Budget nonsense
#1
I have never ever seen and heard so much bullshit talked about the economy over the last couple of days since Brexit. Especially the pantwetting from outlets such as the Mail and the Times. As some of you may know, I am a Prof in Economics.

I keep hearing crap, like you can't tax yourself to growth; talk of doom loops from high tax, leading to low growth leading to higher taxes. 

Equally , I could set up other doom loop scenarios... Low spending, means an unhealthy and uneducated workforce, which leads to low growth.. and so on.

The reality is, the key determinant of growth is not the tax rate or the amount of spending. Yes they are important, but the key driver is technological change and innovation (political stability and strong institutions helps as well - which we now have). This is usually a function of the State and private business working together. E.g. most of the components of an iPhone started out in a publicly funded research lab.

There are crazy people on X going on about relatively small increases in bond yields. This is exactly what one would expect if the government is going to engage in more borrowing. Furthermore, we have a big election next week, where a fascist could be elected as President of the US. It is no wonder the markets are getting nervous given the fact he has suggested a drastic change in the US tax code that may result in a trade war and a huge increase in trade tariffs.

Inflation has fallen considerably - to be fair on Sunak and Hunt, they did at least do a decent job of leaving the inflation fighting to the BoE and keeping out of the way. Inflation now looks like it's on a stable path and rates should begin to fall. That will likely lead to lower rates on gilts. 

The Labour Party has a lot of mess to clear up. This budget event is the first step. The next step.. industrial strategy etc, higher capital spending will be critical. That is the future. The Labour government will be judged on that in 5 years time. At least they are trying to do something with the economy. The last shambolic government had no idea whatsoever. They were more focused on sending people off on boats to Rwanda and bleating about immigration, which paradoxically has generated much of the growth we have had since Brexit. They were an English nationalist government, and as well all know, nationalists are never good for an economy over a sustained period of time.

As a society, we have to face up to the fact that our population is ageing. You can't have low taxes and 1st class public services at the same time. If you want low taxes, then healthcare will have to be (at least partially) privatized. If you want 1st class public services, then taxes have to go up to pay for it. Most people in the UK do not want private health care, so I see no other solution.

One hopes that the AI revolution will provide the historical rates of productivity growth that we used to have before the GFC. If that doesn't happen, then the country will have to choose: private healthcare or public healthcare. The former will make us more like the US, the latter will make us more like the EU. At the moment we are in between both and that is not a good place to be.

Politicians from both sides also need to start levelling with the British people and say it how it is. To be fair to Reeves, she at least said straight away that she has made a tough choice and she has designed much better fiscal rules for the future that should benefit either party after the next election. It was bold thing to do, so time will tell if it pays off.
Reply
#2
"Especially the pantwetting from outlets such as the Mail and the Times."

Then proselytized by KKC and Proth.

And, now that they have been proven totally wrong, they have misremembered all the tosh that they came out with since June. They now have 2026/7 shrouds in the air.I

Perhaps they could consider learning from you - someone who actually knows what they are talking about? Beats repeating shite from the Mail and thick as mince WhatsApp groups.
Reply
#3
(11-01-2024, 01:01 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I have never ever seen and heard so much bullshit talked about the economy over the last couple of days since Brexit. Especially the pantwetting from outlets such as the Mail and the Times. As some of you may know, I am a Prof in Economics.

I keep hearing crap, like you can't tax yourself to growth; talk of doom loops from high tax, leading to low growth leading to higher taxes. 

Equally , I could set up other doom loop scenarios... Low spending, means an unhealthy and uneducated workforce, which leads to low growth.. and so on.

The reality is, the key determinant of growth is not the tax rate or the amount of spending. Yes they are important, but the key driver is technological change and innovation (political stability and strong institutions helps as well - which we now have). This is usually a function of the State and private business working together. E.g. most of the components of an iPhone started out in a publically funded research lab.

There are crazy people on X going on about relatively small increases in bond yields. This is exactly what one would expect if the government is going to engage in more borrowing. Furthermore, we have a big election next week, where a fascist could be elected as President of the US. It is no wonder the markets are getting nervous given the fact he has suggested a drastic change in the US tax code that may result in a trade war and a huge increase in trade tariffs.

Inflation has fallen considerably - to be fair on Sunak and Hunt, they did at least do a decent job of leaving the inflation fighting to the BoE and keeping out of the way. Inflation now looks like it's on a stable path and rates should begin to fall. That will likely lead to lower rates on gilts. 

