Form
#11
Cole has shown some nice touches and looked a handful in his cameos. But I believe it's a bit of stretch to clamber for him to be starting.

Rather than analysing what's going wrong, then we should look at what worked and go back to the XI that started and how we played in the first six games. Injuries permitting.
Reply
#12
I get the point on Johnston but even in his appearances so far he’s not made chances for himself or others. Equally, Grant is playing out of his skin in MJs natural position.

I’m loathed to see Grant move central because of what he’s bringing to the team. When you start moving people around you run the risk of losing what they bring.

Furlong Holgate Heggem Styles
Molumby Mowatt
Maja
Fellows Grant
Cole
Reply
#13
(11-08-2024, 10:12 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: I get the point on Johnston but even in his appearances so far he’s not made chances for himself or others. Equally, Grant is playing out of his skin in MJs natural position.

I’m loathed to see Grant move central because of what he’s bringing to the team. When you start moving people around you run the risk of losing what they bring.

Furlong Holgate Heggem Styles
Molumby Mowatt
Maja
Fellows Grant
Cole

I think our starting 11 last night was our best. Subs wise when chasing a winner/equaliser, maybe stick Grant in front of Maja and replace him at 11 with Mikey or Dobbins. IMO, last night's subs worked, Burnley were on top 2nd half and the subs switched the game in our favour.
Reply
#14
I think we are playing too deep. And that's because we are not controlling midfield and are being pushed back by the opposition.

Personally I would like to see an extra body in midfield, which would probably mean a midfield 3 of Mowatt, Molumby and Racic.

In particular I think Mowatt has been far to deep which is a waste of his talents.

Might be seen as a defensive move playing another midfield at the expense of a creative player, but at the end of the day if you can't give your creative good possession and support, then they are not going to be creative, no matter how many you have on the pitch.
Reply
#15
(11-07-2024, 11:08 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: The thing is with Grant, I think he’s our best player, I’d be so loathed to move him.
Ay, but that same workrate and movement further up field would make him more potent as a goalscoring threat.
Reply
#16
You could have Messi n Pele up front in this set up and they wouldnt score. Theyd never see the ball unless they come in their own half. Swift wont score again cos hes far too deep.
The style and tactics are the problem..end of.
Reply
#17
(11-08-2024, 11:02 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I think we are playing too deep. And that's because we are not controlling midfield and are being pushed back by the opposition.

Personally I would like to see an extra body in midfield, which would probably mean a midfield 3 of Mowatt, Molumby and Racic.

In particular I think Mowatt has been far to deep which is a waste of his talents.

Might be seen as a defensive move playing another midfield at the expense of a creative player, but at the end of the day if you can't give your creative good possession and support, then they are not going to be creative, no matter how many you have on the pitch.

We're not particularly deep in terms of our defensive line, Shabby. But I think you're right about our midfield not controlling the tempo and flow of the game. I have thought for quite a while that our CM if the biggest problem we have and I am still of that opinion. 

Below are the average positions from last night. Our shape is good, the distance between the lines are tight which is generally the sign of a well coached, organised team. But the midfield 2 are abit too square of each other considering the full backs aren't particularly high. That's where we need to get the balance right.

   
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#18
Are they out of form or are the instructions they're given what is holding them back? Fine lines I'd say, especially when you're playing risk averse football and your main focus is on not letting your opponents score... Quelle surprise, your attacking players then look out of form... As they can't play to their strengths...
Reply
#19
(11-08-2024, 10:43 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-08-2024, 10:12 AM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: I get the point on Johnston but even in his appearances so far he’s not made chances for himself or others. Equally, Grant is playing out of his skin in MJs natural position.

I’m loathed to see Grant move central because of what he’s bringing to the team. When you start moving people around you run the risk of losing what they bring.

Furlong Holgate Heggem Styles
Molumby Mowatt
Maja
Fellows Grant
Cole

I think our starting 11 last night was our best. Subs wise when chasing a winner/equaliser, maybe stick Grant in front of Maja and replace him at 11 with Mikey or Dobbins. IMO, last night's subs worked, Burnley were on top 2nd half and the subs switched the game in our favour.

I think there’s a difference between our best 11 and what is working right now. We have to try something slightly different, not root and branch, but we have to get something kick started. I honestly believe one win turns this but I think we have to amend the current 11.

(11-08-2024, 11:02 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I think we are playing too deep. And that's because we are not controlling midfield and are being pushed back by the opposition.

Personally I would like to see an extra body in midfield, which would probably mean a midfield 3 of Mowatt, Molumby and Racic.

In particular I think Mowatt has been far to deep which is a waste of his talents.

Might be seen as a defensive move playing another midfield at the expense of a creative player, but at the end of the day if you can't give your creative good possession and support, then they are not going to be creative, no matter how many you have on the pitch.

I don’t disagree, I just wonder if it’s a lack of form and confidence is resulting in the players dropping deep and playing too safely. 

Carlos was hoarse last night telling them to get up the pitch so I don’t think it’s planned.
Reply
#20
(11-08-2024, 11:53 AM)MrBater Wrote: Are they out of form or are the instructions they're given what is holding them back? Fine lines I'd say, especially when you're playing risk averse football and your main focus is on not letting your opponents score... Quelle surprise, your attacking players then look out of form... As they can't play to their strengths...

If players are regularly getting 7's and 8's in our ratings, then that suggests they are actually looking half decent. Seems we are holding our shape well and are positionally and defensively sound. The fact that we are creating very few chances has to indicate that the set up itself is not quite right, surely?

Grant and Maja are two of our most high ranking players, yet we can't score??

For me the issue is the 10. Swift is dropping so deep, him and Mowatt could share boots, and his passing is sadly lacking. That's not to mention that, when he does get in the box, he regularly finds row z. Diangana is lively and can beat a bloke or buy a foul, but his timing and passing are poor and when he does get in the box, he regularly finds row z. Both are regularly rated 6 or below.

Sure, we could try MJ, Cole, Dobbins or Wallace in the 10, but would we really expect anything to change?

For me it has to be a formation change, even if temporarily, just to try and get some goals and build confidence.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: