Assisted dying legislation.
#31
Surely any situation can be manipulated by those unscrupulous scumbags, regardless of whether this bill is passed, or not.
Reply
#32
(11-12-2024, 12:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 11:57 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 11:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe a few years ago I would have said a definite yes but having seen now how the disabled were treated during Covid with DNR’s disproportionately used at the whim of the state against them be they children or adults, I find the idea the thin end of the wedge.

It’s well meaning now, but the idea of fundamentally changing our laws from protecting the sanctity of life to this muddying of the waters whilst we have populist agitators (you can insert any insult you wish here) like Farage and co waiting in the wings is scaring/alarming the disabled community and imo with just cause. We are already seeing the way language is being used about the disabled changing from one of understanding and support to how much per person does this person cost the state, (Labour should hang their head in shame at continuing this demonisation) and you can see if we as a country let the shyster populist in, that language will potentially have consequences far beyond the current proposed bill.

In short I wouldn’t trust the state, politicians or many within our communities to not change the law as we move forward to the detriment of the disabled community.

Have you seen the (unpublished and never enacted) COVID rationing criteria that came out of the enquiry last week?

No but here’s some links…

Article One 
Article 2
Article Three

Sorry but I don’t trust this bill to be the end of the conversation for some vulnerable groups.

This is shocking if true (no reason to disbelieve it).
Reply
#33
If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.

I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc. I understand that there are concerns about vulnerable people being taken advantage of, but surely it is within reason and not 'too' difficult to implement (why would it be more difficult than Power of Attorneys for financial and health, where you have to have checks by relevant professionals). I just believe the right to not suffer in unimaginable pain with no chance of improvement should be a basic human right.
Reply
#34
(11-12-2024, 12:33 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Surely any situation can be manipulated by those unscrupulous scumbags, regardless of whether this bill is passed, or not.

That would be my view too.

I don’t think avoiding it solves it and actually there is nothing stopping people having almost the opposite in place when they are sane of mind - something that is signed to say they specifically don’t want such decisions ever made. 

Avoiding the problem because other things are not perfect isn’t the solution
Reply
#35
(11-12-2024, 12:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 11:57 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 11:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Maybe a few years ago I would have said a definite yes but having seen now how the disabled were treated during Covid with DNR’s disproportionately used at the whim of the state against them be they children or adults, I find the idea the thin end of the wedge.

It’s well meaning now, but the idea of fundamentally changing our laws from protecting the sanctity of life to this muddying of the waters whilst we have populist agitators (you can insert any insult you wish here) like Farage and co waiting in the wings is scaring/alarming the disabled community and imo with just cause. We are already seeing the way language is being used about the disabled changing from one of understanding and support to how much per person does this person cost the state, (Labour should hang their head in shame at continuing this demonisation) and you can see if we as a country let the shyster populist in, that language will potentially have consequences far beyond the current proposed bill.

In short I wouldn’t trust the state, politicians or many within our communities to not change the law as we move forward to the detriment of the disabled community.

Have you seen the (unpublished and never enacted) COVID rationing criteria that came out of the enquiry last week?

No but here’s some links…

Article One 
Article 2
Article Three

Sorry but I don’t trust this bill to be the end of the conversation for some vulnerable groups.

Yeah, these were more decision-making by individual organisations. The report last week was about a nationally consistent approach to depriorotising certain groups of patients. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cd0gdzdv53yo
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#36
(11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.

I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc. I understand that there are concerns about vulnerable people being taken advantage of, but surely it is within reason and not 'too' difficult to implement (why would it be more difficult than Power of Attorneys for financial and health, where you have to have checks by relevant professionals). I just believe the right to not suffer in unimaginable pain with no chance of improvement should be a basic human right.

Almost like an "Enduring Power of Attorney", that you appoint when you are of "sound mind" to take effect when it might be judged that you are in a situation where it could be argued you can't make decisions for yourself?
Reply
#37
(11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.

I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc.

Same. Should be similar to a donor card, or part of a will. I should be able to decide now, what should happen to me if I become incapable of deciding in the future.
If it's a physical illness and there is no loss of brain function, then I should be able to decide at any time.
Reply
#38
https://wellcomeopenresearch.org/articles/6-183

Is a better image of the screenshot.

You got extra points for having two hospital admissions per year, needing help with medications or having cancer.

Too many points? Someone else gets the itu bed.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#39
(11-12-2024, 12:42 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.

I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc. I understand that there are concerns about vulnerable people being taken advantage of, but surely it is within reason and not 'too' difficult to implement (why would it be more difficult than Power of Attorneys for financial and health, where you have to have checks by relevant professionals). I just believe the right to not suffer in unimaginable pain with no chance of improvement should be a basic human right.

Almost like an "Enduring Power of Attorney", that you appoint when you are of "sound mind" to take effect when it might be judged that you are in a situation where it could be argued you can't make decisions for yourself?

That's how it would work in my mind, yes. 

I think to a man we all agree we don't want to be alive when dementia completely takes hold. I do understand there's a grey area of when that point may be, but it's surely possible to sign something well before you're even diagnosed to say 'when I no longer recognise my family, and I'm a complete burden, please end my life peacefully'.

(11-12-2024, 12:43 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.

I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc.

Same. Should be similar to a donor card, or part of a will. I should be able to decide now, what should happen to me if I become incapable of deciding in the future.
If it's a physical illness and there is no loss of brain function, then I should be able to decide at any time.
It should be along these lines, combined with a passport type system, where it needs to be renewed periodically to ensure wishes are as up-to-date as possible.
Reply
#40
I understand the good intentions behind this bill, but I think I would vote against it.

Strikes me as thin edge of a very scary wedge.

That said I would impress on the cps the need for criminal prosecutions to be in the public interest.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)