The Labour Party has a lot of mess to clear up. This budget event is the first step. The next step.. industrial strategy etc, higher capital spending will be critical. That is the future. The Labour government will be judged on that in 5 years time. At least they are trying to do something with the economy. The last shambolic government had no idea whatsoever. They were more focused on sending people off on boats to Rwanda and bleating about immigration, which paradoxically has generated much of the growth we have had since Brexit. They were an English nationalist government, and as well all know, nationalists are never good for an economy over a sustained period of time.

As a society, we have to face up to the fact that our population is ageing. You can't have low taxes and 1st class public services at the same time. If you want low taxes, then healthcare will have to be (at least partially) privatized. If you want 1st class public services, then taxes have to go up to pay for it. Most people in the UK do not want private health care, so I see no other solution.

One hopes that the AI revolution will provide the historical rates of productivity growth that we used to have before the GFC. If that doesn't happen, then the country will have to choose: private healthcare or public healthcare. The former will make us more like the US, the latter will make us more like the EU. At the moment we are in between both and that is not a good place to be.

Politicians from both sides also need to start levelling with the British people and say it how it is. To be fair to Reeves, she at least said straight away that she has made a tough choice and she has designed much better fiscal rules for the future that should benefit either party after the next election. It was bold thing to do, so time will tell if it pays off.

I don't disagree with much of this. I'm just not seeing any evidence though of the next incompetent lot (following the previous incompetent lot) to deliver.

Too many assumptions on income and tax growth, when the reality is the Employers NI is going to drive a "blip" in inflation, and as a consequence Interest rates. I can see there being a gap in income when tax revenue is behind forecast. Not even the OBR are on-board with it fully.

(11-01-2024, 01:08 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: "Especially the pantwetting from outlets such as the Mail and the Times."

Then proselytized by KKC and Proth.

And, now that they have been proven totally wrong, they have misremembered all the tosh that they came out with since June. They now have 2026/7 shrouds in the air.I

Perhaps they could consider learning from you - someone who actually knows what they are talking about? Beats repeating shite from the Mail and thick as mince WhatsApp groups.

This is a grown up chat. I think you should stay out of it.
Reply
#4
(11-01-2024, 01:01 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I keep hearing crap, like you can't tax yourself to growth; talk of doom loops from high tax, leading to low growth leading to higher taxes. 

I'd be delighted to hear why that contention is "crap" when I spent last night with another economics professor who who suggested that the only way the economy will grow at the rate Labour needs it to grow without the need for further tax rises will be.....luck.

Though of course I agree with you about the need to raise vast amounts of money if people want the actual services they say they do (though they only want to pay £10 extra per week in tax according to one survey!). I'd be interested to hear your views on our tax base as well, which appears to be rather dependent on not many taxpayers.
Reply
#5
(11-01-2024, 01:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 01:01 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I have never ever seen and heard so much bullshit talked about the economy over the last couple of days since Brexit. Especially the pantwetting from outlets such as the Mail and the Times. As some of you may know, I am a Prof in Economics.

I keep hearing crap, like you can't tax yourself to growth; talk of doom loops from high tax, leading to low growth leading to higher taxes. 

Equally , I could set up other doom loop scenarios... Low spending, means an unhealthy and uneducated workforce, which leads to low growth.. and so on.

The reality is, the key determinant of growth is not the tax rate or the amount of spending. Yes they are important, but the key driver is technological change and innovation (political stability and strong institutions helps as well - which we now have). This is usually a function of the State and private business working together. E.g. most of the components of an iPhone started out in a publically funded research lab.

There are crazy people on X going on about relatively small increases in bond yields. This is exactly what one would expect if the government is going to engage in more borrowing. Furthermore, we have a big election next week, where a fascist could be elected as President of the US. It is no wonder the markets are getting nervous given the fact he has suggested a drastic change in the US tax code that may result in a trade war and a huge increase in trade tariffs.

Inflation has fallen considerably - to be fair on Sunak and Hunt, they did at least do a decent job of leaving the inflation fighting to the BoE and keeping out of the way. Inflation now looks like it's on a stable path and rates should begin to fall. That will likely lead to lower rates on gilts. 

The Labour Party has a lot of mess to clear up. This budget event is the first step. The next step.. industrial strategy etc, higher capital spending will be critical. That is the future. The Labour government will be judged on that in 5 years time. At least they are trying to do something with the economy. The last shambolic government had no idea whatsoever. They were more focused on sending people off on boats to Rwanda and bleating about immigration, which paradoxically has generated much of the growth we have had since Brexit. They were an English nationalist government, and as well all know, nationalists are never good for an economy over a sustained period of time.

