid.
Something ideological has crept its way into all this, and I’ve encountered supporters of the system who seem committed not to easing human suffering but redefining human existence. I say this not as a moral conservative but a progressive Christian. Nor am I alone. Inclusion Canada works on behalf of people with learning disabilities. Its executive vice president Krista Carr said recently, “We are witnessing an alarming trend where people with disabilities are seeking assisted suicide due to social deprivation, poverty and lack of essential supports.”
This is crucial. Contrary to what some British proponents of assisted dying have claimed, opposition is far from exclusively religious. The loudest rejection in Canada is now from the disabled, poor and marginalised. Hardly surprising when a poll last year found that 27 per cent of Canadians said poverty or homelessness could be considered valid reasons for applying for Maid.
Canada and Britain share many similarities; one is a publicly funded health system under constant strain. In British Columbia, Dan Quayle, a 52-year-old cancer patient, chose Maid. His partner, Kathleen Carmichael, said: “The oncologist would come in and say, ‘We’re pretty backlogged right now; so hang in there.’” He couldn’t.
It’s undeniable that what was proposed as enlightened and overdue has taken on a frightening form of its own, with even mental health now proposed as a qualification for assisted dying. Clichés aside, some slopes really are grimly slippery.
I don't see anything there that suggests murder is rife. All of the above seem to be borne from choice.
It's a sad indictment on society that poverty would be considered by someone as a viable reason, I agree, but I don't see how a medical professional would sign off on that?
As for mental health, well, the tortures of that can be more debilitating and life changing than physical illness, so should be treated the same way. If the only treatment option is to lock me up, for the safety of myself or others, then I'd say it was a fair option.
Posts: 7,452
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Ponty, as usual, is off in Pontys World, while the rest of us discuss reality
|