Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
What is this wedge people speak of?
This is a very specific bill based around terminally ill people being given some dignity in death and removing the arduous wait for the inevitable from around the necks of their families.
There is absolutely no one who will use this as the foot in the door to enable the willful dispatch of the disabled and the elderly.
Posts: 7,995
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(11-12-2024, 01:12 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I understand the good intentions behind this bill, but I think I would vote against it.
Strikes me as thin edge of a very scary wedge.
That said I would impress on the cps the need for criminal prosecutions to be in the public interest. Isn't that sanctioning, illegal, assisted suicide.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(11-12-2024, 12:33 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Surely any situation can be manipulated by those unscrupulous scumbags, regardless of whether this bill is passed, or not.
You don’t make it easier for them is the point. Reform and many in the Tory Party already wish to abandon the ECHR so anything that weakens or potentially weakens the most vulnerable rights I’m naturally against or at least sceptical of. No, I don’t believe our own bill of rights will an adequate replacement.
Many in the disabled community feel under attack from successive governments and those that advocate for them. They don’t believe this will be a full stop to the conversation and instead It’ll be start of a whole new chapter of whittling away the rights of the same care and rights others receive.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(11-12-2024, 01:37 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: What is this wedge people speak of?
This is a very specific bill based around terminally ill people being given some dignity in death and removing the arduous wait for the inevitable from around the necks of their families.
There is absolutely no one who will use this as the foot in the door to enable the willful dispatch of the disabled and the elderly.
This is the specific bill, the thin end of the wedge is what Derek and Squid have offered as what could possibly happen. I favour a cautious approach even though I'm in full agreement that I wouldn't want to simply exist as a burden to family or endure a long, painful exit. It is all about the level of trust in whoever is around at the time.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
11-12-2024, 02:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-12-2024, 02:07 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(11-12-2024, 01:37 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: What is this wedge people speak of?
This is a very specific bill based around terminally ill people being given some dignity in death and removing the arduous wait for the inevitable from around the necks of their families.
There is absolutely no one who will use this as the foot in the door to enable the willful dispatch of the disabled and the elderly.
Here you go…
Lived experience
It’s not a black and white issue for many and it’s incredibly naive to believe the best in people around this subject, it cannot be taken for granted.
Quote:For anyone who thinks “that could never happen here”, consider that it already has in some form. During the height of the pandemic, some people with learning disabilities were given “do not resuscitate” orders without their consent. Women with learning disabilities already die on average 18 years younger than non-disabled women, with many of these deaths found to be avoidable due to unequal healthcare.
It is not as if there is outrage when disabled people die needlessly. More a tilt of the head and an easy acceptance that it was “probably for the best”. Every disabled person who has been told by a stranger in Tesco that they would “rather die than be like you” knows, in the pit of our stomachs, what some members of the public think about the value of our lives. It is easy to dismiss the dangers of a “slippery slope” when it is not you who is at risk of falling down it.
From the Guardian (I know disgraceful to quote it).
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(11-12-2024, 01:43 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (11-12-2024, 01:12 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I understand the good intentions behind this bill, but I think I would vote against it.
Strikes me as thin edge of a very scary wedge.
That said I would impress on the cps the need for criminal prosecutions to be in the public interest. Isn't that sanctioning, illegal, assisted suicide.
No. For all crimes, criminal prosecutions should only proceed if it is in the public interest.
What I am suggesting is that the cps in this particular area should tread more carefully than they might in other areas. There will be incidents of assisted dying where it is absolutely right that a criminal prosecution is pursued.
Posts: 7,446
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Often agree with your views SR but this just sounds like a continuation or worsening of the current fudge.
It’s an issue that won’t go away and needs to be confronted and improved, not constrained by other things that need improving also
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.
I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc. I understand that there are concerns about vulnerable people being taken advantage of, but surely it is within reason and not 'too' difficult to implement (why would it be more difficult than Power of Attorneys for financial and health, where you have to have checks by relevant professionals). I just believe the right to not suffer in unimaginable pain with no chance of improvement should be a basic human right.
So when you are in any or one of those situations, someone will decide that you are a burden and someone will murder you. Can't you see what's wrong with this?
It is not illegal to commit suicide. indeed it is a right you have had since 1961 - it is illegal to "assist" someone and rightly so. I have done my power of attorney for health & wealth, there is absolutely no way you will ever have yourself "offed" by this method
Posts: 9,642
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
(11-13-2024, 07:34 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (11-12-2024, 12:35 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: If I'm ever in a situation where I'm terminally ill, or a situation where I'm in insufferable pain and there's no chance of my life improving, or I get diagnosed with dementia, or I'm a burden on loved one, I want my life to end as pain free and easily as possible. This should be a human right.
I possess all my faculties now, and this view will never change. I don't understand why the above wishes can't be adhered to if/when the time comes, given proper checks, documents etc signed and authorised and approved by the relevant doctors etc. I understand that there are concerns about vulnerable people being taken advantage of, but surely it is within reason and not 'too' difficult to implement (why would it be more difficult than Power of Attorneys for financial and health, where you have to have checks by relevant professionals). I just believe the right to not suffer in unimaginable pain with no chance of improvement should be a basic human right.
So when you are in any or one of those situations, someone will decide that you are a burden and someone will murder you. Can't you see what's wrong with this?
It is not illegal to commit suicide. indeed it is a right you have had since 1961 - it is illegal to "assist" someone and rightly so. I have done my power of attorney for health & wealth, there is absolutely no way you will ever have yourself "offed" by this method
No, because it would be my choice and a choice I'd like to make officially when I'm not in that situation, i.e now, and while I'm compos mentis. If I was able to sign a power of attorney to that affect today, I would.
We're not advocating some scumbag nephew signing forms to end his aunts life against her wishes to gain access to her fortune, here. We're talking about heavily regulated consent which is made when you're in full control of your mind.
Posts: 2,182
Threads: 163
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation:
7
11-13-2024, 07:45 AM
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2024, 07:46 AM by Mouse.)
Tough subject.
Up until my daughter was born I was fully supportive of people making their own choice when it comes to dying and in principle I still agree that people should have their own choice. The problem is how and when you get help from others that’s the issue for me.
With hindsight (and genuinely no criticism of the NHS) we as new parents were railroaded into signing a DNR for our daughter without all the facts available to us at the time. We felt we were making the right decision for the right reasons however we did not have all the facts and looking back was driven by the NHS doctors for reason(s) only they know.
Everything worked out and we are not angry or upset with them however the guilt of knowing the choice we made will live with me forever.
Our situation isn’t directly related to assisted dying however the pressures from the medical teams may be the same (especially given the state of the NHS) and my worry is it’ll be used in future for unethical reasons (or reasons not directly related to that person) by outside parties (not just the NHS)
We need more conversations around the logistics of it before I can fully on board with it.
|