As a society, we have to face up to the fact that our population is ageing. You can't have low taxes and 1st class public services at the same time. If you want low taxes, then healthcare will have to be (at least partially) privatized. If you want 1st class public services, then taxes have to go up to pay for it. Most people in the UK do not want private health care, so I see no other solution.

One hopes that the AI revolution will provide the historical rates of productivity growth that we used to have before the GFC. If that doesn't happen, then the country will have to choose: private healthcare or public healthcare. The former will make us more like the US, the latter will make us more like the EU. At the moment we are in between both and that is not a good place to be.

Politicians from both sides also need to start levelling with the British people and say it how it is. To be fair to Reeves, she at least said straight away that she has made a tough choice and she has designed much better fiscal rules for the future that should benefit either party after the next election. It was bold thing to do, so time will tell if it pays off.

I don't disagree with much of this. I'm just not seeing any evidence though of the next incompetent lot (following the previous incompetent lot) to deliver.

Too many assumptions on income and tax growth, when the reality is the Employers NI is going to drive a "blip" in inflation, and as a consequence Interest rates. I can see there being a gap in income when tax revenue is behind forecast. Not even the OBR are on-board with it fully.

(11-01-2024, 01:08 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: "Especially the pantwetting from outlets such as the Mail and the Times."

Then proselytized by KKC and Proth.

And, now that they have been proven totally wrong, they have misremembered all the tosh that they came out with since June. They now have 2026/7 shrouds in the air.I

Perhaps they could consider learning from you - someone who actually knows what they are talking about? Beats repeating shite from the Mail and thick as mince WhatsApp groups.

This is a grown up chat. I think you should stay out of it.
What if the increase in taxes on employment, leads to firms substituting away from labour to capital? Perhaps stimulating investment instead of relying on cheap labour? This has not been mentioned by anyone. Small business is exempted from much of the changes. Is it not right that private bigger business contributes to health and education and the country's defence? If we have a private health system, would that not have to be financed from employers like in the US? Is a healthier population and kids being educated in schools not falling down in the private sectors interest?

Under the previous government the tax take went from 37% of GDP to 38%. This government plans to increase it to 39%. There are many countries that have a higher tax take than us and have much better living standards. If you have an ageing population, perhaps it is optimal to have higher taxes.
Reply
#6
Move over to the grown up chat about fake royal children Corner Shop. It’s high brow and credible.
Reply
#7
(11-01-2024, 01:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 01:01 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I keep hearing crap, like you can't tax yourself to growth; talk of doom loops from high tax, leading to low growth leading to higher taxes. 

I'd be delighted to hear why that contention is "crap" when I spent last night with another economics professor who who suggested that the only way the economy will grow at the rate Labour needs it to grow without the need for further tax rises will be.....luck.

Though of course I agree with you about the need to raise vast amounts of money if people want the actual services they say they do (though they only want to pay £10 extra per week in tax according to one survey!). I'd be interested to hear your views on our tax base as well, which appears to be rather dependent on not many taxpayers.
I agree with him or her. Perhaps AI will provide the luck like that North sea oil did for Thatcher in the past. 

Perhaps taxes will have to rise again but there is no reason to suppose that tax rises will be detrimental to growth. Perhaps it is optimal to have higher taxes? Perhaps a healthier nation will get inactive people back in to work?

PS: I am bearing a substantial burden from these tax increases but that's the price I'm prepared to pay for a better society.
Reply
#8
(11-01-2024, 01:29 PM)Logic1 Wrote: What if the increase in taxes on employment, leads to firms substituting away from labour to capital? Perhaps stimulating investment instead of relying on cheap labour? This has not been mentioned by anyone. 

It's been mentioned by me since 2008. Since the GFC wage suppression has enabled plenty of moribund firms barely making a margin to stay in business on the back of cheap (and formerly plentiful Labour), and just about servicing their debt.

Given that even Labour considers mass immigration to be unacceptable these days (apparently) then it's a plan of sorts. Unfortunately, as was pointed out to me last night - too many British businesses essentially spend their time selling "coffee" to each other - which makes the substitution of capital and / or higher skills / wages unlikely.
Reply
#9
(11-01-2024, 01:29 PM)Logic1 Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 01:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 01:01 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I have never ever seen and heard so much bullshit talked about the economy over the last couple of days since Brexit. Especially the pantwetting from outlets such as the Mail and the Times. As some of you may know, I am a Prof in Economics.

I keep hearing crap, like you can't tax yourself to growth; talk of doom loops from high tax, leading to low growth leading to higher taxes. 

Equally , I could set up other doom loop scenarios... Low spending, means an unhealthy and uneducated workforce, which leads to low growth.. and so on.

The reality is, the key determinant of growth is not the tax rate or the amount of spending. Yes they are important, but the key driver is technological change and innovation (political stability and strong institutions helps as well - which we now have). This is usually a function of the State and private business working together. E.g. most of the components of an iPhone started out in a publically funded research lab.

There are crazy people on X going on about relatively small increases in bond yields. This is exactly what one would expect if the government is going to engage in more borrowing. Furthermore, we have a big election next week, where a fascist could be elected as President of the US. It is no wonder the markets are getting nervous given the fact he has suggested a drastic change in the US tax code that may result in a trade war and a huge increase in trade tariffs.

Inflation has fallen considerably - to be fair on Sunak and Hunt, they did at least do a decent job of leaving the inflation fighting to the BoE and keeping out of the way. Inflation now looks like it's on a stable path and rates should begin to fall. That will likely lead to lower rates on gilts. 

The Labour Party has a lot of mess to clear up. This budget event is the first step. The next step.. industrial strategy etc, higher capital spending will be critical. That is the future. The Labour government will be judged on that in 5 years time. At least they are trying to do something with the economy. The last shambolic government had no idea whatsoever. They were more focused on sending people off on boats to Rwanda and bleating about immigration, which paradoxically has generated much of the growth we have had since Brexit. They were an English nationalist government, and as well all know, nationalists are never good for an economy over a sustained period of time.

As a society, we have to face up to the fact that our population is ageing. You can't have low taxes and 1st class public services at the same time. If you want low taxes, then healthcare will have to be (at least partially) privatized. If you want 1st class public services, then taxes have to go up to pay for it. Most people in the UK do not want private health care, so I see no other solution.

One hopes that the AI revolution will provide the historical rates of productivity growth that we used to have before the GFC. If that doesn't happen, then the country will have to choose: private healthcare or public healthcare. The former will make us more like the US, the latter will make us more like the EU. At the moment we are in between both and that is not a good place to be.

Politicians from both sides also need to start levelling with the British people and say it how it is. To be fair to Reeves, she at least said straight away that she has made a tough choice and she has designed much better fiscal rules for the future that should benefit either party after the next election. It was bold thing to do, so time will tell if it pays off.

I don't disagree with much of this. I'm just not seeing any evidence though of the next incompetent lot (following the previous incompetent lot) to deliver.

Too many assumptions on income and tax growth, when the reality is the Employers NI is going to drive a "blip" in inflation, and as a consequence Interest rates. I can see there being a gap in income when tax revenue is behind forecast. Not even the OBR are on-board with it fully.

(11-01-2024, 01:08 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: "Especially the pantwetting from outlets such as the Mail and the Times."

Then proselytized by KKC and Proth.

And, now that they have been proven totally wrong, they have misremembered all the tosh that they came out with since June. They now have 2026/7 shrouds in the air.I

Perhaps they could consider learning from you - someone who actually knows what they are talking about? Beats repeating shite from the Mail and thick as mince WhatsApp groups.

This is a grown up chat. I think you should stay out of it.
What if the increase in taxes on employment, leads to firms substituting away from labour to capital? Perhaps stimulating investment instead of relying on cheap labour? This has not been mentioned by anyone. Small business is exempted from much of the changes. Is it not right that private bigger business contributes to health and education and the country's defence? If we have a private health system, would that not have to be financed from employers like in the US? Is a healthier population and kids being educated in schools not falling down in the private sectors interest?

Under the previous government the tax take went from 37% of GDP to 38%. This government plans to increase it to 39%. There are many countries that have a higher tax take than us and have much better living standards. If you have an ageing population, perhaps it is optimal to have higher taxes.

What do you call a small business? The Employment Allowance on NI means broadly less than 5 people.

Why should businesses of 5-100 carry the burden? Here in the real world (I advise on finance) I can tell you that those businesses are working on such fine margins that they can't afford these rises. They cannot afford to borrow to invest - the banks won't lend them the money because their margins are too thin, and they can't service the borrowing with the present interest rates - which are being prolonged by this budget.

That's the real world that my clients live in - not a Labour cabinet where not a single person has ever run a business in their lives, and live in a hypothetical world.
Reply
#10
(11-01-2024, 01:34 PM)Logic1 Wrote: Perhaps taxes will have to rise again but there is no reason to suppose that tax rises will be detrimental to growth. 

Hmm. Let's look back at that in a couple of years.

Be very interested to hear your view on the tax base - IMO it's nowhere near broad enough if the electorate wants the services it says it does.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)